European Catholicism emerged from the First World War simultaneously on the attack and forced into defence. The end of the war sparked a sense of insecurity, with the dissolution of Austria-Hungary, Catholicism’s most loyal ally. The Russian Revolution and Bolshevik upheavals in Germany and Hungary aroused fears of a godless takeover of society. Liberal and socialist internationalists were set on creating a new world order, and global Catholicism seemed to be left on the sidelines. On the other hand, in many countries in Europe, Catholics came out of the war with a renewed sense of self-confidence. They saw the war as definitive proof of a moral deficit in European culture. Secularisation, materialism and utilitarianism had led people away from the church and into the abyss. The peace provided a unique opportunity for Catholicism to reclaim moral leadership in the reconstruction of society. Leaving behind the nineteenth-century culture wars, Catholics, not least in Germany, energetically started to promote a society based on Catholic ideals.
German-speaking Catholic activists and social workers tried to harness this momentum to overcome their old sense of vulnerability and live up to the challenges of a new age.Footnote 1 The role of Catholic social work in German society after the First World War reflected Catholicism’s dual nature of defensiveness and self-confidence. Historians of German Catholicism and social work have argued that the Catholic private social work organisations that developed during the Wilhelmine Empire emerged to shield the Catholic population from anticlerical threats and keep believers Catholic from cradle to grave.Footnote 2 This article argues, however, that in the inter-war period, German Catholic social work became part of an increasingly offensive Catholic campaign that weaponised the private sphere with the goal of a wholesale re-Christianisation of society. It draws on the work of historians of Catholicism such as James Chappel and Sarah Shortall, who have asserted that Catholics subverted the arbitrary distinction that secularists had constructed to confine religion to the private sphere of the family and exclude it from the public sphere of politics. In Chappel’s analysis, the privatisation of religion was far from a de-politicisation and rather offered Catholics ‘new forms of public intervention that can be legitimated in the name of that sacred private sphere’.Footnote 3 Shortall has argued along similar lines that the separation of church and state led to a form of ‘counter-politics’ in which Catholics instrumentalised the private sphere against secular political competitors.Footnote 4 Nowhere was this more true than in Catholic social work, which self-confidently mobilised the allegedly private spheres of family, marriage and care to fight against the moral evils of godless modernity.
In the inter-war period, Catholics in the Weimar Republic realised that the Paris Peace Treaties had created a new international reality, in which the majority of German speakers who lived outside Germany’s borders [Auslanddeutsche] were Catholic after the dissolution of the Habsburg Empire and the secession of several largely Catholic regions from the German Reich. This article shows that German-speaking social workers used the Catholic politics of the private sphere to come to the aid of these German-speaking Catholic ‘minorities’. With the aim to strengthen the transnational German nation across Europe, they legitimised such nationalist politics under the umbrella of new forms of Catholic internationalism.Footnote 5 The emerging historiography on Catholic internationalism often focuses on the efforts of Catholic internationalists to achieve peace and international solidarity as a ‘counterweight against nationalism’.Footnote 6 It describes Catholic social work as a crucial part of a process in which Catholics overcame nationalist differences and started to cooperate with non-Catholic expressions of humanitarianism, particularly after the Second World War.Footnote 7 However, historians of internationalism have long argued that nationalism and internationalism were ‘intertwined’, especially in the inter-war period.Footnote 8 Catholic internationalism’s campaign to re-Christianise the world through conservative family values was often highly compatible with nationalism, and even fascism.Footnote 9 This article expands this literature by contending that because German-speaking Catholics saw social work as a key tool to strengthen Catholicism’s position in an international battle of worldviews, they also came to promote the idea that nationalist activism was essential for advancing the Catholic faith. The internationalisation of Catholic social work was meant to re-Christianise Europe while strengthening German national life at the same time.
This article connects the histories of inter-war German nationalist activism, internationalism and Catholicism by examining the case study of the German nun and social worker Hildegardis Wulff (1896–1961), who set up social work institutions for the German-speaking communities of the Romanian Banat. Drawing primarily on her correspondence and on meeting reports and subsidy requests of the German Caritas Association [Deutscher Caritasverband] and the Reich Association for Catholic Germans Abroad [Reichsverband für die katholische Auslanddeutschen], this article shows that these organisations supported social workers like Hildegardis and re-defined the purpose of Catholic social work as a proactive campaign of re-Catholicisation. This Catholic assertiveness encouraged Catholic activists to join the nationalist support for German-speaking minorities in East Central Europe by founding specifically Catholic German-language schools, seminaries, hospitals and spiritual care institutions. The article argues that Catholic activism for German speakers ‘abroad’ bridged the perceived gaps between a universalist Catholicism and a narrow nationalist activism, as well as between the demands of nationalism and internationalism.Footnote 10 The quest to re-Catholicise German-speaking minority communities became a programme of German nationalist internationalism that German Catholic activists bolstered through their participation in international organisations such as Caritas Catholica. Hildegardis’s activities constituted a kind of ‘Catholic internationalism from the bottom up’ that connected Catholicism to German nationalism and tied Europe’s moral reconstruction to the national reconstruction of German-speaking communities everywhere.
Weaponising the Private Sphere
In the Weimar Republic, Catholic social work found itself in a new position of influence. For the first time, the constitution recognised welfare as a right and core responsibility of the state, while the Catholic politicians who helped draft it guaranteed the role and financing of private religious organisations in the welfare state.Footnote 11 As this structure perpetuated ideological tensions between social work competitors, Catholic social workers pushed the idea that within this competition, Catholic family ideals were uniquely suited to morally uplift the entire German national body. German Catholics increasingly sought what they called the re-Christianisation of the German nation, including of German speakers outside the Weimar state. Sister Hildegardis took up this call and became an example of Catholic internationalism from the bottom up that was rooted in social work.
