The word Ibadi does not appear in the title of this slim but thoroughly researched volume. Nevertheless, the Ibadi sect serves as the author's conceptual focus, particularly in relation to her examination of the connection of the Ibadi revival or nahḍa to Arab nationalism and Pan-Islamism, following connections between Zanzibar, Oman, the Maghrib, and the Mashriq. The subtitle is a bit misleading since the only regions of the Indian Ocean with which Ghazal is concerned are Zanzibar and, to a lesser extent, Oman.
This is a reworking of the author's University of Alberta PhD dissertation. Ghazal was thorough in her pursuit of sources, which include a wide range of Arabic publications and primary materials from archival and manuscript collections in Zanzibar, Oman, Algeria, Lebanon, and the United Kingdom. The book essentially revolves around the role of the ʿulamaʾ and other religious elites in Zanzibar, along with rulers, in bringing together ideas, ideologies, personal ties, and intellectual connections between Zanzibar and the wider Islamic world. Links between Oman and Zanzibar in the Ibadi nahḍa are relatively well known. But the links connecting Oman and Zanzibar with North Africa, particularly with the Ibadi scholars of the Mzab in Algeria, as well as between Ibadi and Salafi scholars in both regions, have been less explored. Discussion of these links undoubtedly represents one of the most valuable contributions of the book. Ghazal notes the patronage of Mzabi scholars, most notably Muhammad Atfiyyash, by sultans of Zanzibar and the positive role that such patronage played in the publication of Ibadi works and thus in underpinning the Ibadi nahḍa.
Another purpose of the book is to demonstrate the relations between Ibadi revivalism and Pan-Islamism in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, including links between the Ottomans and Zanzibar, as well as between Ibadi revivalists and leading Salafi scholars. An intrinsic theme of these relationships was common cause against European imperialism and its encroachment on Islamic lands. A full chapter devoted to the Omani-Zanzibari poet and thinker Nasir al-Bahlani illustrates the intersection of these philosophical ties by focusing on his writings in books and in the first newspaper published in Zanzibar, which centered around the themes of the nahḍa, Pan-Islamism, Islamic reform, and colonialism. Ghazal also devotes the bulk of two chapters to tracing how these themes were articulated more broadly in Zanzibar through examining opinion in newspapers and chronicling attitudes toward education.
The volume's strongest emphasis, though, is on its exploration of Ibadi revivalism in Zanzibar. Ghazal rejects the “binary” view that Zanzibari culture and people consisted of two distinct and separate cultures, Arab and Swahili. Swahili culture, she argues, is a fusion of Arab and African (and she extends her argument to reject Africanists’ separation of North Africa from Sub-Saharan African history). She “situates Omani rule within a paradigm that unifies the usually disjointed ‘Arab’ and ‘African.’ Doing so allows us to best capture the dynamics of the identity articulated by Omanis in Zanzibar. For them, Zanzibar belonged to an Arab-Islamic world that stretched into Africa” (p. 7). The contention that the “Omani elite” of Zanzibar should be considered another sector of the colonized population of Zanzibar rather than the country's overlords is a subtheme arising from this idea.
Ghazal is at her best while discussing religious movements and their leading figures. Her handling of broader history beyond Zanzibar is on less sure ground. Indeed, her familiarity with Zanzibari personalities and currents seems much surer than her passages on Oman, even though she notes the close and frequent interrelationships between the two countries. Her sole academic source on Omani history of the 19th and early 20th centuries was published in 1967, and she does not seem to be aware of the extensive work done on Oman over the following forty-five years. The lack of attention to available sources on Oman leads her astray through her concentration solely on the religious impulses behind the revival of the Ibadi imamate, thus ignoring the important role of tribal alignments. The power of the leading figure of the Ghafiri tribal confederation, Himyar b. Nasir al-Nabhani—who is not mentioned in the book—engineered the election in 1913 of an imam from a Ghafiri tribe. Himyar's death in 1920 left the election of a new imam that year in the hands of the Hinawi confederation, thus resulting in an imam from a Hinawi family (not Hinaʾi, as stated in an endnote). Furthermore, the author states that the 1920 agreement of al-Sib “resulted in the official declaration of the Imamate in the Interior of Oman and the Sultanate on the coast” (p. 35). The imam and the imamate are nowhere mentioned in the agreement, which simply legitimizes the autonomy of the interior from Muscat.
