Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T11:20:02.524Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Front propagation in cellular flows: scale dependence versus scale invariance

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 August 2023

S. Bodea
Affiliation:
Aix Marseille Univ, CNRS, Centrale Marseille, IRPHE, 13384 Marseille, France
E. Beauvier
Affiliation:
Aix Marseille Univ, CNRS, Centrale Marseille, IRPHE, 13384 Marseille, France
A. Pocheau*
Affiliation:
Aix Marseille Univ, CNRS, Centrale Marseille, IRPHE, 13384 Marseille, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: alain.pocheau@univ-amu.fr

Abstract

We experimentally study front propagation in a vortex lattice providing closed steady cellular flows and no mean flow. To this end, we trigger an autocatalytic reaction in a solution stirred by magnetohydrodynamic flows in a Hele-Shaw cell. We evidence a scale-invariant regime below some flow magnitude and a scale-dependent regime above, the scales referring here to the vortex scale and the front thickness. The transition between these regimes corresponds to a unitary Damköhler number $Da$: $Da=1$. The enhancement of the mean front velocity with the flow magnitude nicely agrees with the literature on numerical simulations and theoretical analyses in the scale-invariant regime $Da>1$, but displays noticeable discrepancies in the scale-dependent one $Da<1$. This shows that the transition between regimes is qualitatively sharp but quantitatively smooth.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Synthesis of the regimes found in numerical analysis (§ 2.4.1) (Vladimirova et al.2003) and by theoretical analysis (§ 2.4.2) (Tzella & Vanneste 2014, 2015, 2019) at $Pe \gg 1$. For each regime, the range of validity and the relationships for the relative velocity $V/V_0$ are expressed with respect to $(Pe, Da)$ or to $(U/V_0, L/\lambda )$. The order of magnitude of $L/\lambda$ is also reported.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Numerical simulation (Vladimirova et al.2003) at large Péclet number $Pe\gg 1$. Sketch of the regimes as a function of the value of $Da$ versus $Pe$ (a) or of the value of $U/V_0$ versus $L/\lambda$ (b), both for arbitrary units. The domain $Pe\ll 1$, which falls out of the scope of the analysis, is displayed as a dashed line. The regimes, labelled A, B, C, are specified in the text with the corresponding velocity enhancement. In (b), the regime A takes place for $L/\lambda \ll 1/8$ while the remaining regimes B and C occur for the opposite condition $L/\lambda \gg 1/8$. The red segments indicate the experimental range swept in our study, as specified in § 3.2.2.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Theoretical analysis (Tzella & Vanneste 2015) at large Péclet number $Pe\gg 1$. Sketch of the regimes depending on the values of $Da$ versus $Pe$ (a) or on those of $U/V_0$ versus $L/\lambda$ (b), both for arbitrary units. The domain $Pe\ll 1$, which fall out of the scope of the analysis, is displayed as a dashed line. The regimes, labelled by their number $1$ to $4$ are specified in the text with the corresponding closed-form of the velocity enhancement. In (b), the regime 1 takes place for $1/2 \ll (16 L/\lambda )^{-1}$, i.e. $L/\lambda \ll 1/8$, while the remaining regimes $2$, $3$ and $4$ occur for the opposite condition $(16 L/\lambda )^{-1} \ll 1/2$, i.e. $L/\lambda \gg 1/8$. The red segments indicate the experimental range swept in this study, as specified in § 3.2.2.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Sketch of the chemical solution stirred by magnetohydrodynamic forcing. (a) Magnetohydrodynamic forcing results from Laplace forces induced by an electric current $\boldsymbol {j}$ flowing over alternate magnetic fields $\boldsymbol {B}$ induced by magnets. The solution fills a Hele-Shaw cell of depth $d=2$ mm much smaller than its width $l$ or its length. (b) Square lattice of vortices induced by square magnets of size $L$.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Images of front propagation at various vortex size $L$, channel width $l$ and thus number of vortices $n$ on this width. Reactants are dark blue (dark grey) and products are light blue (light grey). The reacting fronts stand at the frontier between the corresponding domains. They move from the light blue (reacted) domains to the dark blue (unreacted) domains so as to increase the former at the expense of the latter. The mean direction of propagation on these images is thus from left to right and, inside vortices, from the vortex periphery to the vortex centre. All images are $17$ cm long, irrespective of the channel length. Lines represent vortex length. (a) $L=5$ mm, $l=100$ mm, $n=20$; (b) $L=12$ mm, $l=144$ mm, $n=12$; (c) $L=15$ mm, $l=120$ mm, $n=8$; (d) $L=20$ mm, $l=100$ mm, $n=5$; (e) $L=40$ mm, $l=120$ mm, $n=3$; (f) $L=45$ mm, $l=135$ mm, $n=3$; (g) $L=48$ mm, $l=144$ mm, $n=3$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Plot of the whole data set with $U/V_0$ as abscissa and $V/V_0-1$ as ordinate for a given $L$. Data show a noticeable bending for $L=20$ mm (a) and slopes varying with $L$ (b). This suggests that different regimes are combined in the same plot with a possible scale dependence for some of them.

