Nearly forty years ago anthropologist Clifford Geertz wrote in Islam Observed that “what a given religion is—its specific content—is embodied in the images and metaphors its adherents use to characterize reality; it makes a great deal of difference whether you call life a dream, a pilgrimage, a labyrinth, or a carnival. However, such a religion's career—its historical course—rests in turn upon the institutions which render these images and metaphors available to those who thus employ them.” These two volumes illustrate the interplay between content and career both for Muslim collectives and for the scholarly communities that study them. The trope of the public sphere (along with its intellectual sibling, civil society) and that of the network have enjoyed wide popularity in social analysis over the last decade and a half, the first because of the fall of Communism and subsequent governments, nongovernmental organizations, and foundation investment in democratization, and the second because of improved mathematical techniques applied to the vast body of empirical data provided by the Internet. What sort of difference does it make whether we approach communicative action within the umma as taking place within or constituting public spheres, or networks? What difference does it make if we draw our analytical metaphors and images of the geometry of social life from the world of political philosophy or from mathematics?
Salvatore and LeVine define public spheres as arenas “where official, state-sponsored discourses are both challenged and carried to the wider public by … socioreligious actors” negotiating understandings of obligations, rights, justice, and the common good (p. 3). But given “the irony of a public sphere based on accessibility and rationality, but factually deployed as a primary strategy of distinction and exclusion” (p. 5) against women, minorities, and other populations, multiple “alternative parallel public spheres” may operate simultaneously, the sites for the formation of social identities as well as discursive opinion (p. 14). In two chapters the editors lay out genealogies of the concepts of public sphere and civil society in various liberal, Marxist, and Foucauldian versions. Their main contention is that Muslim public spheres, like those nurtured by other religious movements, legitimize particular forms of political community in ways that are not bound “by the strictures of liberal norms of publicness premised on atomistic views of the social agent and contractually based notions of trust, by a strict interpretation of the dichotomy between private and public spheres, and by the ultimate basing of public reason on private interest” (p. 30). Instead, they base their actions on a particular sort of practical reason sanctified by religious tradition (pp. 18, 30). Setrag Menoukian, refining these distinctions, argues that the correlate quality of publicness is not privacy but secrecy (p. 59), and investigates how technologies of presentation like photographs and diagrams structure the commitment of individuals to broader social interests, and how techniques of transforming the self toward that end came to be matters of open concern in 20th-century Iran.
The nature of Islamic publicness is investigated further in chapters by Raymond William Baker and Dyala Hamza. Baker writes optimistically of the wasaṭiyya, a diverse and vital “transnational Islamic mainstream” of intellectuals who “reassert the necessity of a creative and collective ijtihād … in the interest of the maṣlaḥa ʿāmma [the common good]” (p. 111). Baker labels this centrist “new Islamism” a complex adaptive system, a nontotalizing networked structure that nevertheless acts as a “difficult whole” in the context of the weakening and collapse of old social and intellectual structures (pp. 118–19). In her far more focused analysis of the Egyptian press, Hamza takes issue with the transnational nature of such difficult wholes as “Arab public opinion,” or “public interest.” She argues that even as the lines between journalistic and theological discourse have blurred, “invocations of a transcendent order are subsumed under the national interest” of particular writers (p. 191), and secularists lose the ability or the will to challenge religious discourse. The busy but limited discussion of the “transnationalist icon” of the suicide bomber points to “the existence of layers of public discourse that never intersect each other rather than to a dialectic public sphere” (p. 199). Far from constituting a basis for political action, the discourse of the Egyptian press, even as it portrays itself as emblematic of wider Arab opinion, constitutes a “symbolic substitute for action” (p. 201).
