No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
This fascinating book explores the relationship between Egypt and Ethiopia from early history through the end of the 20th century. By focusing on the significance of the Nile to both of these countries, this study reveals a rare sensitivity to the force of geography on cultural relations. Haggai Erlich offers rich insights into how Ethiopia and Egypt saw each other bilaterally and how each related to Africa and the Middle East in general. For those looking for historical works that explore the often ignored intertwining of African and Middle Eastern history, this work will provide a great deal of information.
Erlich traces several important themes through this history, the most important being that, as he writes, “this is a story of mutual dependence, but it is also a story of broken eye contact.” Egypt and Ethiopia had been in close contact with each other since ancient times, and the foundation of the Coptic church tied the two countries together with spiritual bonds. Co-believers, however, did not view the Nile with the same eyes. Because the Nile originated in Ethiopia, Egyptians in the 5th and 6th centuries were often suspicious that their neighbors could and would threaten the flow of the Nile. However, Ethiopians were concerned that the Nile could carry Egyptian aggression on boats. The idea of Egypt's heralded historic rights to the great river implied a threat to these Ethiopians. Because of the river's mythic powers, each country became that much more powerful in the other's eyes.
This introduces a second and equally important theme of the book: the creation of each other into the “other.” As Erlich describes it, this otherness did not begin with Islam's increasing influence in northern and eastern Africa but was certainly exacerbated by it, especially during medieval times. Even though parts of contested territories such as Eritrea gained Muslim inhabitants, Ethiopia's emperors increasingly saw themselves as warriors for the Coptic faith, wary of Egyptian Islamic encroachment. Erlich also traces how medieval Egyptian Muslims framed Ethiopia in Islamic history, sometimes praising the Ethiopian negus for his support of the anṣār of the Prophet Muhammad and at other times criticizing Ethiopia for persecution of the region's Muslims.
The increasing consciousness about things “Oriental” and things “African” during the 19th century further elucidates and complicates these themes. Muhammad

Ali's irrigation projects in Egypt were perceived as deeply menacing in Ethiopia. The Khedive Ismail took it even further with his emphasis on Egyptian territorial expansion in Sudan and Ethiopia. The emperors of Ethiopia—Menelik, then Yohannes IV—met these challenges by building up their armies and defeating Ismail's soldiers in 1876. The loss of the Ethiopian wars never healed among many soldiers in the Egyptian army, and this sore point was raised during the Urabi rebellion. It is very interesting how during these years Egyptians were encouraged not to identify with Sub-Saharan Africa. As Erlich shows, this question of cultural identity was not easy for the Ethiopians, many of whom still saw themselves as part of the East, not of Africa. Despite these wars, there remained the great link of the Coptic church and the fact that the abuna, or head of the Ethiopian church, was always picked from Egyptian priests.
Here lies one of the few weaknesses of this otherwise thorough work—the lack of discussion of the role slavery played in the relationship between Egypt and Ethiopia, particularly during the 19th century. Erlich writes with great care about constructions of racial identity that this reviewer thinks could only have been strengthened with an exploration of what slavery did to African or racial identity among both Ethiopians and Egyptians. Nor is it ever quite clear how Erlich defines “African-ness.” This oversight may have come about because Erlich creates a dialogue in each chapter between Ethiopian and Egyptian authors and texts, a discussion in which slaves are rarely, if ever, authors themselves. It is only in this chapter that this reliance on written texts results in omission; it works extremely well in the other chapters.
The finest example of this type of narration occurs in Erlich's discussion of the late 20th century and his juxtaposition of Gamal Abdel Nasser and Haile Selassie. Erlich presents a fascinating portrait of the cultural voyages made by the Ethiopian emperor. The chapters on this ruler provide one of the most interesting biographies of Haile Selassie this reader has seen and gracefully relate how he tried to negotiate not only with Nasser himself, but also with the symbolism the Egyptian president used so strategically.
In a political world where it is becoming incumbent on those who teach African or Middle Eastern or religious history to renegotiate the boundaries of the areas we explore, this book would make an excellent addition to the syllabi. Clearly and elegantly written, it offers a crucial view into history usually glimpsed only by historians of the Middle East.