The main actor of Catholic social work in Germany was the German Caritas Association, founded by Lorenz Werthmann (1858–1921) in 1897 as a private organisation that created diocesan Caritas organisations and united them under one federal roof. Independent from both the German state and the Catholic hierarchy, the Caritas Association promoted modern Catholic ideas about social reform by professionalising and rationalising social work, providing centralised education for social workers and establishing so-called Caritas science.Footnote 12 Although it shared many goals with Protestant and secular social work organisations, the Caritas Association was not a stepping stone towards interconfessional social work and much less to Christian Democracy, as some historians have argued.Footnote 13 Rather, the goal of the Caritas Association was to keep people Catholic or to make them return to Catholicism, using welfare work to help people to live a moral life. Here, Catholic social work differed from state or secular forms of welfare, as Joseph Löhr, a Caritas scientist, wrote in 1922:
Even where both Caritas and welfare work move in the same areas of activity, there can be significant differences. Take, for example, the care for venereal patients and alcoholics. For [secular] social work, these are merely areas of health care, but Caritas regards these phenomena as a national vice [Volkslaster] and accordingly systematically organises its work in this direction to combat moral distress.Footnote 14
The Caritas Association treated venereal diseases and alcoholism because they not only were health concerns but also reflected the decrepit moral state of German society. The Caritas Association helped alcoholics and drug addicts, provided marriage counselling to prevent divorce and offered spiritual care to children, workers and migrants. Through these activities, the Caritas Association, like other religious social work organisations, aimed to heal the national body by instilling moral virtues in the people it supported, rather than simply improving their health and well-being. In competition with non-religious organisations, which they accused of having a ‘functional-rational’ outlook on care, Caritas workers asserted that when they offered healthcare or welfare assistance, they were also educators, teaching people moral values that would guide them towards the Catholic faith.Footnote 15
The life of Sister Hildegardis shows that after the First World War Catholic social work enjoyed a status that extended beyond the Catholic milieu. The holistic conception of care that the Caritas Association represented inspired a range of people to become Catholic social workers. It resonated particularly well with bourgeois women, such as Sister Hildegardis.Footnote 16 In her own account of her life, Hildegardis explained how she was raised as Liselotte Wulff in a wealthy family of Westphalian merchants and industrialists, whose liberal Protestantism, in her own words, ‘repelled’ her.Footnote 17 She became acquainted with Catholic social work when she studied in Heidelberg and Bonn:
My Catholic friends and acquaintances told me about newly founded religious orders and secular institutes at home and abroad, which, already founded or planned, took up the fight against the misery of the time, which seemed essential to me, and that wanted to open up the possibility of apostolic activity for women outside of school and hospital.Footnote 18
After her studies, Wulff converted, joined a convent and took on the name Hildegardis. During her novitiate, she met Maria Benedicta Föhrenbach (1883–1961). In 1920, the two nuns founded a new women’s congregation, the Lioba Sisters, which aimed to fulfil an apostolic mission using the modern methods of Catholic social work. Located in a convent near Freiburg im Breisgau, the Lioba Sisters were close to the main offices of the Caritas Association and the newly founded Institute for Caritas Science at the local university, where they also attended courses. Hildegardis and Maria Benedicta instrumentalised the concept of ‘spiritual motherhood’, through which women from all religious denominations claimed professional opportunities based on women’s perceived caring nature.Footnote 19 The congregation of the Lioba Sisters might have seemed anachronistic and old-fashioned, even at the time. However, in its goals it was a product of very modern ideas about Catholic charity and the professionalisation of Catholic social work.
At first glance, Hildegardis’s conversion and the foundation of the Lioba Sisters appear consistent with what historians have identified as a specific embrace of Catholic social work by women driven by concepts like ‘spiritual motherhood’. Bernhard Schneider has noted the considerable number of women in Catholic social work from the nineteenth century onwards, characterising this trend as the ‘feminisation of Caritas’.Footnote 20 Others have argued that the Catholic religion at large became more ‘feminine’, exemplified by a surge in Marian devotion and large numbers of women joining religious congregations.Footnote 21 During the nineteenth-century culture wars, liberals labelled such mass outpourings of Catholic piety as ‘irrational’ and ‘feminine’. Catholicism contrasted with the liberal ideal of a rational and productive society, where women had their place in the family and religion was a private affair.Footnote 22 The ‘feminisation’ of Catholicism, in these terms, led to the ‘formation of an anti-intellectual counterculture’.Footnote 23 However, the historian should not replicate such contemporary arguments about Catholicism’s perceived backwardness. The fact that women like Hildegardis became Catholic social workers was a result of the increased assertiveness and visibility of Catholic social work in Weimar society. Catholic social workers consciously mobilised the private sphere to which liberals had tried to relegate both women and the Catholic faith. If anything, the Caritas Association, from its inception, promoted the development of ‘Caritas science’ in order to make social work more intellectual, not less. After the war, ‘Caritas science’ became fully institutionalised in Freiburg. The first Caritas science lectures, conducted over the course of five weeks in August and September 1919, explicitly sought to answer the need for a rapid professionalisation of the discipline caused by wartime conditions, when many social workers, mostly women, were hastily hired into Caritas jobs.Footnote 24 Catholic social work was neither backward, nor anti-intellectual and much less ‘feminine’, but instead a uniquely Catholic embrace of modern social issues.
After her novitiate, Sister Hildegardis started teaching at Freiburg’s Social Women’s School [Soziale Frauenschule], which was run jointly by the Caritas Association and the Catholic German Women’s Union [Katholische Deutsche Frauenbund]. As with other Catholic social work institutions, Caritas leaders saw the school not necessarily as a tool for women’s emancipation. Rather, they saw women teachers as crucial actors to secure the position of Catholic care organisations and contribute to the moral reconstruction of German society along Catholic lines. At the Social Women’s School, Hildegardis taught subjects like hygiene, sociology, home economics and pedagogy, while the Freiburg school also had an outspoken focus on religious education and pastoral care.Footnote 25 As a nun and Catholic social worker, Hildegardis taught people how to live a moral life by educating them in the ways that Catholic principles would make people healthy, keep families together and discipline children. Catholic social work had made private religiosity into a public responsibility, and women were crucial to mobilising the private sphere of the family for political goals.
