Nora Goldschmidt's Afterlives of the Roman Poets is a welcome addition to the recent, and growing, interest in recognising the value of ancient poetic Lives and their blurring of reality and fiction, seen not as an index of unreliability but as evidence of how they were read and understood by ancient audiences. (See B. Graziosi, Inventing Homer: The Early Reception of Epic (2002) and N. Goldschmidt and Graziosi (eds.), Tombs of the Ancient Poets: Between Literary Reception and Material Culture (2018) — the latter, like this book, originating in the ERC project Living Poets: A New Approach to Ancient Poetry, directed by Graziosi). G. argues that Roman poets encoded their lives in their poetry — a form of autofiction — as well as the lives of other poets — a form of biofiction. The poems were themselves read in the light of the (largely fictional) lives of their authors. Extrapolated from the poetry, lives acquire new anecdotes, events and interpretations as they are read, re-read and rewritten through the following centuries, branching into new traditions which are then taken as authoritative. Thus biofiction, imbricated from the start with autofiction, is placed firmly within the reception history of poetic texts from antiquity all the way to the present, and proves to be ‘a tenacious and adaptive mode of reception’ (21).
After an Introduction that lays the historical and theoretical foundations, the book progresses through successive periods in a series of ‘test cases’ (185). We encounter medieval manuscripts that focus in particular on Ovid, the poet whose work displays ‘autofictional obsessions’ (35) and whose life is often intersected with Virgil's (ch. 1, ‘Medieval Ovids’); the early modern stage, in ch. 2, ‘Staging the Poets: Ben Jonson's Poetaster’, which focuses on ‘a play whose basic currency is lives’ (58); the English Civil War and the French Revolution, when Lucan's biography and, even more crucially, his thanatography are read alongside his Bellum civile in republican terms (ch. 3, ‘Lucan and Revolution’); the Victorian reading of Lucretius as ‘the Roman poet alone with his mind’, anticipating Victorian and modern anxieties and ‘the discovery of modern subjectivity’ (133) (ch. 4, ‘Lucretius and Modern Subjectivity’); and, finally, the modern death of the author in Herman Broch's Der Tod des Vergil’, a full-blown biofiction whose modernist (inter)textual experiments pivot on Virgil's life and works, representative of the crisis of modernity (ch. 5, ‘The Death of the Author’).
While some of these ‘biofictions’ consist of full lives, in other texts the references to Roman poets’ lives and works are less elaborated, limited to brief anecdotes, references or short episodes — what Roland Barthes would call ‘biographemes’ — even as their significance remains central to the meaning of the text. The label of ‘biofiction’ is thus used quite broadly, to span all these different textual presences as well as the reception of the Roman poets and their works. Most critics of biofiction have mainly discussed it as a genre consisting of texts (novels, mostly) that select historical individuals as their protagonists, or in any case as significant characters within it. This use of the concept, expanding it to a mode of reception that places lives at its centre, may thus be seen with some scepticism, as carrying a risk that virtually all references to historical writers (and to their work, since the work is read through the life) may fall within a looser sense of biofiction, to the point that the definition ceases to be of much use. However, I was fully convinced by the book's meticulously argued thesis and illuminating analyses. Afterlives of the Roman Poets prompts a necessary rethink of the pervasiveness of that encounter between life, fiction and interpretation, writing, reading and reception. Its take on ‘biofiction’ is cultural more than generic: the ‘Post-Mortem’ that serves as Conclusion describes it as ‘a cultural history of biofictional reception’ (187). It is in this respect that the bold statement with which the book opens — ‘This book is a manifesto at heart’ (1) — acquires its strongest meaning and most powerful value. Alongside all its other merits — its erudition, which it wears lightly, its readability, the precision and lucidity of its textual readings, the illuminating connections it draws — a significant feature of the book is that it acts as a useful corrective for all those who see biofiction as an intrinsically postmodern and contemporary phenomenon: by reminding us of its much longer, deeper roots, it affords a larger perspective from which contemporary biofiction can be considered as a particular phase in the history of the reflection on lives as they are lived and as they are imagined, read and written. The book also helps bridge fields that do not often meet: as G. points out, ancient literature is often ignored by modern life writing, while classical scholars often ignore modern life writing; by bringing them together, Afterlives aims to expand the scope of both (3).
In its widening of the historical and conceptual scope of biofiction, Afterlives of the Roman Poets is one of the most significant contributions to current debates on the form, and it should be read by anyone interested in biofiction, autofiction, heterobiography and all forms of life writing, especially as they intersect, more or less explicitly, with fiction.
