The Resilience of the Latin American Right is a superb contribution to the study of comparative politics in Latin America. In a very strong analytical introduction, editors Juan Pablo Luna and Cristóbal Rovira Kaltwasser note that although the resurgence of the left has attracted considerable attention, it would be premature to conclude that the right is a spent political force. In many ways the right remains an influential political actor. In addition to building parties, the right can organise electoral movements or seek influence outside the electoral arena (p. 2).
What is the right? According to Luna and Rovira Kaltwasser, the right is constituted by a specific ideological position on inequality: ‘we define the right as a political position distinguished by the belief that the main inequalities between people are natural and outside the purview of the state’. The left believes ‘that the main inequalities between people are artificial and should therefore be counteracted by active state involvement’ (p. 4). Definitions are neither correct nor incorrect, of course, but only more or less useful. In this case, the utility of the definition is that it situates the subject within a larger debate on inequality in Latin America.
According to Luna and Rovira Kaltwasser (p. 10), predictions based on the median voter theorem suggest that redistribution from rich to poor should occur in countries with a highly unequal distribution of income, and that those with greater assets tend to be more hostile to democracy. In Latin America, where high inequality and democratic politics have long coexisted, these models generate misleading expectations. The ability of the right to protect the economic interests of those who benefit from inequality provides part of the explanation. Even with left-wing governments in office throughout the region, the right can still influence the degree to which redistributive policies are used to reduce inequality.
Following the introduction, two chapters provide an overview of the contemporary context. Kenneth M. Roberts argues that political competition in the region ‘revolves around programmatic distinctions between leftist and rightist alternatives that are ultimately grounded in redistributive conflicts. As the defender of minority elite interests opposed to redistributive policies, the right is at an inherent disadvantage …’ (p. 43). Nevertheless, the right has substantial de facto powers to block reform, as well as political resources to mobilise constituencies that cut across distributive conflicts. Security, for example, and specifically the need for mano dura or hardline security policies, is one of the issues the right seeks to own, and crime is an issue of concern to most voters. In their profile of the Latin American electorate, Nina Wiesehomeier and David Doyle note that ‘those on the right are far more authoritarian in their attitudes toward the exercise of powers, particularly with respect to the valence of issues such as crime and public security’ (p. 56). Nonetheless, one can find support for hardline policies across the ideological spectrum (pp. 55–6).
The remainder of the book is divided into three sections. The first deals with the non-electoral right. Kent Eaton discusses non-partisan and non-electoral strategies by the right that target the state, civil society, or seek to influence identity formation; James D. Bowen examines right-wing civil society movements in Ecuador and Bolivia; James Loxton looks at how the right may draw on resources inherited from authoritarian regimes, such as clientelistic networks, organisations, privileged relations with business, party brands and sources of cohesion. The next section of the book examines the electoral, non-partisan right. Rovira Kaltwasser examines right-wing populism; Carlos Meléndez discusses the fate of the right in the Andes following the collapse of party systems; and Laura Wills-Otero discusses the persistence of the right in the context of the exclusion of the left in Colombia. The chapters in the final section deal with the partisan right, including contributions from Steven T. Wuhs (Mexico's PAN); Peter M. Siavelis (Chile's ‘two rights’); Riitta-Ilona Koivumaeki (ARENA in El Salvador); Alfred P. Montero (Brazil's right); and Sergio Morresi and Gabriel Vommaro (‘Propuesta Republicana’ in Argentina).
Many of these chapters strongly reinforce the overall message of the book. For example, the right is powerful in Colombia despite high levels of income inequality because, according to Wills-Otero, the long-standing violent conflict between the government and the guerrillas has decreased electoral opportunities for the left and increased the salience of public security. Meléndez's discussion of Fujimorismo in Peru offers an example of how an emphasis on public security can contribute to the survival of the right in another country that has experienced the trauma of internal conflict. Montero argues that inequality has provided the basis for the power of the Brazilian right, which rests on clientelistic networks at the subnational level. These arguments, and others, lend credence to the concluding words of the editors: ‘one of the key arguments of this book is that it is simply wrong to take for granted that the median voter in Latin America favours socioeconomic distribution … future studies should analyse which factors hinder the framing of inequality and redistribution (relative to other alternative issues) as a central cleavage for political debate and policy making’ (p. 362).
In summary, The Resilience of the Latin American Right is highly recommended not only for scholars interested in the Latin American Right but for anyone interested in democratic politics and inequality in the region. It will be an important reference for future debates and research.