Hildegardis Exports Caritas
In the inter-war period, social work became a missionary calling, a tool to re-Catholicise society by using education and welfare provision to bring people who were perceived to be at risk of falling into the hands of Protestants, socialists and secularists back into the womb of the church. The Caritas model appealed to German speakers beyond the borders of the Weimar Republic. In 1929, Augustin Pacha (1870–1954), the German-speaking acting bishop of the Romanian Banat, sent a letter to his counterpart in Freiburg, asking for help: ‘Germany provides a large number of missionaries and sisters for distant pagan people. May some also come to us Catholic Germans abroad.’Footnote 26 Hildegardis became such a missionary. The records of the German Caritas Association testify that social work leaders and minority clerics in German-speaking communities in East Central Europe believed that both Catholicism and German national identity were under threat from nationalisation campaigns by these new states and from secularising tendencies among the local populations. In their eyes, the Banat was a more important missionary area than regions that had yet to become Catholic. As Hildegardis was called to work in the Banat, Benedict Kreutz (1879–1949), the director of the German Caritas Association, believed that hers should be ‘a true apostolic mission’ in which she could ‘Christianise in a modern sense’.Footnote 27 In contrast to pre-war Caritas activities, Catholic workers now also paid attention to what happened outside Germany’s borders, in minority communities that were seen to have been left without spiritual and national guidance. In doing so, Catholic social workers conflated the national and the religious. As Hildegardis was called to Romania, her Catholic mission became a national apostolate.
Sister Hildegardis must have been an excellent teacher. In 1927, two students from the Romanian Banat, Olga Hadzsy and Adele Csatáry, were profoundly inspired by her classes at Freiburg’s Social Women’s School.Footnote 28 Hadzsy and Csatáry were ‘Social Sisters’, members of a Viennese congregation with the same social and caritative purposes as the Lioba Sisters and that had been active around Austria-Hungary.Footnote 29 However, the Hungarian-speaking sisters lacked the thorough social work education of the Lioba Sisters. More importantly, because they were unable to speak German, the Social Sisters did not manage to appeal to the significant German-speaking parts of the Banat population. On the invitation of Hadzsy and Csatáry, Sister Hildegardis came to Temeswar/Timișoara where in January and October 1928 she gave ten German-language lectures on pedagogy, the youth movement, religious education and ‘education towards motherhood’.Footnote 30 These were, according to Hildegardis, a resounding success: ‘that, firstly, anyone at all could speak German well and flawlessly, and, secondly, that a nun had given lectures and made studies was extraordinary for the time and for the German people there’.Footnote 31
For Catholics in Germany, the Romanian Banat was a remote and little-known corner of Europe. As a former part of the Hungarian half of the Habsburg Empire, connections between Wilhelmine Germany and the Banat had been few before the First World War. The German-speaking ‘Danube Swabians’ were a small rural community of around 220,000 people at the beginning of the 1920s, most of whom were Catholic.Footnote 32 Inter-war Romania was a majority Orthodox state, which after the border changes of the Treaties of Trianon and St. Germain had gained large groups of Protestants, Jews and Catholics, all split among the country’s different linguistic minorities. Each of those sought to realise the cultural and language rights, that, in theory, were guaranteed by international minority treaties.Footnote 33 The majority of German speakers in Romania were Protestant. Before the war they had become the focus of support campaigns led by German nationalist organisations from Wilhelmine Germany, which were themselves largely dominated by liberal Protestants.Footnote 34 In contrast, the Catholic Church in the Habsburg Empire had aligned itself with the interests of the Hungarian ruling class, and German nationalists therefore considered Catholic social work tainted by its association with the government’s Magyarisation efforts.Footnote 35 From the perspective of the Danube Swabians, what was extraordinary about Hildegardis was not that she was a Catholic nun, nor that she was a German speaker, but rather that she brought these two identities together in her support for the local population.
Sister Hildegardis’s unique appeal was not lost on the Banat’s local church leaders, who called on the Caritas Association and the Lioba Sisters to send her again. Franz Blaskovics (1864–1937), a local German-speaking prelate, wrote Benedict Kreutz:
our colonist people . . . has recently awakened to a German national consciousness, determined to remain German and to fight for its cultural existence at any cost. It is in this southeastern corner of Europe a valuable stronghold of the German nation, surrounded by foreign Volkstum.Footnote 36
Bishop Pacha applauded this ‘national awakening’ of the Banat Swabians. While German nationalists saw the neighbouring Protestant Siebenbürger Sachsen in Romania as authentic Germans that had clung to their Volkstum for centuries, the Danube Swabians were considered an almost new ‘tribe’ of Germans that had re-emerged after decades of Hungarian repression.Footnote 37 However, Pacha warned that the ‘awakening of my faithful to German national consciousness . . . could also have harmful consequences if this strong popular movement is not carried by the Christian Catholic spirit’.Footnote 38 The Hungarian-speaking Social Sisters were associated with the Magyarisation campaigns, noted Pacha. They did not lack in Christian spirit but could never lead the local population in this national movement.Footnote 39 For the local German speakers, Sister Hildegardis would later write, ‘“Catholic” was the same as “Hungarian”’ and ‘pastoral care in another language or recognition of another Volkstum in these works was a crime’.Footnote 40 The ‘national reawakening’ of the Banat German speakers was a sign of the times, which the local clerical leaders wholeheartedly embraced. With it came a challenge: they had to convince the local population that Catholicism was on their side in the national battle.
