This slim volume provides an overview of legal precedents, international treaties and ongoing disputes among the countries of the Nile River basin over water resources. The book focuses on making a case for upstream states, particularly Ethiopia, to challenge existing treaties that allocate Nile flow at Aswan between Sudan and Egypt. The authors trace the evolution of conflicting positions between upstream and downstream states, with Ethiopia and other upstream riparians advocating ‘fair and equitable’ use of Nile waters, while Egypt and Sudan have long invoked international legal norms of ‘historic’ use. The book explains the origins of these competing legal claims, and traces efforts since 1999 to negotiate a new multilateral treaty, the Cooperative Framework Agreement (Entebbe Agreement) through the donor-supported Nile Basin Initiative (NBI). The book tracks existing policy debates and relies on a relatively limited secondary literature, combined with official policy statements, to provide historical context. Individual chapters exhibit significant redundancy in the argument and evidence and would have benefited from judicious editing.
With the exception of Egypt, the authors do not examine the political economies of Nile riparians. While Egypt receives critical treatment throughout, portrayed as a hydro-hegemon that unfairly obstructs upstream development (an empirically more ambiguous claim than the authors present), political struggles and violence in Sudan and Ethiopia that underpinned civil wars and famines are not mentioned. Relying largely on official statements by postcolonial leaderships, the authors pay little attention to the complex regional and internal politics at play in upstream states.
As the authors show, Ethiopia's unilateral construction of the Renaissance Dam has forced Egypt to recognise the changing balance of power in the basin, which may offer new opportunities for cooperation. The authors call for local participation and consultation along the basin, but the specific issues of land degradation, soil erosion, food insecurity, and challenges of water and land conservation in the very diverse agro-ecological communities of the basin are not addressed. The authors make little mention of work under the NBI that sought to expand water planning to focus not only on the ‘blue’ surface water of rivers and tributaries, but also groundwater supplies and the ‘green’ water provided by rainfall.
Lastly, the authors provide little critical commentary on how dam-building across the Nile Basin (as well as across Africa), fuelled in part by ready capital and construction tenders from Chinese, Gulf and European firms, will translate into substantive rural development. In this respect, Egypt offers a cautionary example for Ethiopia. The building of the Aswan High Dam was insufficient to address rural poverty, particularly in Upper Egypt. Authoritarian practices and governance in Egypt, as in modern Ethiopia, deepened rural exclusion. As Addis Ababa taps the Blue Nile for hydropower, the authors could have asked how state elites plan to use these new resources and revenues to tackle social and economic vulnerability in the peripheries.
