Analyzing race as a historical construction has been used recently to make fascinating discoveries about the enmeshment of race and culture, seeding a fruitful area of discussion and debate among theatre historians and performance scholars. Two new books contribute to and advance this conversation: Tavia Nyong'o's The Amalgamation Waltz: Race, Performance, and the Ruses of Memory and Harvey Young's Embodying Black Experience: Stillness, Critical Memory, and the Black Body. Both understand race to be an idea that dialectically combines a physical, material presence and a historical, social construction; yet each emphasizes a different aspect of this pairing. Young focuses on the materiality of race, whereas Nyong'o emphasizes how its social constructions are articulated.
Nyong'o's book chronicles the centrality of racial hybridity to antebellum discussions of racial difference and national character. Over the course of five chapters, he carefully selects representative details for analysis, proving that the United States was very aware—and very afraid—of the realities and effects of racial mixing even as these same effects were being disavowed. Subjects taken from history show how these debates coursed through the society, from depictions of Crispus Attucks in eighteenth and nineteenth-century illustrations to the gendered and racial panic created by cross-dressed prostitute Peter Sewally in the 1830s. Nyong'o discusses the term hybridity in the nineteenth-century context of its creation and critiques it through the lens of postcolonialism and performance theory. In the nineteenth century, hybridity meant the mixing of black and white races through offspring, but Nyong'o connects this procreative idea to questions of the national “character” and the unattainable teleology of U.S. racial harmony. Hybridity thus is used to analyze various antebellum discourses, from speeches and newspaper articles to minstrel routines and novels, that weigh upon the social divisions of the races and the various futures envisioned through continued racial interaction: “Cultural hybridity became the centerpiece of the drama of human liberation as forms of racial and humanistic essentialism were deployed to harness its more irreverent and outrageous consequences. And it is within this context, within this fold, that the discourses of miscegenation and amalgamation proliferated” (22).
The complex dualities of cultural hybridity culminate in the most searching chapter of the book: “Minstrel Trouble: Racial Travesty in the Circum-Atlantic Fold.” To the discussion of racial surrogation and the carnivalesque that minstrelsy typically evokes, Nyong'o adds the ambivalent responses from the black abolitionist press. He notes: “The white attraction to black song and dance, which fed into white supremacy as black abolitionists well knew, was paradoxically also the grounds upon which a challenge to that supremacy could be mounted, precisely insofar as minstrelsy refused to imagine an America without blacks” (132). For Nyong'o, paradoxes such as these reside inside antebellum remembrances, such as historical reenactments and museum displays, to this day.
Young has a similar historical trajectory and schema. In the opening chapter of his book, he describes its core idea: “Embodying Black Experience spotlights the ways in which an idea of the black body has been and continues to be projected across actual physical bodies; it chronicles how the misrecognition of individuated bodies as ‘the black body’ creates similar experiences” (4). Tying this argument to performance theory, he writes: “Spectacular events demonstrate the ways in which conceptions of blackness are projected across individual bodies. They reveal that embodied experiences develop, in part, from racial (mis)recognition and spotlight how an idea of the black body materially affects actual bodies” (11). He tracks instances of this complicated social calculus—how an idea materially affects bodies—in each of the book's chapters. For example, Chapter 2 looks at instances of blacks as the subject of photography: slaves forced to sit in front of a daguerreotypist as scientific evidence, 1920s studio portraiture, and Depression-era images of poverty in the South. Chapter 3 connects the biographies of four black boxers from different eras: Tom Molineaux, Jack Johnson, Joe Louis, and Muhammad Ali. In each of these chapters, the more recent subjects learn from the sufferings of the past even as they face—and meet with an evolving sense of dignity—similar repressions. The modern-day perspective in the book's early chapters is that of the author, whereas Chapter 4 charts a similar historical trajectory through the works of contemporary playwrights that specifically address this “idea of the black body”: Suzan-Lori Parks's Venus and In the Blood, Robbie McCauley's Sally's Rape, and Dael Orlandersmith's Yellowman. These works approach history at a microcosmic level, and show how normative standards of race difference are imposed upon individuals. The performed history that Young aims to describe balances the personal with the racial.
Near the end of Embodying Black Experience, Young encapsulates his argument in a single material object: the lynching souvenir, a piece of a dead (or soon to be killed) body, such as a toe or a strip of flesh, which was cut off as a keepsake of the event. “Containing within itself the various features of the souvenir, the fetish, and the remain,” he writes, “the body part recalls and remembers the performance of which it is a part. It not only gestures toward the beliefs that motivated its theft but also renders visible the body from which it was taken” (169). Young movingly charts how the meanings of these effects have changed over time. These body parts originally emblematized the carnival atmosphere of the lynching event; because of the efforts of chroniclers and historians, however, they are now remainders/reminders of an act of complicit communal violence upon an individual. As historical and cultural perspectives shift, what once was the “idea of the black body” becomes a black body.
As a way of acknowledging the rich connections between these books, I want to focus in closing on several ideas central to both authors: the first is blackness, in its various historical contexts, and the other is time, with its expressions of past and future, critical memory and primitivist accumulation. The greatest strength of these studies, particularly when thought of together, is their consideration of how time and blackness mutate and interact in social and national landscapes. In fact, it is difficult to find a sentence in either work where the former term does not evoke the latter. “Race is a theory of history,” Nyong'o succinctly states, “so exposing its historicity will trouble its foundations and foreground its assumptions regarding time and temporality” (11). And Young arrives at a similar conceptualization: “Black is always an imprecise projection or designation. … The mystery of blackness, which manages to become a fact through repeated deployment across a range of bodies, encourages the (mis)identification of individuated bodies (a body) as the black body” (7). Memory is a similar historical mystery, deployed across bodies and over time. Both historians find import in a sense of collective African American memory; it is a way of critiquing essentialist racial notions while still allowing for experiential racial identity. Young discusses critical memory as something employed by agents and examiners of history, calling it “the process of identifying similarities—shared experiences and attributes of being and becoming—among black folk not by presuming that black bodies have the same memories but by acknowledging that related histories create experiential overlap” (18). And Nyong'o labels this experiential overlap as collective memory, which he employs in the service of a “hybrid and performative historiography” (7). In all, the two works explore a U.S. history in and of the body.
The scope and ambition of these studies (buoyed by rich citations of performance theory) leads them to similar places, in terms of both conclusions and physical locations. Near the end of both books, the authors discuss present-day museums and museum exhibitions. Young charts the problems surrounding America's Black Holocaust Museum in Milwaukee, and Nyong'o examines the work of contemporary artists, such as Fred Wilson and Ellen Driscoll, who invade museums to question claims of historical certainty. Nyong'o and Young analyze the intentions of the curators and also chart their own, sometimes very personal, reactions. Although these are not the final words of either text, this was the final, lasting image I took from both: edifices of history being traversed by subjective, individual black bodies.
This repeated scene could not be coincidence, and it led me to wonder how the organization of separate volumes could arrive at such similar codas. Neither The Amalgamation Waltz nor Embodying Black Experience is a linear or episodic analysis of culture and race. Instead, each book spirals or blossoms outward, as ideas and images lap and overlap. But structuring histories in this way raises several questions: Why these subjects and not others? Why these chapters and not more (or fewer)? If these books are governed by neither time nor space, neither genre nor discipline, neither material elements nor thematic conceits, what brings them to a close? The answer from both books is that the authors themselves bring them to a close, in the present, because this is the moment to which history has brought us, and we can go no further.