Bishop Pacha believed that the ‘national revival’ of his diocese should become tied to a simultaneous religious revival, ‘also because we now belong to an Orthodox state where both faith and Germanness must be protected’.Footnote 41 Hildegardis’s lectures were sensational because she catered to both needs. She spoke German but also represented a modern form of Catholic social work that could bring about the needed religious revival. Pacha wrote to Lioba prioress Maria Benedicta that through Hildegardis’s lectures ‘one became aware of one’s own backwardness here and the necessity to emulate, as much as possible, the social and Caritas activities with which Catholicism in Germany is leading the way for the entire world’.Footnote 42 Blaskovics asked for support from Germany because its ‘highly developed Caritas work is somewhat of a novelty for us and could not be implemented here without knowledgeable and devoted guidance’.Footnote 43 The modernisation and professionalisation of German Catholic social work had not gone unnoticed. German Caritas was a model, an export product for which there was a demand among ‘suffering’ Catholic communities like those in the Banat.
Augustin Pacha and Franz Blaskovics raised the alarm about developments that they considered a danger to the survival of the Danube Swabians as both Germans and faithful Catholics. Pacha wrote to Maria Benedicta about ‘anti-religious influences of the West’ that threatened the community: ‘the one-child system decimates our people. Selfishness divides it. In family life and in childrearing, the Christian spirit is often lacking. A natural consequence of this is also the shortage of priests.’Footnote 44 Blaskovics wrote in similar terms that this ‘German island abroad’ would ‘become extinct’ if this ‘one-child system’ was not overcome, which all depended on ‘a revival of the moral-religious and Catholic caritative spirit’.Footnote 45 Population decline supposedly threatened both the size of the Banat’s German population and its Catholic identity. Discussions around birth control and family planning were an ‘issue of national survival’ for minorities across inter-war Europe.Footnote 46 However, population decrease was often an imagined danger. There was no state-enforced policy of minority birth control in inter-war Romania. In fact, the German-speaking Catholic community, at least before the war, was the ethnic group in the Banat in which birth numbers grew the most.Footnote 47 Catholics regarded family planning and birth control as modernity’s primary evil, a sign of eroding family values as a result of ‘rationalist individualism’.Footnote 48 In their worries about a perceived ‘one-child system’ among the Banat Germans, Blaskovics and Pacha made population politics an area that merged the Catholic and the German national.
The local Banat clergy believed that the solution for declining birthrates in their region lay in German-language education on Catholic family values. In the Habsburg Empire and its successor states, nationalists had instrumentalised social work as a form of ‘nationalist population politics’.Footnote 49 Now Catholic leaders such as Pacha and Blaskovics did the same: their worries reflected the conception of Catholic social work and modern Caritas that vices like birth control were caused by a moral deficit in modern society. Hildegardis was the ideal candidate to counter the one-child trend by teaching Catholic values in German and by helping Bishop Pacha establish institutions for education, social work and healthcare. Hildegardis’s employers agreed, and she settled in the Banat in 1929. As a first act, she set up a local Catholic German Women’s Association and Girls’ Circle (Katholischer deutscher Frauenverein und Mädchenkranz). Hildegardis realised quickly that the Banat women needed more thorough education, so she also founded an education centre for girls in 1932. Banat women, according to Hildegardis, ‘should not become young ladies, but rather peasant women with good knowledge, leaders among their people with a practical, social sensibility’. While the exact content of her lectures and courses is unknown, Hildegardis taught girls between fourteen and eighteen years old how to raise their families in good Catholic manner with courses on religion, housework, cooking, pedagogy and infant care.Footnote 50
The Banat German Catholic Women’s Association and Girls’ Circle, Hildegardis wrote in a 1931 report to the Catholic German Women’s Union in Germany, was ‘“Catholic” because it wants to operate on the foundations of the Catholic faith and Christian morals, without being a “church” association in the strict sense’.Footnote 51 At the same time, it was also ‘“German”’ as ‘its members have recognised that in order to preserve their families and their ethnicity (Volkstum), they cannot do without the supports of religion, but rather need religious renewal and deepening’.Footnote 52 The curriculum of the girls’ school reflected this belief that teaching about the Catholic family ideal would contribute to German national life among the Danube Swabians. German and history courses accompanied the practical courses that prepared the girls for motherhood. Folk dance was part of the programme and the students went to German-language theatre and film performances together.Footnote 53 Hildegardis and her Women’s Association organised girls’ festivals (Mädchenfeste) in the summer, where participants wore dirndls and other traditional dresses, sang folk songs, danced folk dances and acted in folk plays in the meadows ‘entirely in the style of the Catholic German youth movement’.Footnote 54 Moral and national education was complemented with healthcare provision as Hildegardis initiated the foundation of the St. Anna Hospital in 1936, which acquired local renown for its maternity ward and focus on gynaecology, while it, naturally, campaigned against abortion.Footnote 55 Hildegardis’s institutions would serve to keep the local national body healthy, Catholic and German.
The conflation of moral and national reconstruction was also present in the superficially more religious parts of Hildegardis’s work. She founded a local convent of the Lioba Sisters in Temeswar/Timișoara that admitted local women to the order who could help Hildegardis with her social and educational work. However, their ‘religious knowledge was much lacking; religious education had to start completely from scratch – we could assume very little’.Footnote 56 The reason for this religious deficit was a lack of religious education in German, which she addressed by founding a seminar for women spiritual care workers.Footnote 57 Hildegardis also offered German-language educational work by travelling through the region. Between 1929 and 1931, Hildegardis gave 448 lectures to diverse audiences within the Banat on topics surrounding Catholic values in family, marriage and child-rearing, on the one hand, and on church and general history, modern literature, the German youth movement and Caritas, on the other.Footnote 58 She also transmitted this knowledge through two new German-language journals for the youth, The Carpet (Der Teppich) and The Seal (Der Siegel).Footnote 59 Hildegardis’s apostolate combined lessons about everyday life with the spread of traditional Catholic values and instilled an ideology of Catholic social work and the family that was directly tied to German folk culture.
