No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
Urban history is one of the more well-developed fields in Ottoman Syrian studies. Monographs on individual cities, approached from different perspectives and for different eras of the Ottoman period, as well as comparative studies of urban patterns, have familiarized us with similarities and differences among these cities and with shifting patterns of urbanization over time. Not surprisingly, the largest cities—Aleppo, Damascus, and Beirut—have received the most attention, although recently studies of smaller cities (notably, Jim Reilly's study of Hama and Beshara Doumani's study of Nablus) have appeared. Thomas Philipp's study of Acre fits into the latter category. Making thorough and thoughtful use of all available sources (local histories, Ottoman archives, French consular reports, and travel literature), Philipp provides a detailed and in-depth study of the geography, politics, commerce, administration, and society of Acre and its region, a welcome addition to the historiography of Ottoman Syrian cities.
Acre is a particularly interesting case study because its history was quite different from that of other Ottoman Syrian cities. During the 100 years covered in this study, Acre underwent radical transformation. Little more than a village among the ruins of the Crusader city in 1730, by 1785 Acre had become the third-largest city in Syria, the capital of a politically integrated region in southwestern Syria, and the most important seaport on the Syrian coast. Its decline was equally precipitous. By the fourth decade of the 19th century, it was once again an insignificant coastal town. Philipp's purpose in this work is to narrate and explain both the rise and the subsequent decline of this city.
Philipp argues that this dramatic history was directly linked to the two major structural changes that were affecting the Ottoman Empire as a whole: the decentralization of the state, reflected in the growing power of provincial notables, and the beginnings of the transition to the European-dominated world economy. The particular way in which these two processes intersected in southwestern Syria in the 18th century precipitated the rise of Acre and its subsequent downfall between 1730 and 1831.
Before 1730, Acre was an insignificant town on the geographical periphery of the Ottoman Empire, away from the major economic and military lines of communication in Syria. As a “frontier” town with no settled hinterland, it was a backwater in the early centuries of Ottoman rule. This peripheral position, however, worked to its advantage as political and economic conditions changed in the 18th century. Political weakness at the center of the Ottoman state created the possibility of new political centers. Philipp discusses in detail the rise to power and rule of the powerful notables who took advantage of this vacuum and dominated Acre during this period: Umar al-Dhahir, Ahmad Pasha al-Jazzar, and Sulayman Pasha (chap. 2). On one level, these rulers were classic examples of 18th-century Ottoman provincial notables. At the same time, they were different from many other notables. They achieved an unprecedented degree of political autonomy because of French interest in raw cotton, the measures taken by Acre's rulers to facilitate this export trade, and the wealth they were able to accumulate as a result. “Political power and economic interests were joined in an unprecedented symbiosis” (p. 102). Philipp discusses the economic relationship between the French and the local rulers at some length, focusing on the policy of “state monopoly.” By prohibiting direct contact between the French and the local population, the rulers of Acre reaped the benefits of French demand for raw cotton without having to share the profits with other groups. The economic boom produced by this trade attracted immigrants to the city and resulted both in significant growth in population and major urban development.
According to Philipp, Acre was the first place in the Middle East to be effectively integrated into the world economy. However, the benefits of this relationship did not last. As the world market changed in the early 19th century, the rulers' policy of economic monopoly undermined the government's ability to respond to these changes and hastened France's departure from Acre. Furthermore, it had a stifling effect on the local population. The government dominated all areas of the economy, becoming the biggest contractor and employer, as well as establishing a monopoly on trade. As a result, there were no guilds and there was no urban elite, both of which played such a critical role in other Ottoman cities. Philipp's discussion of urban society and the relationship between government and society (chap. 5) is one of the most interesting in the book. Unlike other Syrian cities, Acre lacked the urban institutions, intermediary social groups, and established urban fabric not only of the “great” Arab cities such as Aleppo and Damascus, but also of smaller cities such as Hama and Nablus. Unfortunately, there are no extant religious court documents to provide a clearer picture of this “frontier” society of immigrants.
Philipp's study of Acre offers a persuasive and well-documented argument that makes an important contribution to our understanding of several issues. One is the process of integration of the Middle East into the world economy. He underscores the fact that this process began well before Muhammad

Ali and the Egyptian cotton boom and therefore reinforces the importance of scholarship on the 18th century for understanding the social transformations associated with modernity. The experience of Acre also reminds us once again that the process of integration into the world economy was not a monolithic one. The degree of integration and its impact on different regions of the Middle East was contingent on when this integration occurred, on local power structures, and on the composition and responses of local elites, as well as market forces and the interests of European players. Philipp also underscores the variation in the relationship between the Ottoman central government and the various provincial actors during this period of decentralization. There were different degrees and kinds (political versus economic) of autonomy even when the Ottoman state was least able to exercise control beyond the core areas of the empire.
Overall, this is an important and welcome contribution to the historiography of Ottoman Syrian cities and to the discussion of the early stages in the transformation to modernity. The depth and detail of this case study make it particularly valuable for scholars of the Middle East and graduate students, although less accessible to nonspecialists.