As I read the focal article (Kath etal., Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) I contemplated how I as an industrial and organizational (I-O) psychologist who leads an office of career and professional development (widely categorized and known as career services in many other colleges and universities) use I-O psychology research in our work in educating students. Furthermore, I thought about how career services could influence I-O psychology teaching in the more formal traditional classroom. I believe this notion is overlooked in the focal article, and I argue that a perspective from career services should be considered in the teaching of I-O psychology to undergraduate students.
The mission of our own Career and Professional Development office is to educate and empower all students to translate experiential learning to the professional world as it is going to be. Many career services offices have similar missions that resemble the broader mission of career readiness. The National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE) defines career readiness as “the attainment and demonstration of requisite competencies that broadly prepare college graduates for a successful transition into the workplace” (NACE, n.d.). Typically, we in career services may help students in individual, group, and programmatic settings with issues such as career and major exploration; resume preparation, LinkedIn profiles, and cover letter preparation; mock interviews; internship and job searches and corresponding applications; and graduate school applications. In addition, we provide services and programs for students; we educate students through one-on-one appointments, workshops, and seminars around I-O-related topics such as diversity, teamwork, selection processes, interviewing, work–life balance, career management, feedback, and goal setting and leadership topics such as influence, motivation, and communication.
Our goal in career services is undoubtedly shared with the viewpoints of the focal article: Students must learn about I-O psychology because they will be leading, hiring, training, and working with others in the future. Clearly, knowledge from I-O psychology is relevant in shaping, guiding, and inspiring our work. I argue that we in career services also educate students about I-O psychology indirectly through these approaches. Our “classroom” may not be what Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) thought about when they were writing the focal article. We obviously don’t have a syllabus or tests or quizzes or set lectures to discuss I-O topics in a classroom setting for 2–3 hr a week for 16 or so weeks as would be typical in the teaching of I-O psychology as a class. Furthermore, the students that we serve are not all psychology majors, and some may not even know (or care about) what I-O psychology is. But career services can be seen as another constituent that educates students about I-O topics in a real-world application of what is being learned.
With this stated position, I contend that some of the ideas that Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) proposed as changes that instructors can make in teaching I-O psychology may need to be altered when one considers the small number of opportunities that we in career services have with students. In turn, I put forth some thoughts to consider how I-O research has shaped our work in career services at our university through two examples (training and development and developmental relationships). Further, I discuss how those examples could shape the teaching of I-O psychology in the more formal, traditional classroom setting of an I-O psychology class.
Training and development
Students who use career services may not use it regularly or consistently. Oftentimes, they may come to us one or two times a year (or only once, right before they graduate, hoping for a job). Thus we need to ensure that our offerings and programs are in line with their needs and desires. A needs assessment (Noe, Reference Noe2020) clearly is necessary. We do so focusing on perceived utility and content relevance (Burke & Hutchins, Reference Burke and Hutchins2007; Roszkowski & Soven, Reference Roszkowski and Soven2010).
First, we poll our student body several times a year to determine what topics they want us to cover. We want to know from our students what interests them because research shows that the expectations of the learner must be taken into consideration (Bouloutian, Reference Bouloutian2009; Tannenbaum etal., Reference Tannenbaum, Mathieu, Salas and Cannon-Bowers1991). Second, we take the opinion of employers into account, as they are the ones who are hiring students. We work with our employer partners regularly and ask them what knowledge, skills, and abilities they are looking for in candidates. In addition, research from NACE (n.d.) based on the opinions of those in the career services and HR/staffing fields reveals several competencies that are needed to prepare college students for the workplace (critical thinking/problem solving, oral/written communications, teamwork/collaboration, digital technology, leadership, professionalism/work ethic, career management, and global/intercultural fluency). We then make sure that the content we discuss during one-on-one appointments or teach in programs and seminars corresponds to these viewpoints.
From the I-O literature, if the content is not relevant or directly related to the challenges one currently has, then satisfaction and transfer of training will be low (Ardts etal., Reference Ardts, van der Velde and Maurer2010; Gentry etal., Reference Gentry, Eckert, Munusamy, Stawiski and Martin2014; Scaduto etal., Reference Scaduto, Lindsay and Chiaburu2008). We may see similar results if we don’t account for these conclusions in our work. From a career services perspective, I would therefore suggest that those who are teaching I-O psychology in the classroom take into account the learners' perspectives and what they will need in the professional world. For instance, take a poll at the beginning of the semester to determine what subjects or content the students are most excited about or see as most relevant for their future careers. With that knowledge, craft the semester-long class to go more in-depth with those topics and emphasize certain parts of the curriculum to meet those needs and to maximize satisfaction and transfer. Also, show the relevance of what is learned based on the opinions of those who are actively working in the field, and tailor the amount of time that is devoted to those topics accordingly.