Hildegardis believed that she could keep religion, nationhood and politics separate: ‘in any case, one thing is certain: we Catholic Germans must, for religious reasons, establish far more (never political) cultural and religious connections with the local Swabian people here, and advocate for them from a religious standpoint’.Footnote 60 Yet, Caritas leaders recognised that her activities were crucial in connecting modern forms of Catholic social work firmly to its new nationalist mission among German-speaking minorities. ‘We must absolutely’, Benedict Kreutz wrote, ‘carry forward the Catholic idea on the foundation of their ethnic German identity [Volksdeutschtum], in this silent form’.Footnote 61 Even though Hildegardis deemed her work unpolitical, she still feared that it ‘could be misunderstood’ in Romania.Footnote 62 Sister Hildegardis and her supporters were aware of the potentially controversial nationalist aspects of her work. They nonetheless believed that Hildegardis’s background in modern Catholic social work and women’s issues gave her the tools to export a German Catholic ideology to the Banat that was decisively different from other forms of nationalist activism. Hildegardis’s care for the ‘private’ domains of family, marriage and childhood was not ‘unpolitical’, but rather a new form of Catholic activism that matched well with nationalist priorities.
German Minorities as Catholic Minorities
Hildegardis hoped that her work in the Banat would forge stronger connections between what Germans perceived as a remote European backwater and their motherland. Local German speakers found that they ‘had a messenger in her, who spread news of us in Germany like hardly anyone before her’.Footnote 63 Hildegardis’s work is an example of a specifically Catholic support for the Auslanddeutsche that developed in the 1920s that was largely based on the provision of Catholic social work. She was supported financially and logistically by the Reich Association for Catholic Germans Abroad, which sustained German-language religious and social work institutions across Europe to foster both German nationhood and Catholic religion. The records of the Reich Association show that Hildegardis’s activities were part of a new and concerted effort to support German-speaking minorities by claiming that threats to their German character were also attacks on the Catholic religion. Catholic activists promoted Catholic social work as a national struggle and so re-defined German minorities as Catholic minorities.
Hildegardis was not a lone apostle. Before moving to Romania in April 1929, she paid a visit to the Berlin offices of the Reich Association for Catholic Germans Abroad.Footnote 64 The Caritas Association and the Catholic German Women’s Union that supported Hildegardis in the Banat were among the eighty-three member organisations supporting German-speaking communities ‘abroad’ that made up this Reich Association. It functioned as a central information hub to collect and distribute funds for which the member organisations could apply.Footnote 65 Hildegardis met with its leaders to discuss her move, probably agreed with them on her funding and browsed its library for information about the Banat. The Reich Association for Catholic Germans Abroad connected Catholic social work, publishing and scholarship to the nationalist support for German-speaking minorities. It was founded in 1918 on the initiative of Caritas Association director Lorenz Werthmann and sanctioned by the German bishops in the same year.Footnote 66 It distributed religious literature, catechisms and schoolbooks in German-speaking minority communities and financially supported the kind of institutions in which Hildegardis was involved: schools, seminaries, women and girls’ circles, hospitals and pastoral care institutions.
Upper Silesian prelate-politician Carl Ulitzka (1873–1953) described the Reich Association’s mission at its tenth jubilee in 1928:
The first goal and pursuit of our Reich Association still always remains: to preserve German Volkstum among our Catholic compatriots through effective means, through German pastoral care, German sermon, German confession and German church hymn; through the formation of small parishes, through the appointment of German-speaking priests, through German Catholic schooling or, at the very least, religious instruction in German.
We are Catholics and want to save the Catholic culture of the minority. We do this most effectively on the foundation of their Volkstum. We are Germans and want to preserve our brothers’ Volkstum. We achieve this most reliably through our ecclesiastical and religious objectives.Footnote 67
The Reich Association’s priority was to give minority communities access to Catholic care, education and religious practice in the German mother tongue. Supporting the German identity of these communities extended to support for non-religious institutions and activities such as schools and folk festivities. The connection between religion and folk culture was considered self-evident: the religious culture of German-speaking communities required protection that only German Catholics could provide.
The support for German-speaking minorities was a national issue that unified Germans from the entire political spectrum. Yet, Catholics and the Reich Association have barely featured in the literature on the German support for minorities in Europe in the inter-war period.Footnote 68 Historically, Catholics had been hesitant to involve themselves in the support for Auslanddeutsche because of the association of German nationalist organisations with liberal Protestantism and anticlericalism.Footnote 69 Catholic historians have sometimes even denied that the Catholic support for German speakers ‘abroad’ had a ‘nationalist accent’, replicating the language of contemporary actors.Footnote 70 Centre Party politician Georg Schreiber (1882–1963), for example, wrote in 1922 that ‘we German Catholics are national in the sense of a passionate struggle for the preservation of our German Volkstum. But even though we are indeed national, we are nevertheless not nationalist’.Footnote 71 Hildegardis did not think her activities were nationalist either, especially as she, after the Second World War, compared them to the incursions of local Nazis: ‘even though I worked in the German language, on the basis of German culture in this German-speaking people, the goal and intention was and remained pure and undivided throughout all the years, naturally and exclusively Catholic’.Footnote 72 For Catholics, nationalist were the others.
