On 4 July 2007 the bilingual Turkish-Judeo-Spanish weekly, Şalom, the last remaining journal that serves the Jewish community in Turkey, dedicated its first page to the centennial of the Beth Israel synagogue in Izmir. Opened to the public in 1907 in the Karataş neighborhood, the synagogue has been since its foundation a testimony to the community's wish to present itself as modern and successful. Unlike many other synagogues in Turkey, Beth Israel is still functioning as an active place of worship serving the contemporary, modest Jewish community of Izmir, which harbors about 1,500 people. The current community represents only a small fraction of the community that built the Beth Israel synagogue at the beginning of the 20th century. Furthermore, living as a miniscule non-Muslim minority in a city of about three million inhabitants, the Jewish community and its different institutes are only a vestige remaining from the multireligious and multiethnic city that once was Izmir—or Smyrna, as the city was known to its Greek inhabitants and in the West.
The image, or rather the myth of gavur Smyrna (“infidel Izmir”), is one of the recurring images representing the late Ottoman period. It portrays late Ottoman Izmir as a multiethnic bustling port city in which Turks, Greeks, Armenians, Jews, and Europeans peacefully cohabited. Izmir's fine harbor, its fertile hinterland, the resourcefulness of its inhabitants, and the presence of European merchants turned the city into a major economic center serving the Ottoman Empire. Its self-confident inhabitants invested their wealth in turning Izmir into a modern metropolis that could compete with major European cities.
This opulence came to a brisk end with the demise of the Ottoman state and its division among several nation–states. Although such a sinister destiny was shared by other Ottoman port cities, it seems that the downfall of Izmir stands out as the city and its prosperous heritage were rendered to ashes during a four-day blaze in 1922 that consumed its economic area as well as the Greek, Armenian, and European parts of the city. The destruction of Smyrna was not a gradual process but rather a swift disaster caused by men who totally ravaged the city and later relegated it into oblivion.
During the past two decades, several studies—such as those written by Daniel Goffman, Suraiya Faroqhi, Yaakov Barnai, Elena Frangakis-Syrett, Necmi Ülker, Marie-Carmen Smyrnelis, and others—have successfully deconstructed these images of Izmir. By using mostly European sources, these studies follow the development of Izmir into a major Ottoman port city. They mostly explore the two periods that marked the city's prominence under Ottoman rule: the rise of Izmir as a major port city in the 16th and early 17th centuries and, later, its role in Ottoman integration into the world economic system in the 19th century. In both cases, the emphasis was put on the city's economic history and the identity of its inhabitants as migrants who arrived in Izmir to avail themselves of the economic opportunities.
Furthermore, unlike the case of other major Ottoman cities, the near total loss of the local sicil—the kadi court records—in flames prevented the use of this important source that enables the study of numerous aspects of the social life in the Ottoman city. In the absence of the sicil, scholars have had to rely on European sources as well as on those compiled by the local non-Muslims, mostly Greeks. The result is that although the economic dimension of Izmir's rise has been amply discussed, its social matrix is often still presented in clichés that put forward only part of the story.
Hervé Georgelin's book, based on his dissertation, aims precisely to study the social aspects of Izmir in the late Ottoman period until the outbreak of World War I (1870–1914). The book's major contribution lies in the use of new sources, previously ignored or only marginally used, among them the records of the national Armenian delegation and oral testimonies collected during the 1960s and 1970s among Greeks originating from Izmir who settled in Greece after the catastrophe of 1922. These testimonies are kept today in the Center for Study of Asia Minor in Athens. They enable the author to retrieve different voices from the Greek community and therefore to enhance and diversify our knowledge of the largest community that inhabited Izmir prior to 1922.
Georgelin studies these sources well aware of their advantages and flaws. He critically explores their discourses and offers the reader a well-written book that is particularly dedicated to the study of Greeks who opted to adopt European manners and perceptions. Their different paths to Westernization and their reflections on everyday life are clearly presented through the study of individual memoirs or the photos that those Izmirlis of Greek origin left behind. Their major institutions of acculturation—different schools and their curricula, religious festivals, and sites of leisure and entertainment—receive their due place. The influence of new European trends on the structure of the family and gender relations are likewise discussed in depth.
The last part of the book is devoted to political changes and their influences on the Greek and Armenian populations living in Izmir. The Hamidian period, the “spirit of 1908,” the Balkan wars, and the ensuing exclusionist policy vis-à-vis non-Muslim populations lead the reader to the great fire of 1922. The deportation of its Christian population, the settlement of Muslim refugees from the Balkans in their place, and the reconstruction of the city according to a new plan render republican Izmir a totally different city from multiethnic Smyrna.
Georgelin's book is an important contribution to our knowledge of the Greek and Armenian communities of Izmir. The other communities who inhabited Izmir, or even those Greeks who did not avidly embrace Westernization, are surely present in the book. However, their voices remain marginal. This is especially true with regard to the local Turkish community, which is presented merely through the mediation of Western and Greek sources. As justification for his decision to concentrate on non-Turkish sources, Georgelin mentions the loss of the sicil (although some files covering the second half of the 19th century did survive the vicissitudes of time).