Developmental relationships
Given that we in career services (compared with a typical semester-long class) have a small amount of time to educate our students either through one-on-one appointments or seminars and workshops, we need to make the most of our limited time with students (particularly if it is a one-time visit). Research from the developmental relationships literature influences the way we educate our students and could influence the teaching of I-O psychology classes as well.
When I reference developmental relationships, I am primarily focusing on coaching and mentoring. While there is a difference in what coaches do versus what mentors do (see Gentry, Reference Gentry, Riddle, Hoole and Gullette2015; Murphy & Kram, Reference Murphy and Kram2014), research does note qualities and characteristics that successful mentors and coaches have that could be applicable to career advisors in career services or teachers in the classroom. For instance, motivation (Burke & McKeen, Reference Burke and McKeen1989; Eddy etal., Reference Eddy, Tannenbaum, Alliger, D’Abate and Givens2001) readiness (Allen,Poteet, Russell, etal., Reference Allen, Poteet, Russell and Dobbins1997; Allen, Russell, etal., Reference Allen, Russell and Maetzke1997; Ragins & Scandura, Reference Ragins and Scandura1999) and personal qualities such as empathy and trustworthiness (Allen, Reference Allen2003; Allen, Poteet, & Burroughs, Reference Allen, Poteet and Burroughs1997; Catalyst, 1993; Cunningham, Reference Cunningham1993; Eddy etal., Reference Eddy, Tannenbaum, Alliger, D’Abate and Givens2001; Messmer, Reference Messmer2001; Tyler, Reference Tyler1998) were important for mentors to have. Being adaptable, credible, relationship focused, and open were characteristics of coaches (Gentry etal., Reference Gentry, Allen, Wolf, Manning and Hernez-Broome2011). These types of qualities and characteristics are important to have for us in advising, counseling, training, developing, and educating our students, whether it is one-on-one or in seminar/workshop settings. I encourage faculty to consider these qualities and characteristics not only in the classroom but particularly during office hours and one-on-one meetings with students that may occur outside the classroom.
Our work is also influenced by research on peer mentoring (Murphy & Kram, Reference Murphy and Kram2014; Smith-Jentsch etal., Reference Smith-Jentsch, Scielzo, Yarbrough and Rosopa2008) and developmental networks (Dobrow etal., Reference Dobrow, Chandler, Murphy and Kram2012; Ghosh etal., Reference Ghosh, Haynes and Kram2013; Murphy & Kram, Reference Murphy and Kram2014). In our Office of Career and Professional Development we employ juniors and seniors to work with students in resume, cover letter, or LinkedIn profile development. These peer career advisors (PCAs) do not do the work for the student in need (i.e., they do not write the resume or cover letter). Instead, these PCAs work side by side with the student to coach, advise, and educate the student on how to make these documents stand out. Learning from one’s peers is an important aspect of the development and education of our students. Our office also encourages students to think about how important their own network is to getting help and support, which mirrors the importance of developmental networks in one’s own life. Having a “constellation of relationships” (Higgins & Kram, Reference Higgins and Kram2001) is an important aspect of supporting one’s development and education.
The discussion of peer mentoring and developmental networks provides two unique ways in which I-O psychology has influenced our work in career and professional development, which may in turn influence the teaching of I-O psychology to a classroom of students. First, I would suggest that teachers explore how peers could help students. Could students from previous semesters come in and provide peer mentoring to the current students in how to study, how to operate in teams for projects, how to make a great presentation, or other important parts of the class? In terms of developmental networks, could other parties (such as career services, alumni, employers, supervisors of student internships, HR representatives of companies) be part of the education and development of students during the class? Could they come in and provide coaching, mentoring, insight into fields of study, or examples of how the content is applicable to the professional world outside of the classroom?
Conclusion
In laying out how I-O psychology has played a role in how we operate, I hope you will strongly consider how career services could influence the teaching of I-O psychology to undergraduate students. Being an I-O psychologist in a career services office is a unique and wonderful opportunity for me personally. I am able to put into practice my own research on leadership and leadership development and implement what I read about and know in selection, careers, vocational, and business literatures from the I-O psychology field into our Office of Career and Professional Development. Moreover, it provides me an opportunity to directly make a difference with future entry-level employees who will eventually fill the leadership pipeline and become leaders in industry.
I hope that we in career services can be seen as a viable extension of what is taught in the classroom. I hope you can find allies and partners in career services offices to enhance transfer of what is being learned in the classroom for the benefit of career readiness of students.