German nationalism reminded Catholics across German-speaking Europe of the dark days of persecution during the nineteenth-century Kulturkampf. In Otto von Bismarck’s (1815–98) Germany, liberal nationalists had attacked Catholics for their ‘ultramontanism’, claiming that they were more loyal to the pope than to the German nation. The Prussian government had expelled religious orders and individual clerics and forced Catholics to distance themselves from the church hierarchy to show themselves loyal Germans.Footnote 73 Amidst these tensions, the support for German speakers ‘abroad’ became associated with the loud-mouthed actions of Prussian Protestant liberals and nobles, such as the Eastern Marches Society in Germany and pan-German movements like that of Georg von Schönerer (1842–1921) in Austria.Footnote 74 The latter’s Los von Rom movement had urged Austrian Catholics to leave the church to facilitate a Prussian-led unification of all German speakers. A ‘trivial threat’ to the church at most, Los von Rom had nevertheless instilled in Catholic clergy a deep suspicion of pan-German forms of German nationalism associated with the support for German speakers ‘abroad’.Footnote 75 When German-speaking Catholics referred to ‘nationalism’, they had these examples in mind.
The Catholic turn towards the kind of German nationalism that treated disparate German-speaking communities as parts of one German nation was anything but a self-evident process. However, the new international order after the First World War forced Catholics to assess nationalist activism differently. In a 1926 memorandum on the ‘so-called German minorities’ in south-eastern Europe, Cologne Cardinal Karl Joseph Schulte (1871–1941) lamented the silence of the Vatican on the issue of German-speaking minorities and the protection of the use of the German language, specifically referencing the Banat. ‘If these most basic religious rights are not guaranteed by the church authority’, Schulte wrote, ‘if minority rights in their religious-ecclesiastical aspect are not somehow secured for these German minorities, then . . . the spread of a “Los von Rom movement” is to be expected’.Footnote 76 The Catholic Church could no longer ignore the national cause of minorities, otherwise ‘Protestantism will reap a rich harvest’.Footnote 77 Hildegardis also believed that the Catholic hierarchy had neglected caring for German nationhood: ‘it is unbelievable, but true: here in Romania among the few million Germans abroad, the notion still prevails: Protestant = German’.Footnote 78 The failure to provide a Catholic vision for nationhood had left the field open to denominational competitors. Catholics saw nationalism no longer as a threat to the universal church but rather as necessary aid in an international competition for souls.
The Reich Association for Catholic Germans Abroad became the main advocate for this vision. It connected the goal of re-Catholicising Europe with the protection of German Volkstum in its publications and activities. Reich Association pamphlets consistently stressed that the dissolution of the Habsburg Empire and the secession from regions such as East Upper Silesia and Alsace-Lorraine from the German Reich had led to a situation in which the majority of Auslanddeutsche were Catholics. It claimed that of thirty-two million German speakers ‘abroad’, ‘at least’ eighteen million were Catholics.Footnote 79 A 1928 pamphlet proclaimed that two million Catholics in minority communities lacked churches, two million suffered from shortages of education opportunities for German-speaking priests, three million Catholics needed youth education and three and a half million had urgent needs for German-speaking schools and orphanages.Footnote 80 If those institutions disappeared, German-speaking Catholics were at risk of losing their ‘faith and Volkstum’ at the same time. As the Reich Association’s journal clarified in 1927:
The experiences of recent years and decades have also shown us that religion and Volkstum are most intimately connected with one another, that every loss of Volkstum is very often also connected with the loss of religion. We must therefore, as Catholics, as confessors of the one world-spanning, peoples-uniting Catholic Christian faith, affirm the genuine national idea.Footnote 81
The universalism of the Catholic religion did not absolve German speakers from caring for their own. Hildegardis wrote that her ‘activity was not supposed to be directed at an ethnically and linguistically mixed, half-Hungarian, half-Romanian public. From the beginning, I was assigned Catholic, German Banat Swabian people as the subject of my work and apostolic activity’.Footnote 82 Hildegardis’s apostolate was first and foremost a mission for Germans.
The Reich Association for Catholic Germans Abroad supported Sister Hildegardis’s Banat mission directly and indirectly. Even before Hildegardis arrived, the Caritas Association used Reich Association funds to support the institutions set up by Danube Swabian theology professor Josef Nischbach (1889–1970) to educate German-speaking priests in the Banat. The organisations distributed stipends and funded his trips and those of his students to Germany, where they could learn about modern German Catholic social work.Footnote 83 Hildegardis herself attended meetings of the Catholic German Women’s Union in Poland and kept the leaders of the Reich Association up to date with information about the communities she served.Footnote 84 The Reich Association also organised courses for Catholic Auslanddeutsche students. Nine Banat Swabians participated in an April 1930 course in Neisse where they took classes on the Catholic worldview, the minority question in Poland, Catholic trade unions and the völkische leadership tasks of German speakers ‘abroad’.Footnote 85 The Reich Association worked together with interconfessional support organisations for German-speaking minorities like the Association for Germanness Abroad [Verein für das Deutschtum im Ausland] to financially support the St. Anna Hospital and the boarding house ‘Banatia’ for German-speaking students in Temeswar/Timișoara.Footnote 86 The Reich Association funded institutions that were uniquely Catholic but also facilitated general care and education institutions and would often refer beneficiaries to other funding streams if it lacked the funds itself.
Caroline Mezger has observed for the Yugoslavian Banat that ‘Donauschwaben Catholic activists . . . learned not only to “nationalize” their goals, but to achieve these through German aid’.Footnote 87 This cut both ways: Catholics in Germany also nationalised themselves. Over the course of the 1920s, the reconstruction of German nationhood of communities outside Germany radicalised German foreign policy and the domestic political debate.Footnote 88 Catholic organisations followed this trend. Within the Reich Association, the more nationalist members such as the Caritas Association increasingly clashed with missionary orders who feared that ‘adopting nationalist tones’ would endanger their room for manoeuvre abroad, including in the colonies of other states.Footnote 89 The nationalist forces came out on top in this battle, denying, like Hildegardis, that their support for German-speaking minorities was ‘political’.Footnote 90 Cornelia Eisler has argued that the Reich Association’s ‘national(istic) orientation’ can be seen as ‘an attempt to participate in socio-political and state-political developments’.Footnote 91 If German public opinion demanded action for their brethren ‘abroad’, the episcopacy included, how could that be political?