Although the sicil is certainly a major source for the study of Ottoman societies, its importance greatly decreases with regard to the second half of the 19th century. Late 19th-century judicial reforms largely limited the legal and administrative responsibilities and functions of the Muslim court. The sicil clearly reflects this marginalization. Therefore, the study of the Turkish-speaking population of the late Ottoman period needs to rely more on other sources compiled by Turkish-speaking Muslims—especially those representing new cultural products, such as the press, memoirs, literature, theater, and so forth. Such texts are available. Moreover, disregarding the Turkish sources does not imply merely omitting one ethnic group but also ignoring the state and its various local agents. Due to the increasing power of the state to intervene in the regulation of urban space during the late Ottoman period, such omission limits the ability of the book to present a general and a coherent picture of Izmir.
Indeed, writing the urban history of Ottoman cities necessitates mastering several indigenous languages. As such, an acquaintance with all the different languages is certainly beyond the capacity of most scholars; the idea to divide such a project among several scholars seems a very fruitful endeavor. This logic stands behind Smyrne, la ville oubliée? 1830–1930. This volume, edited by Marie-Carmen Smyrnelis, appears in the series Collections Mémoire, published by Editions Autrement. Like previous publications of Autrement, this collection of articles includes papers written by leading scholars in the field who explore from different perspectives the topic of the volume—Izmir and its inhabitants in the face of the swift changes and challenges of the 19th century.
Designated for general readers as well as academics, this book is accompanied by contemporary postcards, maps, and a detailed glossary and chronology that help the reader to navigate in the troubled waters of Izmir's history. Some of the authors contribute papers that summarize their own previous studies; others contribute the fruits of recent studies. The result is, by and large, a well-written and innovative volume that successfully incorporates different voices from late Ottoman Izmir. Some of the articles follow the ethnic division that characterizes the historiography of many Ottoman cities; others try to look at the city as a whole. Although all the authors tackle the new challenges that characterize the long 19th century, they use different sources and methods to delineate the different, sometimes contradictory, responses. The scope here is too small to give each paper its appropriate place; therefore, I give only a few examples that attest to the volume's merits.
To begin, the editor made two important decisions while organizing this volume. First, she did not bring the discussion to an end with the traumatic events of 1922 but rather chose to include two papers that explore the development of republican Izmir (Cana Bilsel and Alp Yücel Kaya) out of the debris of Ottoman Smyrna. These two papers, while not diminishing the scale of devastation caused to the Christian population of Izmir, nevertheless also retrace the continuity that connects “infidel” Smyrna with republican Izmir. This could be found, for example, in the reluctance of republican Izmirlis to accept state authority and intervention in local economy or in the nostalgia felt among modern Izmirlis toward their city's past.
Second, the editor made the decision to begin the part of the volume that deals with the different communities inhabiting Izmir with the Muslim community (Fikret Yilmaz). Although this chapter is unfortunately written in the format of an interview rather than as an academic study, it nevertheless gives a voice to the Muslim community that is often omitted from studies on Izmir.
The paper of Vangelis Kechriotis convincingly shows the diversity inside the Greek community, or rather, communities. There were local Rums and Hellenes, long-established Turcophone Greeks and newly arriving immigrants from the Aegean islands, those who associated themselves with traditional institutions like the church and those who searched for new venues in which to display their newly gained wealth and to receive legitimacy. The accompanying competition over power and legitimacy was reflected, for example, in the construction of charitable and educational institutions. Often presented as powerful merchants benefiting from European support, the so-called Levantines stand at the center of a chapter written by Oliver Jens Schmitt. By using church records, Schmitt demonstrates the diversity of this significant group that was united only by confession and alleged European origin. Not all of them were wealthy merchants: some were small artisans, day laborers, or just “poor” people, as they were qualified in the records. Bereft of any clear national affiliation to a particular nation–state, they were often the first victims of nationalism. The deportation of Italian citizens, some of them living for generations in Izmir, back to their “homeland” following the outbreak of the Italian–Ottoman war over Libya (1911) and the cold reception that those deportees received upon their arrival to Naples demonstrates their awkward position.
The intensive encounters with the West (sometimes made possible through the mediation of Istanbul or Athens) and their influences on the local populations stand at the center of two papers (Basma Zerouali and Sibel Zandi-Sayek). Zerouali describes Izmir as cite métisse, a real crucible that shaped the literature and art produced in the city. She finds the best examples for this cultural mélange in the realm of popular music composed by local Izmirlis coming from all ethnic groups. Zandi-Sayek uses press reports related to two festivals that were part of the year calendar in Izmir: the Catholic Fête-Dieu and the coronation of a new sultan. On both occasions, the festivals were marked mainly by public processions. She claims that these two festivals should be regarded not merely as a time of rejoicing and popular entertainment but should also represent important political arenas in which different communal identities were publicly displayed and defined while claiming a place in the public sphere at times of continuous changes.
These are only a few examples that demonstrate the significance of this volume to the study of late Ottoman Izmir. Back in 1992 Gilles Veinstein published a similar volume on late Ottoman Salonica. Likewise published by Autrement in the Série Mémoires, this volume became one of the major textbooks that delineate Salonica from different perspectives and angles. The volume was later translated into Turkish and Greek and encouraged further research of Ottoman Salonica. I believe that this volume on Izmir will gain similar success in the near future.
