Juliana Adelman's Communities of Science in Nineteenth-Century Ireland is a welcome and groundbreaking contribution to the history of Irish science. Taking an innovative and thematic approach to the topic, it makes a cogent case for the importance of science in Irish public culture during the nineteenth century. Arguing that the importance of science in Irish popular discourse can hardly be overstated, Adelman examines the development of science in nineteenth-century Ireland, exploring the values placed on science in Irish society, and how these values were expressed through institutions, voluntary activities and publications.
Communities of Science charts the changes in the Irish scientific landscape from the 1840s to the 1880s. It examines the impact of the establishment of the new Queen's Colleges in Cork, Galway and Belfast on the communities in these new university towns and explores how, outside the colleges, science continued to ‘serve as entertainment in the context of scientific societies’ (pp. 1–2) and how this scientific recreation contributed to Irish society and identity. Apart from discussion of the circumstances surrounding the establishment of the Catholic University in Dublin in 1854, the scientific institutions in Ireland's capital are excluded from this study. Instead, the book focuses on the various communities identified by Adelman as part of the wider community of science in nineteenth-century provincial Ireland and, more specifically, on the various approaches to the study of natural history and of agricultural chemistry within these communities. The main structure of Communities of Science examines how these subjects were addressed by scientific societies and within the formal educational environment of the new colleges. The role of museums in scientific education is addressed, as is the relationship between science, religion and national identity as reflected in the contributions to contemporary periodicals.
The introductory chapter establishes the historical context to the topic, providing a perceptive review of the interplay between the varying scientific institutions in Ireland (and their backgrounds) in the middle decades of the century, the principles which inspired them and the constraints under which they operated. The significant factors which made the Irish scientific environment so different to that of Britain – religion, lack of industrialization and a much higher level of government control and funding of scientific institutions – are identified, succinctly establishing the political, social and educational background context to the book.
Given the wide-ranging nature of the book, in the chapter on voluntary societies devoted to science in Ireland, Adelman wisely chose to focus on one town, Cork, and its scientific societies to illustrate the education these bodies offered (either through formal lectures or informally) to those with an interest in the sciences. The interaction between amateur scientists and those whose scientific interests were more professional is examined, especially in the years after the establishment of the Queen's College in Cork. Addressing the topic of university education, Adelman provides a deft description of the complex and complicated situation surrounding the establishment of the three government-funded Queen's Colleges, the resulting rejection by the Catholic hierarchy of these non-denominational institutions and the subsequent establishment of a Catholic University in Dublin. As the author points out, this debate had a long-lasting effect on the study of science in Ireland. The continuing involvement of religion and politics in education for the rest of the century polarized the Irish intellectual community and made Irish scientific education highly political and sectarian. Addressing the contributions of both universities and voluntary societies to a specific topic, it is in the following chapter that Adelman examines the efforts to establish formal agricultural education in the Queen's Colleges and compares these with the activities of the agricultural societies. Focusing on the agricultural education offered in the Queen's College in Belfast, the aspirations underlying the establishment of the agriculture diploma in 1849 and the reasons for its failure by 1863 are analysed.
The concluding chapters address the wider public access to science education. The contribution of industrial exhibitions and of the museums of the Queen's Colleges to the popularization of science and to the encouragement of public interest in scientific developments are examined. The penultimate chapter, reviewing contributions to contemporary Irish literary periodicals, presents an invaluable overview of the relationship between science, religion and culture, concluding, ‘Despite the efforts of scientific reformers, the idea of science for improvement did not take hold in Catholic and nationalist periodical culture in Ireland’ (p. 159).
The history of science and scientific pursuits in nineteenth-century Ireland has, up until recently, been confined to studies of specific disciplines, individuals or institutions which contributed to the wider scientific endeavour. As a topic it has also been sadly ignored by historians in the field of Irish cultural, educational and social history. Adelman, in Communities of Science, makes a significant contribution to establishing a new awareness of the subject. Her thematic approach to the study of Irish scientific communities in the nineteenth century illustrates how science intersected with other interests, reveals the very active interest in the sciences in a variety of environments in provincial Ireland and supports the author's argument that Ireland's relationship with science was unique. However, the publication as a whole suffers from the drawbacks of the thematic approach. The individual chapters make complicated issues understandable but despite the book's interesting argument and insightful observations, the overall structure is disjointed. The inclusion of a section on the activities of the national societies, the Royal Dublin Society especially, and their contribution to scientific education and development in nineteenth-century Ireland would have drawn the individual thematic chapters into a more unified whole.
That said, this is an exceptionally wide-ranging and accessible study whose value lies not only in its content but also in the many new research questions it raises. Historians of Irish history, as well as historians of science in Ireland, will find much enlightenment here.