In the Reich Association’s work, nationalism and Catholicism came to mean almost the same thing. An internal memorandum stated around 1930 that ‘the contrast that becomes noticeable between German and foreign Volkstum is not merely a contrast of Volkstum to Volkstum, but almost everywhere also a contrast of Catholic to secular’.Footnote 92 Catholic activists compared the Banat to other regions in Europe where both Catholicism and nationhood were perceived to be under threat, such as South Tyrol and Upper Silesia. In 1933, the Reich Association’s newsletter praised Hildegardis’s women’s organisations as ‘exemplary’ and mentioned her activities as part of a list of successes, probably intended to convince the new Nazi regime of the Reich Association’s worth. Hildegardis’s schools and girls’ circles contributed as greatly to the German national effort abroad as German priests in the Soviet Union and pastoral caretakers delivering German-language education in Hungary.Footnote 93 German-speaking minorities were presented as Catholic minorities when Catholic nationalist efforts needed to be distinguished from liberal or Protestant actions. Conversely, the Reich Association recast Catholic minorities as German minorities if this served to persuade authorities to maintain their financial support. The result was the same: by 1933, the assertiveness of Catholics after the First World War had culminated in their nationalisation.
German Nationalism and Catholic Internationalism
The Catholic support for German-speaking minorities that Hildegardis preached became one of the most important motivations for German Catholics to initiate new forms of Catholic internationalism. Hildegardis was ‘doing’ a nationalist form of Catholic internationalism on the ground that the Caritas Association also promoted within new international social work organisations.Footnote 94 Historians of religious internationalisms often stress how the nation-state order ‘fractured’ international religious activism.Footnote 95 However, Giuliana Chamedes has shown that Catholic internationalism could actually reinforce religious forms of nationalism and the nation-state order, while simultaneously challenging liberal and communist international competitors.Footnote 96 Still, the kind of Catholic internationalism that Hildegardis represented did not necessarily follow the Vatican template of Catholic internationalism that Chamedes describes. Hildegardis’s supporters saw their local nationalist goals as a motivation to set up institutions of Catholic internationalism in the first place. Seen from the Vatican, Catholic internationalism was a universal programme of re-Christianisation. Seen from Freiburg and Temeswar/Timișoara, it was a set of local practices that also promoted nationalism.
Hildegardis’s work in the Banat was a local proponent of what German-speaking social work leaders also tried to achieve internationally. Historians in recent years have explained how internationalism was often a way for illiberal and anti-liberal actors to infiltrate, subvert and ultimately provide an alternative to the existing international order.Footnote 97 Catholic social work internationalism was an example of this. The leaders of the German Caritas Association realised that the model of a modern and scientific German Catholic social work could play a key role in the international battle of worldviews and initiated the foundation of the international organisation Caritas Catholica in 1924. With Caritas Catholica, they explicitly intended to counter non-Catholic international social work organisations that were associated with Protestantism and liberalism like the International Red Cross and sought to spread the German Caritas Association’s organisational model.Footnote 98 Swiss Caritas Director Wilhelm Kissling (1890–1963) told the second international Caritas conference in 1926 that Caritas workers from different countries had to come together in ‘compassionate love’ to oppose ‘the significant dangers facing Christian charitable work due to the increasing secularisation, communalisation and de-spiritualisation of welfare services’.Footnote 99
The intentions of the German-speaking Caritas leaders behind Caritas Catholica were similar to those of the church leaders that had invited Hildegardis to the Banat. Caritas Catholica’s goal was to re-Catholicise and re-moralise people who had strayed from the faith and who were at risk of falling into the hands of perceived ‘anti-Catholic’ internationalists. Caritas Catholica members, at the 1926 conference in Lucerne, voiced their opposition to a proposal by the Save the Children International Union to establish an international ‘Day of the Child’. Save the Children had failed to choose Christmas day for this celebration, which conference participants saw as a ‘deliberate exclusion of the Christian tradition’ and a missed opportunity to present child aid as a ‘practice of Christian charity’. Caritas Catholica also presented local struggles of Catholic social work organisations as threats to international Catholicism as a whole. Austrian Caritas leaders, for example, drew the attention of the participants in Lucerne to the dangers of socialist child support in Vienna, which they described as a campaign against ‘Christian family education’.Footnote 100 Caritas Catholica extended Hildegardis’s work in the Banat to the international stage by connecting local activism to a larger battle of Catholicism against socialist and liberal foes.
It is significant that Caritas Catholica was set up on a German initiative. German-speaking Caritas leaders hoped that an international Caritas organisation would bring together German speakers from different states to jointly fight what its leaders perceived to be anti-Catholic and immoral tendencies in international social work. The representatives of these different states often saw themselves as members of the same German nation, and Caritas Catholica’s meetings became networking events for German speakers from all around Europe. A German report on the 1928 International Caritas Conference stated: ‘the conference offered a good opportunity for discussion with our Alsatian friends, with German Catholic leaders from Czechoslovakia, Western Switzerland, Danzig as well as with leading Catholics from other nations’.Footnote 101 The Catholic internationalism of Caritas Catholica was an excellent forum for German speakers living in a different states to find each other in the new international order. Promoting what was originally a German organisational model of modern Catholic social work on the international stage was a way to bring back German interests to that same stage. German Caritas leaders claimed, for example, that Save the Children pushed away not only local Catholic but also Weimar German support organisations helping children in Vienna.Footnote 102 Similarly, they believed that the spread of ‘Caritas science’ could help break open the international boycott of German science after the war.Footnote 103 Social work internationalism combined Catholic and German nationalist interests in joint opposition to the existing international order.
