The Cambridge Companion to Boethius is made up of twelve essays, each examining aspects of Boethius' logical, theological, and philosophical output. The Companion presents a useful introduction to both current and previous scholarship on Boethius' work. The depth and scope of the scholarship on offer will also maintain the interest of those more familiar with the field.
The Companion heralds the timely and welcome arrival of a work which seeks to explain why Boethius captured the imagination of so many. As editor John Marenbon explains in his introduction to the work, Boethius has suffered from the demands of specialist disciplines which ignore context and prevent a more rounded picture of the man and his work emerging. Boethius has also suffered from a perception that he is a mere translator of texts, a ‘conduit’ transmitting others' thoughts to future generations. The result of this, M. believes, is that the man himself is ignored and his significant contributions undervalued. M.'s desire for the reader ‘to read Boethius, whole’ is an attempt to re-establish exactly why Boethius was, and still is, a remarkable figure.
The twelve essays are divided into two parts. The first part of the work is devoted to Boethius' output before he penned the Consolatio Philosophiae. The second half concentrates on the great work itself. Within this division there are further subdivisions. Part 1 can be seen as a three-part act. There is an introductory essay which concentrates on setting the historical scene. There follow three essays which discuss different areas of Boethius' work on logic and philosophy. The third act of Part 1 has three further essays focusing on points of interest in Boethius' theological output. Part 2 on the Consolatio opens with two essays on philosophy. There follows an essay on the philosophical implications of literary form. This essay links the philosophical first half of the second part with the final two essays, which focus on the literary traditions which the Consolatio sprung from and gave birth to.
In John Moorhead's opening essay the Companion finds a perfect foundation upon which to build. Moorhead's essay simply and elegantly sets out the context in which Boethius lived, worked, and thought. Political backdrop, academic climate, and philosophical trends are laid out before the reader in a useful synopsis. Boethius and his work are then placed into this context. The result is that the uninitiated reader is able to appreciate the diverse pressures and influences under which Boethius worked. One further result is that the specialist reader is invited to view the intellectual achievements of Boethius as more than a disembodied link in a subject-focused continuum.
Sten Ebbesen, Christopher Martin and Margaret Cameron evaluate Boethius' commentaries, glosses, and translations. Ebbesen presents some of the philosophical trends circulating around Boethius' time. Helpfully, he explains the ‘revolution’ which swept through the Greek world, witnessing the replacement of inimical philosophical schools of thought with a reconciliatory approach. We are informed of Boethius' rôle as translator of this revolution. Ebbesen then examines Boethius' interaction with exegetical glossaries (39–40), Greek inquisitorial structure (42), and non-dialogical commentaries (Ammonius). This feeds into a general question concerning sources, but Ebbesen refuses to take a firm view. The discussion provides the reader with valuable information on current and previous views on Boethius' sources. Christopher Martin focuses on the influence Boethius' philosophical work brought to bear on the medieval period. Although asserting that, in the history of logic, Boethius was not a great logician (56), Martin demonstrates that without Boethius there would have been little or no link between late antique philosophy and the medieval period. We are reminded that individuals like Abelard and William of Ockham developed new approaches to understanding logic in response to Boethius. Margaret Cameron approaches the same material used by Ebbesen and Martin, but focuses on how it deals with the familiar Aristotelian problem of signification. She looks at the triad of: expression; understanding; and reality (85). Cameron discusses the influences which may have been brought to bear on Boethius' view of this triad. Highlighting the potential influence of Porphyry, Plato (perhaps via Ammonius), and Alexander (94), Cameron reminds us of the philosophical tradition Boethius was interacting with.
The final three essays from Part 1 discuss Boethius' theological works. David Bradshaw correctly states that much of Boethius' Opuscula was a response to contemporary Church crises (108). Bradshaw discusses the theological shortcomings in Boethius' work and explains that these were in part attributable to the fact that he was employing inappropriate philosophical methodology (109). Andrew Arlig also considers Boethius' use of philosophy when approaching theological problems. Arlig examines Boethius' views on the trinity and the ways in which they were informed by Aristotle and Plato and the general theory of forms. Arlig argues that Boethius' understanding of forms was a product of Late Antiquity, and most probably informed by Plotinus and Porphyry. Finally, in his essay, Christopher Erismann recapitulates the idea that Boethius the philosopher created Boethius the theologian (156). Erismann is able to show that, in combining derivative philosophical ideas with original argumentation (173), Boethius introduced innovative new ideas which informed the development of both medieval philosophy and theology.
The second part of the Companion is devoted to the Consolatio. The first essay by John Magee examines the implications of the structure of the work for its philosophical message. The arrangement of the books is an indication ‘to his readers that the architecture of the Consolatio is a literary manifestation of philosophical themes’ (183). The familiar therapy metaphor is discussed as one of the themes introduced by the structure. Magee's essay, like the others before it, locates Boethius' ideas in a late antique context. Magee convincingly argues that Boethius' use of the Gorgias has been formed by a mediating Neo-Platonist voice. However, Boethius makes the conscious decision to focus on the simple message of Plato rather than indulge in the Neo-Platonic penchant for ‘wild allegories’ (200). In his essay, Robert Sharples concentrates on the issue of fate and freewill. While noting that the Consolatio is inconsistent in its tackling of the issue, Sharples reminds the reader that Boethius' particular take on Aristotle's ideas concerning ‘future truth’ is part of a wider tradition in Late Antiquity, to which the now familiar names of Ammonius, Proclus, and Alexander adhere (211–14).
Danuta Shanzer's essay examines the literary implications of the Consolatio. Shanzer asks: how should we read the text? She introduces an array of potential literary precedents and proceeds to discuss what the application of each literary form would mean for a reading of the Consolatio. Comedy (Menippean satire), bucolic work, and the dialogue form vie with each other, as Shanzer provides many answers without deciding on one. Like the other essays, the presentation of the various scholarly opinions offers a good overview of current scholarship. The final two essays are devoted to the literary history of the text. Lodi Nauta investigates the work's vast Latin commentary tradition. Nauta's essay highlights an important aspect of the work's enduring appeal: the overlapping theological and philosophical discourses which inform the work. Generations of scholars have thus been able to read the work in a way that speaks to their own particular cultural contexts. Winthorp Wetherbee's essay examines the translations, adaptations, and the general reception of the Consolatio. This essay has a wide remit which covers such diverse aspects of the work as metre, themes, content, and structure. The emphasis on medieval responses to Boethius again brings our attention back to the significant contribution Boethius made to such varied fields.
The Cambridge Companion to Boethius is a well-structured and successfully-executed addition to scholarship on Boethius. It represents a welcome emphasis on context which re-introduces Boethius the Philosopher, Theologian, and man. The excellent bibliography and continuous footnotes ensure that it will serve as an invaluable tool for scholars of Boethius.
