Malawi has the unfortunate distinction of suffering one of the most severe HIV epidemics and being among the world's poorest countries. Women in Malawi are more likely to be infected with HIV than are men, a defining characteristic of all heterosexually driven epidemics. In Gender, HIV and Risk: Navigating Structural Violence Emma-Louise Anderson seeks to explain these circumstances by examining ‘the nuances of the gender context of HIV risk in Malawi – how it is produced, experienced and responded to at the local level’ (p. 2). She then reflects on and critiques the broader policy response in light of the gendered context of risk. Anderson frames her approach in terms of structural violence, which she defines as the situation in which social structures engender inequality by preventing people from meeting their full potential (p. 3).
Anderson critiques the neoliberal response to the epidemic with its focus on individualistic and technical approaches to AIDS instead of structural and social solutions. To do so, she draws on data from key informant interviews she conducted in 2007 and 2011 with national-level and – to a lesser extent – local-level HIV-affiliated personnel from the Malawian government and non-governmental organisations. She complements these with focus group discussions with men and women from HIV support groups. Importantly, she conducts research in two different districts, one that is comprised of predominately patrilineal and the other predominately matrilineal tribes, reflecting the diversity of gendered environments in Malawi and the absence of a monolithic social structure.
The main substantive chapters, ‘Sex for Security’ and ‘Sex for Well-Being’, describe the gendered nature of poverty in Malawi and argue that women's sexual decision-making is constrained within a context of poverty and a subordinate position in society. At times the arguments are old and familiar ones – e.g. women have sex for survival and dangerous cultural practices drive the HIV epidemic. These arguments have been lauded for years but fail to capture the complexity of risk and the epidemiological reality of HIV in Malawi. Indeed, as Anderson herself notes, there is a positive association between wealth and HIV in Malawi among both men and women (the same is true across the region) (Parkhurst Reference Parkhurst2010). Unfortunately, she stops short of engaging in why this would be the case if, as she argues, gendered poverty, survival sex and cultural practices are fuelling the epidemic. Similarly, she problematises women's limited autonomy and inability to leave marriages as causes of their HIV infection. Once again, however, the reader is left to wonder why HIV prevalence is twice as high in the (largely) matrilineal south where divorce is common and women have greater autonomy (National Statistical Office (NSO) and ICF Macro 2011).
Fortunately, elsewhere in the book, Anderson offers a more nuanced depiction of women, whom she acknowledges also have sex for upward mobility (see also Mojola Reference Mojola2014 in Kenya) and wellbeing. Ultimately, there is juxtaposition in the book between the old foils of gendered poverty and cultural practices and more nuanced and insightful portrayals of the complexity and challenges faced by both women and men in modern Malawi. The former are likely a function of an overreliance on interviews with urban elites who frequently offer simplistic views of rural villagers, cultural practices and gender roles. In contrast, the strengths of the book lie in the segments that present a more complicated picture of the structural nature of HIV risk and astutely critique neoliberal approaches such as the female condom and vaginal microbicides – two technical solutions that consume the imaginations of Western donors but offer little real solution to the complex social underpinnings of the HIV epidemic.