For the social work organisations that supported Sister Hildegardis, Catholic internationalism was a useful form of nationalist internationalism. They believed that nationalism was crucial for the spread of the Catholic worldview on the international stage. Benedict Kreutz argued that Caritas ‘strives to shape worship and Caritas in ways that align with the character of each Volk’.Footnote 104 This corresponded to the idea of a specifically Catholic support for German speakers ‘abroad’. A 1926 booklet published by Caritas Catholica introduced the German Raphael Association, a Catholic support organisation for Catholic German-speaking migrants and settlers.Footnote 105 The German text claimed that ‘to preserve [emigrants] in their ancestral faith also meant to keep them German. Just as, conversely, only worship in their mother tongue could safeguard their faith.’Footnote 106 Under the umbrella of Catholic internationalism, different nationalisms did not have to bite each other but jointly served to protect Catholicism. The same booklet also wrote about the Italian Opera Bonomelli, which supported Italian-speakers ‘abroad’ in the ‘material and moral-religious improvement’ of ‘the parish, the family, the fatherland’. Both the Raphael Association and the Opera Bonomelli aimed at the ‘preservation of faith through preservation of nationality’.Footnote 107 Catholic internationalism, in the conception of the founders of Caritas Catholica, should not cover up but rather celebrate national differences. In a complete volte-face to pre-war Catholic antagonism to the idea of nationalism, Catholic activists in the inter-war period promoted an idea of Catholic internationalism to which nationalism was central.
Hildegardis’s Catholic German activism contributed at the grassroots level to what Caritas Catholica sought to advance in international institutions. Hildegardis’s activism in the Banat, Benedict Kreutz wrote to the German Foreign Office, ‘is a matter of pure cultural work, which will begin on a small scale, but should be undertaken with great energy and determination’.Footnote 108 The international and the local strengthened not only each other but also German nationalism more broadly. Carl Ulitzka told the members of the Reich Association for Catholic Germans Abroad that ‘the more energetically we Catholics now position ourselves in this international life-stream of the church, the sooner and more freely will the floodgates open for the exchange of the ideal, spiritual and cultural goods of the peoples (Völker), the greater help we can provide to our beleaguered minorities’.Footnote 109 Catholic internationalism and German nationalism went hand in hand. Sister Hildegardis’s social work was a local force that would enable Germany to claim its rightful place among the nations.
Conclusion
Today, Banat Swabian expatriates still revere Hildegardis Wulff as a local patron saint. Residents of the Nischbachhaus, a retirement home for Banat Germans in Ingolstadt, continue to celebrate mass in the Hildegardis Wulff Chapel.Footnote 110 Hagiographic accounts of her life paint Hildegardis as a victim of persecution by the Nazis in the 1930s, who, in her own account, even threatened to send her to Dachau.Footnote 111 In reality, Hildegardis was able to carry on most of her activities and described the Second World War as a ‘relatively easy’ time.Footnote 112 In Nazi Germany, the Caritas Association and the Reich Association for German Catholics Abroad continued their activities until well into the war.Footnote 113 Hildegardis’s real martyrdom only came after the war, when the new communist leaders of Romania imprisoned her together with Bishop Pacha and Josef Nischbach as ‘foreign spies’ in 1950. She was only released in 1959 as part of a prisoner exchange with West Germany, soon after which she passed away in 1961.Footnote 114
The life and works of Sister Hildegardis and her supporters demonstrate crucial entanglements between Catholicism, nationalism and internationalism in the inter-war period. Hildegardis’s mission to set up social work and women’s organisations in the Banat shows that German-speaking Catholics, including secular and regular clergy, had warmed up to transnational German nationalist activism in ways that would have been unheard of before the First World War. Catholic social work was no longer seen as a defensive tool to protect the German Catholic population against a German state dominated by Protestants and secularists. Rather, in the 1920s, it had become part of an expansionist missionary programme that tried to keep German speakers that now constituted a minority in the new states of East Central Europe loyal to both their Catholic faith and German nationhood. Offering German-language education, healthcare and pastoral care, Catholics saw German nationalism no longer as a threat but rather as a useful tool to spread Catholic values. Insisting on the unique Catholic dimensions of German nationhood and folk culture legitimised nationalism as a bona fide force that could contribute to the moral reconstruction of Europe.
By assessing Hildegardis’s journey as part of a larger push for Catholic internationalism by German-speaking Catholics, this article has argued that forms of religious internationalism were not fundamentally antinationalist or informed by pious calls for peace. Taking Catholic internationalism away from the Vatican, this study has shown that nationalist concerns were at the very origins of an organisation like Caritas Catholica, the precursor to modern-day Caritas Internationalis, the world’s largest charity organisation after the International Red Cross. German-speaking Catholics were sincere in their worries about the position of their religion vis-à-vis other internationalising worldviews but at the same time utilised its international moral power to promote their transnational conception of a German nation scattered across Europe. German speakers saw the appeal of Catholic social work as an opportunity to strengthen the German position on the international stage. The need to assert Catholic social work against competing worldviews made Catholic activism on the ground adopt German nationalist language. In the meantime, Catholic internationalism became more nationalist.
Acknowledgements
I thank Pieter Judson for his untiring and detailed feedback on the earlier drafts of this article and his shared enthusiasm for the life of Sister Hildegardis. I would also like to extend my gratitude to the anonymous reviewers for making this a better piece. The continuous discussions with Benjamin Carver, Björn Johnsen, Dann Grotum Nielsen and William Sims in our writers’ group have contributed greatly to the text’s style and arguments. I presented earlier versions of this article at the workshop ‘New Directions in Late-Habsburg History’ at the European University Institute in June 2024 and at the ‘Catholics in Conflict, 1900–1945’ conference at King’s College London in May 2025, for which I want to thank the organisers and participants.
