The historian might approach a biography – or perhaps ought to approach? – with a degree of caution, wary of lapses into ‘great men’ or ‘great women’ interpretations, characterised by sentimental hagiography or pseudo-psychology, and telling us little of depth about the subject in question. We therefore perhaps approach this book with slight trepidation, especially given its suggestive title (albeit slightly reassured by the subtitle). It is not that we do not need a study of Celia Sánchez, for one is long overdue, to help us understand the woefully underestimated contribution, role and importance (to post-1956 Cuban history) of the woman often casually dismissed as a secondary adjunct to Fidel Castro (secretary? partner?). Moreover, one might add that the several women who contributed so significantly to shaping the character and outcome of the early decades of rebellion and Revolution in Cuba (after all, one can also list Vilma Espín, Haydée Santamaría and Melba Hernández, most notably), have been equally ignored by historians, either left in the shadows of their male counterparts or, at worst, treated as ‘wife-of’ bit-part characters in the drama. However, while we welcome any serious study of the person characteristically known inside Cuba simply as ‘Celia’, we perhaps understandably hesitate before a clearly sympathetic biography.
However, all of that caution does not prepare us for what turns out to be a fascinating, commendably detailed, remarkably well-researched, and always thoughtful study of someone who, quite clearly, was more central to decision-making than we might expect, both in the leadership circle of the Sierra rebels before 1959 and in the Revolution's governing circles after 1959, until her death in 1980. Certainly, many older Cubans know that centrality well, even if not the detail, and any close study of her constant presence near Fidel, or of the accounts of her discussions with him and other leaders, or, more importantly, of her invaluable contribution to the 1956–58 rebellion's military success soon suggests much more than a mere bit-part player.
To her credit, Nancy Stout (already with a solid pedigree as a writer on Cuba) does succeed in this account of Sánchez's life in bringing out much more than a blow-by-blow account of her life, highlighting well her qualities, her actions (significant and insignificant, but all revealing) and her emotional relationship with the guerrilla struggle and its leaders. There may be a tendency towards sentimentality in some of Stout's treatment of Sánchez's life and a parallel tendency at times to speculate about motives, on the basis of intuition or casual comments, or perhaps even of wishful thinking; but, going beyond a tone which the conventional historian might easily find a little cloying, we soon discover a picture of a remarkable woman, of someone with an unusual strength of character, a clear sense of personal commitment, considerable courage and an astute political awareness. We see someone with a prodigious efficiency and dedication to detail (the account of the creation of the would-be rebels' initial training camp near Manzanillo highlights both qualities well), someone with an energy and a determination which drove her to resist considerable hardship and take considerable risks, but, above all, someone without whose efforts, judgements and personality, the shape and outcome of the insurrection might well not have turned out as it did. For, as we are told with commendable and well-checked detail (details which, given the usual plethora of factual errors, contradictions and vagueness which bedevil many accounts of those years, even those we find in Cuba, we have long needed) the network of supporters, suppliers, messengers, loyalties and, ultimately, recruits which Sánchez created in 1955–57, before she finally went to the Sierra to join Fidel Castro and become probably his most trusted and closest advisor, was crucial to the survival of the original handful of post-Granma rebels in December 1956, and then to the survival and development of the emerging infrastructure of rebellion. Indeed, one might add that, in the process, Stout also does a valuable service in revealing to us quite how fundamental (and since forgotten) was the role in the insurrection played by the whole Manzanillo area and its many sympathisers, active and passive alike. Manzanillo rarely gets included in studies of the Sierra campaigns, so this is a welcome corrective.
If there is a weakness in the story being told, it is perhaps that the post-1961 pages take us rather too quickly and in less detail through two decades where we might have welcomed more comment on Sánchez's political, as opposed to personal and emotional, judgements and contribution; for the existing evidence is that she did indeed play a fundamental role on many occasions in those years. However, we are given less of a sense of that importance and detail than of the much richer picture of her months in rebellion. Maybe that is inevitable, given the ‘heroic’ nature of those months and that experience, which lends itself more easily to Stout's very useful step-by-step approach; however, it should be said that, overall, this unevenness in the treatment does not ultimately detract from the impact or value of what is, in the end, much more valuable and more solid than one initially fears. It is, in short, a useful, and always readable, addition to the literature.
