Simon Werrett is to be congratulated on producing a work of intriguing artifice. This impressive book of thorough scholarship is strongly argued, well produced and nicely illustrated. But in his somewhat perverse insistence on the primacy of pyrotechnics as the key to understanding the interaction and development of the arts and sciences through history and geography, the author lessens the force of his case by overstretching it. The outcome is a sustained attempt to make, as the customary saying has it, the tail wag the dog.
The study is further weakened by the author's failure to recognize, however briefly, the essential role of gunpowder-making in any examination of the reality and significance of fireworks. The aerial fantasies described here so beautifully would have been grounded without the power provided by gunpowder – a commodity with messy origins in the saltpetre-rich earth derived from human and animal detritus, skilfully incorporated with sulphur and charcoal in carefully balanced quantities to produce the sieved and dusted grains that when fired revealed their explosive and propellant qualities. There are several references to the ingredients of gunpowder in this book, but its makers and their procedures are so far below the designers, constructors and artillery men in status and significance in Werrett's accounts as to receive no mention despite the importance of their knowledge of ‘The Art and Mystery of Making Gunpowder’, in the words of partnership agreements. Furthermore, the papers on making and refining saltpetre and on gunpowder-making presented by Thomas Henshaw to the Royal Society in the early 1660s and published in Thomas Sprat's History of the Royal Society of London (1667) are not expanded upon although they offer a clear account of the processes to be followed. It is regrettable that the ill-tempered pamphleteering by Henry Stubbe should have prevented them being more generally appreciated. Henshaw's lucid account of the purpose of incorporation can hardly be bettered – the ingredients should be mixed so exactly that in every grain of powder they must all be found in their exact proportions.
This limitation of approach may have arisen because, as Simon Werrett acknowledges, the book has its roots in the ‘study of spectacle in Russia’ (p. 249), in Moscow and St Petersburg between the reigns of Tsar Peter I (1696–1725) and his daughter Elizabeth (1740–1760). Here the displays of fireworks on richly allegorical themes were used by the designer–academicians as a tool of negotiation, hoping through flattery of the powerful sovereign to establish their position and that of their institution within the hierarchy of the absolute state. Turning to Paris, the author found the lavish spectacles to be similarly sycophantic, but greatly enhanced by the finesse and colourful skills of the Italian masters who established themselves there. Some of these Italian masters were brought to London to add their artistry to the display being organized in Green Park by the Board of Ordnance and the Royal Laboratory in celebration of the Peace of Aix-la-Chapelle of 1748. A confusion in the lines of command and trails of powder led to a fire in one of the pavilions making up the elaborate framework or ‘machine’, and in the ensuing delay the crowd drifted away, leaving many fireworks unused. But the people had their spectacle a few weeks later when the display was resumed at the Thames-side home of the Duke of Richmond. Werrett makes great play of the fact that amongst press and people in London this episode was derided as ‘The Grand Whim for Posterity to Laugh At’, although it could be pointed out that in more authoritarian countries such mishaps, leading even to loss of life, were not afforded this publicity.
The role of Charles Frederick as the senior officer responsible for the Green Park display is also worthy of greater consideration than appears in this account because his close involvement with the gunpowder and fireworks for this celebration was an aspect of his primary responsibility for the materiel of war. This dual function was of great importance, especially in the matter of maintaining the quality of the powder produced by the private manufacturers on whom the crown then relied. An earlier holder of these complex duties was Martin Beckman, who in Werrett's portrait from his fireworks perspective is shown as the man responsible for the royal celebrations especially around the time of the Glorious Revolution. But Beckman also had an active military role, working in the 1690s on ‘bomb vessels’ for expeditions against the French coast, putting to sea himself on several occasions. The shells and carcasses aboard these ships bore a strong resemblance to the fireworks used in displays such as that he organized back in London to celebrate the safe return of the king from the Continent in November 1695 following the capture of Namur. The public criticisms following the Green Park extravaganza half a century later did no lasting damage to the Royal Laboratory and the Board of Ordnance, whose fortunes revived as Britain asserted itself on the world scene and Charles Frederick found himself practising ‘the Art of making Fireworks for real use as well as for Triumph’ (NA/WO/55/408, 1744–1748, Royal and other Warrants).
The comments prompted by this book and the questions raised are a sound indication of its quality. It is an elegant construct, a fine ‘machine’, sparking many ideas about the ‘pyrotechnic arts and sciences’ across time and space. There remains a final query, about an item in the commendably full bibliography, where a volume is listed as ‘Buchanan, Brenda J., David Cannadine, et al. Gunpowder Plots: A Celebration of 400 Years of British Carelessness with Explosives. London: Allen Lane, 2005’. However, the book was not published with this working title, but with the much more appropriate Gunpowder Plots: A Celebration of 400 Years of Bonfire Night. There was here, perhaps, some strange alchemy at work.