Baudouin Dupret and Jean-Noel Ferrie write that such fragmentation is to be expected, as the very idea of a stable Islamic public sphere is a fantasy. The distinction between public and private spheres is always contingent. Both morality and the domain of the private are public objects dependent on language and practice, so that the consciousness of particular actors, rather than structural contexts or hegemonic contests, are what mark public actions as Islamic. Muhammad Khalid Masud's fine analysis of the social construction of shariʿa in Pakistan highlights the plurality of voices working to define issues of public good, authority, and legitimacy. In Pakistan the state has been an important source of both progressive and fundamentalist legal ordinances around and against which various interest groups have mobilized. The difficulty is that in the proliferation of private media “each group was talking to its own members” rather than to each other, so that distinctly different constructions of shariʿa struggled for normativity without a majority finding any particular construction suitable to their interests (pp. 174–77). Brinkley Messick's chapter on the genesis of a private Yemeni legal periodical shows how understandings of the sources and practice of law have been transformed, with law itself becoming an issue of public interest and engagement. The public sphere and civil society as concepts in global circulation mean that local professionals come to employ them consciously in pursuing their political agendas (p. 226).
The network metaphor has different political correlates, in part because although public spheres have both participants and audiences, networks have only participants. “Networks,” write Cooke and Lawrence, are “phenomena that are similar to institutionalized social relations, such as tribal affiliations and political dynasties, but also distinct from them, because to be networked entails making a choice to be connected across recognized boundaries” (p. 1). Networks may span both space and time, including the networks forged in pilgrimage, long-distance trade networks, Sufi and scholarly discipleship, and the transcontinental flows of language and culture. We can identify networks in times and places where the notion of public spheres and civil societies might be anachronistic, as with Vincent Cornell's enlightening examination of the medieval traveler Ibn Battuta and the way his own private interests were served, not through entering into public discourse about public good but by attaching himself to local rulers and serving their dynastic interests while avoiding their wrath. However, as the editors argue, “A networked epistemology pluralizes individuals. It allows them multiple contexts where no one identity predominates and none can be reified” (p. 27–28). The notion of private interest or even public identity, once apparently so solid, melts into air.
David Gilmartin points out that the idea of Islamdom as a networked civilization was articulated as early as the middle 1970s by Ira Lapidus. Gilmartin's own chapter on Pakistan can be usefully compared to Masud's, tracing the bewildering complexity of that country's institutional and cultural transformation during the 20th century as ʿulamaء entered the public realm to define a sense of moral community separate from the colonial state and from other sets of local ties, a sense of “a community defined by the moral standing and commitments of individual Muslims” (p. 59) whose primary duty is to protect the symbols of religion (p. 66). Personal commitments to Islamic values and symbols structured either by existing social networks defined by class (Samia Serageldin on elite women's salons in Cairo) or by more ephemeral personal networks forged through media production and consumption, conference attendance, and the desire both to acknowledge and to move beyond gender and ethnic hierarchies (Jamillah Karim on an American Muslim women's magazine and H. Samy Alim on hip hop), provide the focus for several chapters.
Islamic symbols and values, like individual identities, change as they move through social and technological networks. From the entry of Orientalist scholarship into the Muslim consciousness (the Islamization or “religionization” of Islam, in Carl Ernst's phrase) (p. 191) to its development as an Internet presence since the 1990s, modes of discourse, patterns of authority, and populations involved in cultural production and debate have both fragmented and homogenized the tradition. Judith Ernst questions the very category of Islamic art in the face of the multiconfessional identities of its producers and the relentless cosmopolitanism of working Muslim visual artists who—like musicians—constantly appropriate styles and techniques from other artistic traditions. Carl Ernst analyzes the curious publication of formerly esoteric Sufi teachings through print, music, and other media until it hardly appears connected to Islam. This new, globalized pop-star Sufism nevertheless inspires young Muslims whose parents rejected its precursors as backward superstition. Gary Bunt explores the Muslim networks inhabiting the space that is not space of the Internet. Real-world processes of social network building, ideological conflict, vandalism, and even forced migration are transferred to and replicated in web interactions. Jon Anderson points out that in the Web's multiple intersections, “Boundaries between diaspora and homeland populations are blurred, while those between the Internet's favored demographic of middle-class professionals and others sharpen” (p. 261), which in turn affects the curricula of religious schools, the nature of relationships between laymen and religious scholars, and other living social relationships and institutions.
