Nowadays, bombarded as we are with messages that promote excess and glamorize the exceptional, the unusual, the extreme, it is certainly surprising that the author of this book has opted for a tribute to moderation. Aurelian Craiutu, an expert in French political thought, offers an in-depth study of a handful of half-forgotten liberal writers: Jean-Joseph Mounier, Jacques Necker, Germaine de Staël, Benjamin Constant. Writing in so turbulent an age as the “era of revolutions,” they all shared a firm commitment to politics based on prudence, negotiation, and compromise. This painstaking reconstruction of the thinking of those late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century French authors is not, however, an exclusively historiographic enterprise: those ideas still have, according to Craiutu, much to tell us.
In an earlier book on François Guizot and the doctrinaires, Craiutu had pointed to the particular relevance of the work of that group of intellectuals specifically on account of the moderation they exhibited (Liberalism under Siege: The Political Thought of the French Doctrinaires). The focus of this new book clearly highlights this crucial point, previously only hinted at: the author takes pains to underscore that the lessons that today's readers might draw from the writings of Staël, Constant, and the other publicists he analyzes, most of them linked to the so-called Coppet group, are related above all to moderation. This is the leitmotiv of this splendid monograph which, for this reason, may at the same time be read as an essay on political philosophy.
The book is divided into two parts, each of which has three chapters, as well as a prologue and an epilogue. Chapter 1 sketches a brief outline of the many faces of moderation in the Western tradition, from the Aristotelian doctrine of the mesotēs to the French moralists and encyclopedists of the early modern age. Chapter 2 offers an illuminating analysis of the architecture of moderate government according to Montesquieu. Chapter 3 transports the reader to the maelstrom of debates during the French Revolution to show us the “radically moderate” opinions—ultimately defeated—of Mounier and the Monarchiens. Chapter 4 returns to the scenario of the crisis of the ancien régime to monitor the evolution of Necker's stance in those crucial years at the turn of the century. Finally, chapters 5 and 6, dedicated respectively to Madame de Staël and Benjamin Constant, present an interpretation of these two complex and controversial characters, whose greatest works were the fruits of a permanent dispute with the French Revolution, as both struggled to imagine just how the Terror had been possible.
The fact that the true axis of the book is that great revolution comes as no surprise; after all, “we continue to live today in a democratic world shaped by—and built upon—the ideas and principles of the French Revolution” (2). Partially refuting the idea, widely held in academic circles, that a genuine liberalism has never taken root in France, Craiutu reveals a seam of figures—half thinkers, half politicians—who were without any doubt among the leading ideologues of liberalism. The historical-political image of France, revolutionary nation par excellence and the epitome of “immoderation,” is thus qualified in this book, which displays a range of reflections which, in the wake of Montesquieu, that great standard bearer of the “spirit of moderation,” support the thesis that the courageous minds of that critical period often sought moderate solutions to the serious problems and political challenges faced by their societies. It is a pity that Craiutu does not really enter the debate over whether those first liberals made a clean break with republicanism, as some scholars have maintained (see, for example, Andreas Kalyas and Ira Katznelson, Liberal Beginnings: Making a Republic for the Moderns), or whether, on the contrary, French liberalism should be seen as an offshoot from the republican trunk (Andrew Jainchill, Reimagining Politics after the Terror: The Republican Origins of French Liberalism).
Unlike those radical sectors who sought to establish a kind of synonymy between liberalism and revolution, the authors analyzed in this volume respond more to a “liberalism of fear” (Judith Shklar), which seeks to protect the liberties of the individual against the threatening intrusions of the public authorities. In this respect, Uwe Backes's book on political extremism, the English version of which came out in 2010, might serve as an interesting counterpoint (Political Extremes: A Conceptual History from Antiquity to the Present).
To emphasize the multiplicity of dimensions and facets—philosophical, moral, political, institutional—of moderation, the author recurs to the metaphor of the archipelago. All the islands in that lost archipelago which Craiutu discovers and shows to the reader—ideas, modes of action and argument—are as attractive as they are pertinent. One might possibly glimpse, however, another island or two, related to the intense temporalization of politics which marked that turbulent period of Western history. There is no shortage of witnesses to that age of transition who measure the degree of radicalism or moderation of the actors according to the speed each wishes to accompany the changes he or she advocates. Thus, while the revolutionaries seek to break with the past by accelerating the rhythm of change, the conservatives favor gradual transformations that guarantee a certain continuity between past, present, and future. For this very reason, moderation, Craiutu notes, “is a double-edged sword” (18). Depending on the circumstances, it can be invoked alternatively either to push forward changes or to slow them down, when the “moderates” consider that the radicals are advancing too fast (and even to arrest that progress, putting an end to the revolution).
Just as questionable is whether moderation deserves to be regarded as a fundamental political virtue per se, or could be interpreted rather as a quality which accompanies and modulates other more substantial principles. The author of this book believes that this is a multifaceted concept. Nevertheless, it is not unreasonable to interpret moderation as a cross or combination of various concepts: prudence, compromise, negotiation, reasonability, restraint, circumspection, temperance, mixed government, separation of powers. Along with the image of the archipelago, Craiutu cites another equally suggestive ancient metaphor that describes moderation as “the silken string running through the pearl-chain of all virtues” (241). If this silken string links together a set of pearls/virtues, one could conclude that moderation is not in fact just another virtue, but in a way a transversal one that threads together and connects all the others.
Whatever the case, unlike the friends of extremes and strong emotions, so abundant in neoromantic times like today's, Craiutu has had the courage enthusiastically to defend—in the footsteps of that “enthusiastic moderate,” Germaine de Staël—an unpopular and vilified virtue such as moderation. In one of his diatribes against moderate attitudes, Friedrich Nietzsche suggested that such attitudes are those of mediocre types who follow “the instinct of the herd.” This book proves, however, that this herd instinct often leads to radicalization and fanaticism, while it is often the moderates who actually swim against the current.
