In Jordanian Jerusalem: Holy Places and National Spaces, Kimberly Katz undertakes a topic that has received little scholarly attention. This is the issue of the role of Jerusalem in the Jordanian government's construction of national identity and pursuit of legitimacy between 1948 and 1967. It is not the urban geography or demographic character of the city on which the author focuses, but the Jordanian government's representations of the city in shifting circumstances of domestic, inter-Arab, and international politics.
The author devotes particular attention to changing representations of Jerusalem on Jordanian and Transjordanian banknotes and postage stamps. While still under British control, Amir עAbdullah's administration endeavored to attain the accoutrements of sovereignty by issuing postal and revenue stamps. The images depicted upon them suggested continuity of the new dynasty with the country's distant past. Katz relates that, after gaining formal independence in 1946, the Transjordanian government represented itself as a champion of the Palestinian cause and issued stamps depicting Palestinian holy places, including Jerusalem's Dome of the Rock. However, after Transjordan annexed East Jerusalem and part of central Palestine in 1950, the new Jordanian administration suddenly dropped all official references to those areas as Palestine. In addition to designating central Palestine as the West Bank, Jordanian officials recast Jerusalem as a Jordanian holy city and one of several of the country's historical sites, which were represented on postal stamps and currency.
The book explores the Jordanian government's efforts to assert and gain international recognition of its sovereignty over East Jerusalem by initiating changes in the city's administration, despite that the United Nations Palestine partition resolution of 1947 had designated the city a corpus separatum under international trusteeship. The reader, thus, learns that King עAbdullah signaled his new authority in the city in 1950 by making an appointment to the office of Custodian of the Holy Places and by challenging the privileges of foreign consuls in the city. Similarly, King Hussein redistricted the city and its environs, appointing new officials, despite the concerned attention of the consular corps. By 1955, Katz tells us, the foreign consuls had accepted Jordan's de facto control of the city. The Jordanian government further demonstrated its authority in Jerusalem by intervening in the succession of patriarchs of the Armenian and Greek Orthodox churches, by taking responsibility for renovation of the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, and by extending Jordanian education law to foreign Christian schools, which were predominately located in Jerusalem. By promoting the city as a place of pilgrimage and tourism, the Jordanian government used the image of Jerusalem to identify Jordan before the international community as the Holy Land.
Katz also details how Jordan signaled to the Arab and Muslim worlds that Jerusalem was a Jordanian city. Thus, Jordan took responsibility for the restoration of the Dome of the Rock and, in 1964, hosted heads of Arab and Islamic states at the celebration of the completion of the project's first stage. The Jordanian government likewise converted the commemoration of the Prophet's Night Journey into a national celebration and an occasion to bring together Arab and Muslin leaders at Jerusalem's al-Haram al-Sharif. The author also briefly addresses the founding of the Palestine Liberation Organization in Jerusalem in 1964.
Katz makes some fascinating observations, especially about the relations of the European states to the Hashemite dynasty and Jerusalem. One learns, for example, that British advisers in 1916 prevented the Hijazi government from issuing postage stamps bearing the image of Sharif Husayn, because the advisers considered representations of humans as alien to Arab art. The author also reveals that, only a year before the 1956 Suez Crisis, the French government still attempted to preserve its rights in Jerusalem as a Great Power and Catholic power under the terms of the 1878 Treaty of Berlin.
Although the book has its share of keen insights, it has several shortcomings as well. First, its sources are thin. One can certainly sympathize with the author's predicament, because the Jordanian government has hardly thrown its archives open to research into such sensitive topics. Katz does use Jordanian government publications and British Foreign Office documents to good effect, but she does not use archival sources of the United States or France. Given that she characterizes the French consul as “the doyen of the consular corps” in Jerusalem, the lack of official French sources is conspicuous. Of more concern is the limited extent to which the author exploits the press of Jordan and other Arab states.
This last issue is directly related to a second limitation of the book. Although the author proposes pursuing a “relational approach” (p. 3) to her topic by taking into account the histories of other Arab states and the Palestinians, one learns little about either Palestinians in Jordan or about the question of Jerusalem in inter-Arab relations. The limited discussion of both matters is particularly evident in chapter 6, which is an account of the establishment of the Palestine Liberation Organization in 1964. The author mentions that King Hussein sought at the time to improve tense relations with Egypt's Gamal Abdel Nasser, but there is no discussion in the chapter of the Syrian and Iraqi Baעthist coups in 1963, of the Cairo negotiations on Arab unity the same year, or of the fact that Jordan then suppressed mass demonstrations by its citizens in support of Arab unity. Scarcely seven pages long, chapter 6 should have either been more thoroughly developed, or its material incorporated into another chapter. Finally, the book would have benefited by a conclusion.
In summary, Jordanian Jerusalem adds to our knowledge of the modern history of Jerusalem and Jordan. Although less than fully executed, the book is well conceived, and it represents a point of departure for future research on its topic.