As I read the focal article (Kath etal., Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) I contemplated how I as an industrial and organizational (I-O) psychologist who leads an office of career and professional development (widely categorized and known as career services in many other colleges and universities) use I-O psychology research in our work in educating students. Furthermore, I thought about how career services could influence I-O psychology teaching in the more formal traditional classroom. I believe this notion is overlooked in the focal article, and I argue that a perspective from career services should be considered in the teaching of I-O psychology to undergraduate students.
The mission of our own Career and Professional Development office is to educate and empower all students to translate experiential learning to the professional world as it is going to be. Many career services offices have similar missions that resemble the broader mission of career readiness. The National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE) defines career readiness as “the attainment and demonstration of requisite competencies that broadly prepare college graduates for a successful transition into the workplace” (NACE, n.d.). Typically, we in career services may help students in individual, group, and programmatic settings with issues such as career and major exploration; resume preparation, LinkedIn profiles, and cover letter preparation; mock interviews; internship and job searches and corresponding applications; and graduate school applications. In addition, we provide services and programs for students; we educate students through one-on-one appointments, workshops, and seminars around I-O-related topics such as diversity, teamwork, selection processes, interviewing, work–life balance, career management, feedback, and goal setting and leadership topics such as influence, motivation, and communication.
Our goal in career services is undoubtedly shared with the viewpoints of the focal article: Students must learn about I-O psychology because they will be leading, hiring, training, and working with others in the future. Clearly, knowledge from I-O psychology is relevant in shaping, guiding, and inspiring our work. I argue that we in career services also educate students about I-O psychology indirectly through these approaches. Our “classroom” may not be what Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) thought about when they were writing the focal article. We obviously don’t have a syllabus or tests or quizzes or set lectures to discuss I-O topics in a classroom setting for 2–3 hr a week for 16 or so weeks as would be typical in the teaching of I-O psychology as a class. Furthermore, the students that we serve are not all psychology majors, and some may not even know (or care about) what I-O psychology is. But career services can be seen as another constituent that educates students about I-O topics in a real-world application of what is being learned.
With this stated position, I contend that some of the ideas that Kath etal. (Reference Kath, Salter, Bachiochi, Brown and Hebl2021) proposed as changes that instructors can make in teaching I-O psychology may need to be altered when one considers the small number of opportunities that we in career services have with students. In turn, I put forth some thoughts to consider how I-O research has shaped our work in career services at our university through two examples (training and development and developmental relationships). Further, I discuss how those examples could shape the teaching of I-O psychology in the more formal, traditional classroom setting of an I-O psychology class.
Training and development
Students who use career services may not use it regularly or consistently. Oftentimes, they may come to us one or two times a year (or only once, right before they graduate, hoping for a job). Thus we need to ensure that our offerings and programs are in line with their needs and desires. A needs assessment (Noe, Reference Noe2020) clearly is necessary. We do so focusing on perceived utility and content relevance (Burke & Hutchins, Reference Burke and Hutchins2007; Roszkowski & Soven, Reference Roszkowski and Soven2010).
First, we poll our student body several times a year to determine what topics they want us to cover. We want to know from our students what interests them because research shows that the expectations of the learner must be taken into consideration (Bouloutian, Reference Bouloutian2009; Tannenbaum etal., Reference Tannenbaum, Mathieu, Salas and Cannon-Bowers1991). Second, we take the opinion of employers into account, as they are the ones who are hiring students. We work with our employer partners regularly and ask them what knowledge, skills, and abilities they are looking for in candidates. In addition, research from NACE (n.d.) based on the opinions of those in the career services and HR/staffing fields reveals several competencies that are needed to prepare college students for the workplace (critical thinking/problem solving, oral/written communications, teamwork/collaboration, digital technology, leadership, professionalism/work ethic, career management, and global/intercultural fluency). We then make sure that the content we discuss during one-on-one appointments or teach in programs and seminars corresponds to these viewpoints.
From the I-O literature, if the content is not relevant or directly related to the challenges one currently has, then satisfaction and transfer of training will be low (Ardts etal., Reference Ardts, van der Velde and Maurer2010; Gentry etal., Reference Gentry, Eckert, Munusamy, Stawiski and Martin2014; Scaduto etal., Reference Scaduto, Lindsay and Chiaburu2008). We may see similar results if we don’t account for these conclusions in our work. From a career services perspective, I would therefore suggest that those who are teaching I-O psychology in the classroom take into account the learners' perspectives and what they will need in the professional world. For instance, take a poll at the beginning of the semester to determine what subjects or content the students are most excited about or see as most relevant for their future careers. With that knowledge, craft the semester-long class to go more in-depth with those topics and emphasize certain parts of the curriculum to meet those needs and to maximize satisfaction and transfer. Also, show the relevance of what is learned based on the opinions of those who are actively working in the field, and tailor the amount of time that is devoted to those topics accordingly.
