From the end of the nineteenth century to the middle of the twentieth century, the American South experienced one of the great structural shifts in American history. In this book, Matthew L. Downs documents the transition from a cotton economy to a robust industrial economy in one portion of the South, the greater Tennessee River valley. Downs details this transition and its link to the changing role of the federal government throughout the region. Downs describes four main experiences that occurred from 1915–1960 in the Tennessee River Valley, the proposal and construction of Wilson Dam at Muscle Shoals, the creation and development of the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), the rise of local planning boards, and finally, the formation of Redstone Arsenal and NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center in Huntsville, AL. Any scholar interested understanding the industrial transformation of the South, industrial recruitment, or place based policies will benefit from reading this work.
Downs’ central theory is that in each of the four developments in the Tennessee Valley, the success of the region depended critically on the relationship between local leadership and the federal government, and that other regions of the South had similar experiences. Throughout the book, he provides rich examples of how local leadership varied both within the valley, in locations such as Huntsville and Decatur, and between the valley and other locations in the South.
The first main event that Downs documents is the federal government's 1917 announcement to locate a nitrate plant and dam in Muscle Shoals, Alabama. Immediately following the announcement, Downs is quick to point out that local leadership in the communities surrounding Muscle Shoals “became a leading voice in ‘promoting urban unity, growth, and commercial civic priorities’ in a concentrated effort to grow their city” (p. 16). The announcement of the dam led local leaders to promote the Shoals as a region sure to have cheap power for decades to come; however, following the conclusion of World War I, the nitrate plant was still a work in progress, and the federal government began to question the role it desired in the Tennessee River Valley. Congress debated the future of the dam for years. The federal government, Henry Ford, Alabama Power, and American Cyanamid all made proposals to Congress to gain an ownership stake in the dam, in an unsettled drama that played out throughout the 1920s. All the while, “locals quickly learned that, while the governments support in sparking growth might be beneficial, the long term prospects for sustaining such development were dim” (p. 57). A solution to Muscle Shoals controversy was not reached until the creation of the TVA under President Roosevelt in 1933.
The Muscle Shoals experience taught leaders in the valley that they could not depend on the government alone. Initially the TVA represented a boom for the valley, creating thousands of jobs to construct dams and clear reservoirs. However, after dam construction ended, the TVA shifted gears and became a regional planning agency. As TVA became a development agency, tension grew between regional development goals and local communities that desired development. Downs clearly demonstrates how local leadership could influence development. In Decatur, Alabama, “city leaders continued to press TVA for assistance, but they refused to wait on the agency to take a more active interest in Decatur's growth” (p. 135). Cities like Decatur utilized TVA, but it was their drive that landed projects locally. Meanwhile, “the city of Huntsville languished [due to its] failure to take advantage of the agency's [TVA's] bounty.…[L]eaders watched as the textile mills that underwrote municipal finances faltered ” (p. 177).
Huntsville continued to slide until World War II. During the war, Redstone Arsenal was established and created a major economic stimulus, employing more than 10,000 civilians at its peak of operation. Downs shows how wartime defense projects could wreak havoc on the local economy as cities had to provide housing, education, and sanitation services for the influx of workers. Leaders welcomed the boom, but at the conclusion of the war, they struggled to find ways to diversify the economy to soften the de-escalation of the conflict. By 1947, only 1,500 workers remained at Redstone. “For communities like Huntsville, a scaled down federal presence threatened the city's economic livelihood and forced city leaders to action” (p. 204). While city leaders tried to lease surplus industrial sites at the arsenal, it took the federal government to shape the long run path of Huntsville once again. In 1950, Werner von Braun and his team of German rocket scientist were relocated to Redstone Arsenal. This event ultimately set the stage for the region to become a worldwide center for high tech engineering and aerospace systems.
While this book provides a rich history of the events and experiences in the Tennessee Valley, the reader is likely to be left with one nagging question: What is the counterfactual? Did this region of the South grow because of federal involvement, or did it grow in a fashion similar to the rest of the South? Downs is quick to say that the experience of the Tennessee Valley is similar to that of the greater South. Yet, many regions of the South did not experience the TVA, or a defense boom related to NASA. At the same time, Downs often wants to say that the experience in the Tennessee Valley is unique; however, he discusses other state and regional planning agencies, such as Mississippi's State Industrial Board, or the Alabama State Chamber of Commerce (established by Alabama Power) and how they played a similar role as the TVA in the recruitment of industry. These two conflicting points makes it difficult to determine if the growth experienced in the Tennessee Valley was simply part of the overall trend in the South, or, if the Tennessee Valley experienced exceptional growth above and beyond what was seen elsewhere.