Figure 6

Table 2.Variable ranges experimentally scanned for each vortex size $L$. From (3.4), the front thickness $\lambda$ slightly evolves with $V_0$. Here $Pe_0=V_0 L/D$ denotes the value of $Pe$ at $U=V_0$ (3.6). By numerical analysis, a transition between regimes has been identified at $Da=O(1)$ between regime B ($Da\ll 1$) and regime C ($Da\gg 1)$) (figure 1 and § 2.4.1) (Vladimirova et al.2003). By theoretical analysis, a transition has been identified at $Da \ln (Pe) = O(1)$ between regime 2 ($Da \ln (Pe)\ll 1$) and regime 3 ($Da \ln (Pe) \gg 1$) (figure 2 and § 2.4.2) (Tzella & Vanneste 2015). The last two columns thus show that our data range a priori covers the former transition between regimes B and C and a priori only regime $3$.

Figure 7

Figure 6.(a) Here $Da>1$. For all vortex sizes $L$, slopes are much closer than in figure 5 and bending has disappeared. This makes data describe a master curve which validates scale invariance, as expected for $Da>1$ in regime C and regime 3. (b) Here $Da<1$. Main data refer to $L=5$ and $L=20$ mm. They exhibit a noticeable difference of rate of increase and a noticeable bending at $L=20$ mm. The first feature evidences a scale dependence, as expected for $Da<1$ in regimes B and $2$.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Here $Da >1$. (a) Power law fits of data $V/V_0-1 = a (U/V_0)^e$ with exponent either fixed to $e=3/4$ as in (2.13) (dotted line) or to $1$ (linear law, solid line) or free (dashed line). All fits agree with data with exponents and prefactors $(e, a)$ equal to $(3/4, 0.68)$, $(1, 0.25)$ and $(0.83, 0.49)$, respectively. (b) Plot of relation (2.15) of regime 3. Despite the absence of any fitting coefficient, it shows a nice agreement with data, except for a larger data bending at large $U/V_0$.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Here $Da >1$. The evolution of $V/V_0-1$ with $U/V_0$ is compensated by dividing data by the factor $(U/V_0)^{0.83}$ involved in the best fitting power law (figure 7a). This yields a quasistagnation with respect to $L/\lambda$, with a linear fit yielding $(V/V_0-1) (U/V_0)^{-0.83}= 0.46 + 0.001 L/\lambda$. This provides a quantitative test of scale invariance.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Here $Da <1$. (a) Power law fits of data $V/V_0-1 = a (U/V_0)^e$ at $L=5$ mm (dashed line) and $L=20$ mm (solid line). We obtain exponents and prefactors $(e, a)$ equal to $(0.62, 0.81)$ at $L=5$ mm and $(0.66, 1.03)$ at $L=20$ mm, respectively. Exponents are lower than in the $Da>1$ regime but far from the $1/4$ value expected in regime B or regime 2. (b) Power law fits of data with the expected exponent $e=1/4$ at $L=5$ mm (thin lines) and $L=20$ mm (thick lines), with (dashed lines) or without (solid lines) logarithmic correction, as in relations (2.12) and (2.14). The mean value $\overline {L/\lambda }$ of $L/\lambda$ determined from table 2 is used for relation (2.14): $\overline {L/\lambda }=3.3$ for $L=15$ mm and $\overline {L/\lambda }=12.5$ for $L=20$ mm. All fits largely disagree with data.