Developmental relationships
Given that we in career services (compared with a typical semester-long class) have a small amount of time to educate our students either through one-on-one appointments or seminars and workshops, we need to make the most of our limited time with students (particularly if it is a one-time visit). Research from the developmental relationships literature influences the way we educate our students and could influence the teaching of I-O psychology classes as well.
When I reference developmental relationships, I am primarily focusing on coaching and mentoring. While there is a difference in what coaches do versus what mentors do (see Gentry, Reference Gentry, Riddle, Hoole and Gullette2015; Murphy & Kram, Reference Murphy and Kram2014), research does note qualities and characteristics that successful mentors and coaches have that could be applicable to career advisors in career services or teachers in the classroom. For instance, motivation (Burke & McKeen, Reference Burke and McKeen1989; Eddy etal., Reference Eddy, Tannenbaum, Alliger, D’Abate and Givens2001) readiness (Allen,Poteet, Russell, etal., Reference Allen, Poteet, Russell and Dobbins1997; Allen, Russell, etal., Reference Allen, Russell and Maetzke1997; Ragins & Scandura, Reference Ragins and Scandura1999) and personal qualities such as empathy and trustworthiness (Allen, Reference Allen2003; Allen, Poteet, & Burroughs, Reference Allen, Poteet and Burroughs1997; Catalyst, 1993; Cunningham, Reference Cunningham1993; Eddy etal., Reference Eddy, Tannenbaum, Alliger, D’Abate and Givens2001; Messmer, Reference Messmer2001; Tyler, Reference Tyler1998) were important for mentors to have. Being adaptable, credible, relationship focused, and open were characteristics of coaches (Gentry etal., Reference Gentry, Allen, Wolf, Manning and Hernez-Broome2011). These types of qualities and characteristics are important to have for us in advising, counseling, training, developing, and educating our students, whether it is one-on-one or in seminar/workshop settings. I encourage faculty to consider these qualities and characteristics not only in the classroom but particularly during office hours and one-on-one meetings with students that may occur outside the classroom.
Our work is also influenced by research on peer mentoring (Murphy & Kram, Reference Murphy and Kram2014; Smith-Jentsch etal., Reference Smith-Jentsch, Scielzo, Yarbrough and Rosopa2008) and developmental networks (Dobrow etal., Reference Dobrow, Chandler, Murphy and Kram2012; Ghosh etal., Reference Ghosh, Haynes and Kram2013; Murphy & Kram, Reference Murphy and Kram2014). In our Office of Career and Professional Development we employ juniors and seniors to work with students in resume, cover letter, or LinkedIn profile development. These peer career advisors (PCAs) do not do the work for the student in need (i.e., they do not write the resume or cover letter). Instead, these PCAs work side by side with the student to coach, advise, and educate the student on how to make these documents stand out. Learning from one’s peers is an important aspect of the development and education of our students. Our office also encourages students to think about how important their own network is to getting help and support, which mirrors the importance of developmental networks in one’s own life. Having a “constellation of relationships” (Higgins & Kram, Reference Higgins and Kram2001) is an important aspect of supporting one’s development and education.
The discussion of peer mentoring and developmental networks provides two unique ways in which I-O psychology has influenced our work in career and professional development, which may in turn influence the teaching of I-O psychology to a classroom of students. First, I would suggest that teachers explore how peers could help students. Could students from previous semesters come in and provide peer mentoring to the current students in how to study, how to operate in teams for projects, how to make a great presentation, or other important parts of the class? In terms of developmental networks, could other parties (such as career services, alumni, employers, supervisors of student internships, HR representatives of companies) be part of the education and development of students during the class? Could they come in and provide coaching, mentoring, insight into fields of study, or examples of how the content is applicable to the professional world outside of the classroom?
Conclusion
In laying out how I-O psychology has played a role in how we operate, I hope you will strongly consider how career services could influence the teaching of I-O psychology to undergraduate students. Being an I-O psychologist in a career services office is a unique and wonderful opportunity for me personally. I am able to put into practice my own research on leadership and leadership development and implement what I read about and know in selection, careers, vocational, and business literatures from the I-O psychology field into our Office of Career and Professional Development. Moreover, it provides me an opportunity to directly make a difference with future entry-level employees who will eventually fill the leadership pipeline and become leaders in industry.
I hope that we in career services can be seen as a viable extension of what is taught in the classroom. I hope you can find allies and partners in career services offices to enhance transfer of what is being learned in the classroom for the benefit of career readiness of students.