Palestinians in Syria is a well-researched, timely contribution to scholarship on refugees, memory, and the nakba. The work enhances our understanding of the construction of a national community in exile through the intergenerational transmission of loss and dispossession. It comes at a moment when the Palestinian community in Syria is facing further displacement as a result of the ongoing civil war. Anaheed Al-Hardan examines the ways in which the unique experience of Palestinians in Syria created a community that was integrated in Syrian life, yet maintained the status of refugee under the supervision of The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA). At the same time the Palestinian refugees remained committed to the Palestinian national liberation movement. Yet, the shifting intellectual, collective, and national meaning of the nakba remains the background against which Al-Hardan illustrates how loss and dispossession are experienced across generations. The book examines how and why Palestinians in Syria continue to view their lives through the prism of dislocation more than sixty years after their initial forced removal from historic Palestine. While Al-Hardan's contribution is valuable for merely enhancing the sparse literature on Palestinians in Syria and augmenting nascent nakba studies, it also enriches the scholarship on memory and history, narrating the self, and community construction among refugees.
Al-Hardan does an excellent job examining the Arab intellectual origins of the nakba, tracing its evolution as a pan-Arab nationalist discourse and its eventual appropriation by the Palestinian national movement. She concisely demonstrates how over the years the events of 1948 have been revisited by successive generations of Arab and Palestinian intellectuals and political activists for how these events continue to inform the present. The revival of interest in nakba stories among Palestinians in Syria increased significantly after the signing of the Oslo Accords in 1993 and fueled the emergence of the Right of Return movement. Al-Hardan is at her best when she analyzes the ways in which the nakba has been reinterpreted by ordinary Palestinians as a means of maintaining a sense of community after almost seventy years in exile and with no end in sight. By illustrating the Nakba's “universe of discourse” (p. 27), she not only subverts traditional scholarship on the nakba by engaging with Arab writings rather than privileging Western sources (p. xiv), but demonstrates its implication for ordinary Palestinians. This is where she deftly provides concrete examples for how national events impact and redefine quotidian experiences among ordinary Palestinians whose voices are often muted in official historical accounts. While Al-Hardan is quick to note that the traumatic events of 1948 were far from forgotten, it is the absence of a just solution to the plight of refugees that obliges each generation of Palestinians born in exile to affix their own understanding of displacement and dispossession as they attempt to maintain an affiliation to a “homeland” they have never seen (p. 49). Al-Hardan is most perceptive of how personalized the nakba becomes over time for Palestinian refugees who mourn the loss of the national homeland, and on a more intimate level their villages, land, trees, and communities. Yet the nakba and its narratives are not without controversy. As she notes, the controversy surrounding the survivors of 1948 is apparent in how they have been defined. Recently they have earned the appellation the “generation of Palestine” to replace the earlier, rather disparaging moniker the “generation of defeat” (p. 97). Al-Hardan opts for a less politicized term “guardians of memory” to underscore the importance of these memories for maintaining communal solidarity in the climate of political uncertainty and fear following Oslo (p. 98). Nonetheless, she does not shy away from discussing the contention surrounding the perception among Palestinian descendents that their parents and grandparents were somehow complicit in their own displacement from Palestine (p. 178).
Al-Hardan aptly establishes how memory and recollection are political and social processes and critically engages with the literature on memory and history, pushing it beyond its Eurocentric focus (p. 5). She is cognizant of the dialectics between collective and personal memory in her extensive research on the narratives of loss. In tracing the transmission of stories across generations she is not interested merely in the stories of dispossession and displacement but how these stories “circulate, not in a social vacuum, but against the backdrop of the six-decade-old Arab nationalist and later Palestinian patriotic discourse” (p. 49). She is also attentive to the gendered differences in narratives of the nakba, highlighting the essential role of grandmothers in keeping the memory of a Palestinian homeland vivid among the generations born and reared in exile. While she mentions the hesitation and refusal of some guardians of memory to narrate, she does not dwell on the reasons. Nor does she fully address the reticence of some parents who refuse to pass down their memories to their descendents. Moreover, and while she expounds on what the narratives tell us, she does not engage with the silence in these stories. Al-Hardan could have taken this opportunity to engage with the fascinating work on political trauma and testimony studies, especially the literature on the efficacy of testimony by survivors of political violence, genocide, and the Holocaust.
Nonetheless, Al-Hardan has written an excellent study that is among the first to critically engage with the scholarship on identity and exile among Palestinians in Syria. While she touches on the messy politics between the Palestinian national movement and the Syrian regime, she maintains her focus on ordinary Palestinians and their ability to navigate the minefield between the two, especially after Oslo. Research on Palestinians in Syria offers a different perspective on the relation between refugees and the host country compared to other neighboring Arab countries. The current war has serious ramifications for Palestinians in Syria and Al-Hardan's Palestinians in Syria comes at a dire moment in their history as thriving communities in Yarmouk Camp and elsewhere in Syria have been destroyed. It highlights the political predicament and humanitarian crisis for Palestinian refugees, since the current conflict might very likely end their existence in Syria after more than six decades (p. 188). Although the majority of research for the book was conducted prior to this conflict, Al-Hardan highlights how the civil war in Syria is yet another instance of how each Palestinian generation born in exile and living in an Arab country experiences its own nakba.
Throughout the book Al-Hardan demonstrates her commitment to fieldwork as “places of conversation” between the researcher and the “research community” (p. xii). As a Western based researcher of Palestinian origin, Al-Hardan expounds on the positionality of the researcher in the production of knowledge (p. xii). Excerpts from her field notes and interviews demonstrate her conscious effort to illuminate power relations in the field between the researcher and the researched. This attention to the dynamics of fieldwork adds to the poignancy of refugee stories that were documented before the war and have attained new meaning in the aftermath of the conflict. Several of her conversation partners have been killed, displaced, or forced into a new exile and Al-Hardan, where possible, provides a concise update on their status and that of their community: “Another village day took place in al-Qabun, today a war-torn suburb of Damascus, where a small community of Palestinian refugees from the Haifa subdistrict of Tantura and their descendents lived” (p. 91–92). This demonstrates not only her commitment to her conversation partners but also the interplay between objectivity and subjectivity in social science research.
Palestinians in Syria is written in a lucid style with Al-Hardan carefully guiding the reader through each chapter, resulting in a cohesive and accessible text. The book is carefully researched and documented with a robust bibliography that includes sources in French and German to supplement the usual Arabic and English sources. There are detailed endnotes and a comprehensive index. Palestinians in Syria will be of great interest to those who study refugees, memory, community building, and the nakba.
