Virtual banks, virtual libraries, virtual reality … Virtual government? Latin America Online: Cases, Successes and Pitfalls examines the efforts of numerous national, regional and local governments in Latin America to place access to their data, services and developments on the internet. It presents a unique collection of over two dozen articles describing the nature and degree of such services with ample illustrations and tables. The authors are primarily specialists in information technology and/or public administration, working in government or academic posts in Latin America and the United States. The editor is a senior analyst at the International Institute on Governance of Catalonia. Most of the articles are country-specific studies; but interregional, intraregional and municipal developments also receive attention.
An overview of e-government in Latin America describes how, since the beginning of this century, the United Nations has been preparing surveys on global electronic-government resources and participation, evaluating 191 countries. The UN has identified several patterns and levels of electronic presence that Latin American governments provide. The most rudimentary stage is one-way or static, offering information and/or documents such as a directory of ministries or presidential speeches. Progressively, however, government web sites become more interactive, using transactional and networked operations. For example, at an advanced site, a citizen may be able not only to access documents explaining the bidding process for government contracts but also present and negotiate a bid interactively. Some sites may even include online discussion of policy to determine the bidding process.
The UN data show that on a comparative, worldwide, regional basis (as of 2004), Latin America had an e-government readiness index above Africa, several sub-regions of Asia, and Oceania, but below that of North America, Europe, and South and East Asia. Indeed, within Latin America itself, two tiers of e-government capacity exist. In the first tier, among the top 50 nations, are Chile, Mexico, Argentina, Brazil and Uruguay; while in the second tier, well below world averages, are Bolivia, Paraguay, Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua. However, not only is there an index of the physical infrastructure for e-government. A further index measures the extent to which the population can access what is provided, based on internet availability and knowledge of its use. For Latin America, the accessing capacity index generally falls somewhat below the readiness index, a gap known as the ‘digital divide’. The methodology for calculating the indices is clear in terms of the procedures for gathering and analysing data. However, the provenance of data is not uniformly clear, somewhat leaving open to question the standardisation of measures across numerous national and international statistical sources.
The opening half of the book consists of country-specific studies, the articles concentrating on a top-tier country. However, each article does so, not so much as a general survey of a country's e-government profile, but in regard to specific technical and/or policy issues. There is a description of the forum of Argentine public administration information technologists who act as a ‘back office’ community of practice integrating cross-agency policy and techniques. The examination of Brazil focuses on e-government's effectiveness in increasing transparency and efficiency in government procurement operations and its role in state reform. Chile is the top-rated country for e-government in Latin America and the article on it focuses on the policy formation process. For Mexico, its state government portals are studied. There is also an examination of the origin and impact of e-government strategies in Argentina, Chile and Uruguay.
The final half of the book concentrates on municipal e-government. It is at this level that one finds some of the most sophisticated and advanced e-government structures. Not surprisingly, Buenos Aires, São Paulo and Santiago are the focus of attention. The study of Buenos Aires focuses in even more detail, advancing to e-government in the communes and neighbourhoods of the city. Capital cities have not only the technical capacity and human capital for such advances, but also an acute sense of and need for corporate community deliberation and action. In evaluating the municipal sites, not only content and services are analysed but also privacy and security, usability and citizen participation.
Latin America Online offers a comprehensive quantitative profile of e-government in Latin America. It highlights the methods, resources and operations of top-tier countries and cities. However, it does not examine the causes or nature of inadequacies in low-tier countries. Moreover, and quite intriguingly, it does not examine why a poorly ranked low-tier country, such as Honduras, would have a highly ranked municipal e-government in its capital, Tegucigalpa.
Latin America Online provides a detailed yet introductory survey of a phenomenon that will be steadily increasing. It maps the initial stages of the phenomenon of e-government in Latin America. As such services develop beyond curiosity and become key resources on which citizens regularly rely, the phenomenon will generate further works. These studies will require elaboration of issues related to methodology for index calculations, examinations of the inequality of development in the provision and accessing of e-government, and a review of the nature of political control in e-governance.
Analysis of the penetration of political factors in e-government promises to be especially important. For the United States, one study that already examines this situation is New Media Campaigns and the Managed Citizen by Philip N. Howard (Cambridge University Press, 2006). It is an alert regarding the extent to which information technologists manoeuvre a political campaign. Gathering the data we daily discard in numerous electronic transactions, they create virtual political profiles of constituents. With these profiles, they can prepare messages to survey, massage or manipulate recipients appropriately. Just as there has been caution historically about government control of national communications or education, so also the political control a government may be able to exercise over its electronic or virtual extension in the future will become an issue as urgent in Latin America as the rest of the world.