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Here $Da<1$. Compensation of the mean power law evolution $(U/V_0)^{0.64}$ displayed by the best fitting power laws (figure 9a). The exponent $0.64$ stands as a mean between the actual close exponents $0.62$ and $0.66$ displayed in this figure. The noticeable variation in $L/\lambda$ evidences a scale dependence. Its linear fit (solid line) provides a noticeable slope, $37$ times larger than that displayed in figure 8: $(V/V_0-1) (U/V_0)^{-0.64}= 0.65 + 0.037 L/\lambda$. A power law variation in $(L/\lambda )^{3/4}$, although proposed by relations (2.12) and (2.14), is rejected by our data (dashed line). Instead, a power law fit $(V/V_0-1) (U/V_0)^{-0.64}= a (L/\lambda )^f$ gives $f=0.26$ as best fitting exponent (dotted line). Finally, a fit of a power law plus a shift $b$, $a (L/\lambda )^h + b$, yields as best fitting parameters $(a, b, h)=(0.031, 0.66, 1.06)$. This corresponds to the dashed–dotted line which, in our data range, is nearly undistinguishable from the linear fit.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Evolution of $Da \ln (Pe)$ with respect to $Da$. The vortex sizes that provide data in the $Da<1$ domain are $L=5, 12, 15$ and $20$ mm. The vertical line corresponds to $Da=1$. The horizontal line displays the largest value found for $T(L)=Da \ln (Pe)$ when $Da=1$, i.e. $T(48)=11.0$. Taking it as an onset value $T_g$ for $Da \ln (Pe)$, the quadrant A appears to be empty. This makes the domain $Da \ln (Pe) > T_g$ (composed of the quadrants A+B), to be restricted to quadrant B and thus to only a part of the domain $Da>1$ (composed of quadrants B+C). This ensures that the domain $Da \ln (Pe) > T_g$ refers to scale invariance, at least at the same level as the domain $Da>1$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Synthesis of the transition between scale-invariant ($Da>1$) and scale-dependent regimes ($Da<1$). (a) Experimental data are plotted as open symbols for $Da > 1$ and as full symbols for $Da < 1$. Numerical data from Vladimirova et al. (2003) are interpolated as thin lines for $Da>1$ and as thick lines for $Da<1$. For each of them, we indicate the corresponding value of $L/\lambda$ and affect the same colour as that of the experimental data referring to a similar $L/\lambda$ value. The relation (2.15) expected in regime 3 is shown as a thick orange line. The regimes B or 2, referring to the scale-dependent domain, and the regimes C or 3, referring to the scale-invariant domain, are indicated. (b) Sketch of the evolution between regimes for increasing $U/V_0$. One notices that the scale-invariant regime is bounded by a value of $U/V_0$ that depends on $L/\lambda$ and that the scale-dependent regime induces an intrinsic bending of the evolution of $V/V_0$ with $U/V_0$.

Bodea et al. Supplementary Movie 1

Front propagation at $U/V_0 =22.2$ in an array of vortices of size $L=5$mm involving $20$ vortices in their width. The movie is accelerated 12 times.

Download Bodea et al. Supplementary Movie 1(Video)
Video 3 MB

Bodea et al. Supplementary Movie 2

Front propagation at $U/V_0 = 50.8$ in an array of vortices of size $L=20$mm involving $5$ vortices in their width. The movie is accelerated 12 times.

Download Bodea et al. Supplementary Movie 2(Video)
Video 2.1 MB

Bodea et al. Supplementary Movie 3

Front propagation at $U/V_0 = 63.4$ in an array of vortices of size $L=40$mm involving $3$ vortices in their width. The movie is accelerated 12 times.

Download Bodea et al. Supplementary Movie 3(Video)
Video 2.4 MB