The documents filed in bankruptcy and other legal action to collect debt provide windows into the business practices and credit relationships of the widest possible range of businesses, from family shops to the largest enterprises. Yet these documents are rarely used. The US is the best-studied place, but fewer than a dozen projects have extensively used documents from federal cases before 1980, though a large number of the cases are available through the National Archives. Documents from state courts have been used even less frequently. The contributors to The History of Bankruptcy: Economic, Social, and Cultural Implications in Early Modern Europe have used a wide variety of these court documents and have made the case for their usefulness to address a wide range of issues.
Editor Thomas Max Safley aims to illuminate the transition from a world in which insolvency and bankruptcy are rare to one in which they are common. He succeeds by skillfully organizing the thirteen essays of the volume, which are mostly studies of local areas, into three themes.
First, the records allow the scholars to focus on the role of social capital, or trust, in credit networks. The role of repeated interactions in forging credit relationships, well known in modern economic theory, is evident throughout the early modern period. What is new here is the way that several authors draw out how the formal process of bankruptcy rebuilds what might otherwise be broken trust relationships. Bankruptcy and other formal collection processes allow the creditor to air his complaints and the honest debtor to make at least partial amends. A key element is that the business documents examined in public reveal whether the debtor intended to defraud the creditor, was merely incompetent, or whether he himself was the victim of some unfortunate event beyond his own control.
A second theme is how formal and public bankruptcy and collection procedures revealed structural problems with existing forms of business and strategies for management of risk. The revelations led to two sets of important developments. First, they led to rules and regulations. Second, in some cases they led to the creation of new forms of business, what we might consider early government-supported enterprises. The establishment of both the Banco delle Due Sicilie in Naples in 1815 and the Monte de pieta in Bologna are both illustrations of this theme.
The final theme is that institutional development and change occurred continuously. Initially the informal practices for negotiation and settlement that were already in place in many localities formed the bases of formal procedures. But the boundary-crossing nature of trade exposed creditors to practices elsewhere. Successful elements of those practices were incorporated into local law.
Overall, the fifteen contributors to the thirteen essays of the volume have done excellent work turning the complex documents into useful narratives. Of course, such good work begs for more. There are three areas in particular that economic historians and historians of economic thought will find underdeveloped.
The documents themselves, along with their weaknesses, are not as thoroughly discussed as one might like. The curious researcher will wish for appendices that summarize not just the information that was used in each paper, but what was not used. These sorts of appendices are essential for stimulating additional work using the documents. The curious will also want a clearer picture of the procedures in effect in the places and times that are studied. A discussion of the representativeness of the cases examined in more of the papers would also be useful, as would a discussion of the events that led to the survival of the particular records used and the destruction of others.
Second, with these papers laying out the history of particular places, one hopes for more comparative work in the future. For example, businessmen in both civil and common law systems faced similar problems in bankruptcy, but solved them in different ways. How did the differences affect early modern outcomes? The finally essay in the volume, “Bankruptcy, Fresh Start, and Renegotiation in England and France (17th to 18th Century),” by Jerome Sgard, is a step in this direction, but its focus is legal–political rather than economic.
Finally, while several essays emphasize what the editor calls the “centrifugal force” (p. 10) of default and bankruptcy that also can be found, for example, in the literature on the financial crises of the Great Depression, insufficient attention is given to either the long-run trend (that is, early globalization) or the short-run shocks that made default and bankruptcy more and more common and business more and more unpredictable. In seeking to understand the transition from a world in which bankrupts were viewed as frauds to one in which they were viewed as victims of unforeseen circumstances, the increasing exposure to market forces must be discussed.