The chapters in Cooke and Lawrence addressing the institutional roles and networks of religious scholars and activists are perhaps the most conventionally “Islamic.” Muhammad Qasim Zaman provides a sophisticated argument about how the language of the ʿulamaء, once having allowed Ibn Battuta to work as a qadi in places as distant from his native Morocco as Delhi and the Maldives, is changing in response to the entry of lay intellectuals into religious argumentation and about the moral difficulties posed by discursive difference and attempts to overcome it. Quintan Wiktorowicz examines reformist and militant Salafi Islam, looking at how common understandings of sacred text are complicated by different interpretations of how best to generate moral and political transformation and how Salafi networks and organizations developed, changed, and helped to drive political crises from Algeria to Afghanistan over the last three decades. In one of the most useful chapters in the collection, Charles Kurzman provides both a capsule summary of some of the technical elements of sociological network theory and a fascinating systematic perspective on how Iran's mosque networks were transformed in the course of the Iranian Revolution from strongholds of conservatism to platforms for radical mobilization. His case study, more than any of the others, demonstrates the unique qualities of the network metaphor in performing particular kinds of social analysis.
Although the public sphere and civil society clearly are normative concepts, as arenas in which the nature and balance of public good and private interest are created and negotiated, the concept of network is more labile. Criminals, for example, or Wiktorowicz's Salafi jihadists, may be said to have networks, but it is more difficult to speak of a criminal public sphere. Geertz aside, what the practical analytical differences between concepts might be is not always clear in most of the contributions to these two volumes. This is illustrated nicely by the fact that both collections contain articles on Shiʿi women's majlis al-qirāya ceremonies, rituals of remembrance and mourning for the suffering and death of members of the Prophet's family at Karbala. In Salvatore and LeVine, Lara Deeb writes of the importance of Husayn's sister Zaynab for women involved in social work with local religious organizations in southern Lebanon. In Cooke and Lawrence, Tayba Hassan al Khalifa Sharif writes about how Zaynab's suffering and strength models that of Iraqi refugee women in the Netherlands. In fact, the analytical tropes of the two chapters, public sphere and network, could well be exchanged without doing violence either to the case studies or the concepts. Sharif writes of the majlis as “the safest place for speaking of forbidden subjects in authoritarian Iraq” (p. 147), a small-scale public sphere in which the stories of Zaynab's and Husayn's suffering, but not that of their own lives, triggered tears, the perfect illustration of the hegemonic techniques of the self cultivated within and required by interactions within the religious traditions and civil societies discussed by Salvatore and LeVine (pp. 15, 33, 37, 44–45). Likewise, Deeb's demonstration of the new emphasis on volunteer work among Lebanese women might just as well be framed as a network analysis, showing how class and ethnicity interacted with geography and historical events to reconfigure traditional ʿAshuraء rituals as means of mobilizing women, “shifting the meaning from one of personal mourning and regret to a revolutionary lesson” (p. 92) in which Zaynab is a model of social and political action despite personal grief and turmoil (p. 94). Volunteer work among needy families and children, impossible for male volunteers, becomes a marker of female morality as well as modernity within the broader world of international aid organizations.
It is here also, with what Salvatore and LeVine would call an “alternative parallel public sphere” of women, that the main shortcoming of both these volumes becomes apparent. Despite gestures to alternate modalities of public reasoning and the recognition that public–private distinctions and liberal notions of the atomistic individual are problematic, both collections nevertheless treat the individual coming to the public sphere, or the individual member of a network, as a person without family. Neither collection has any sustained discussion of the role of kinship groups within civil society and the public sphere or family as a kind of network relevant to either political or religious change. This seems particularly odd given the importance of family in the ideologies of Islamic activists and the everyday practices of most living Muslims. As Diane Singerman and others have long pointed out—for recent examples, see the Winter and Spring 2006 issues of the Journal of Middle East Women's Studies—both family concerns and families as social networks and resources are vital to the political, economic, social, and religious activities of most individuals—male and female—in the region. It is not enough to acknowledge the growing role of women in Muslim networks and public spheres; we must begin to acknowledge that the “self” interests of both women and men encompass others as well, complicating the nature of networked civilization and the negotiations over hegemony taking place in the public sphere.
Aside from this, both collections are important and thought provoking. They speak to each other and to broader social theory and area studies concerns in multiple ways. Stylistically, although Salvatore and LeVine's collection is appropriate for graduate seminars, Cooke and Lawrence's volume is more immediately engaging and far better suited for a general or undergraduate audience.
