The phrase “comprehensive plan” is so commonplace in discussions about the modern city that it has become mundane. William Bissell's rich study of town planning in colonial Zanzibar challenges readers to pay close attention to the wealth of meaning concealed behind this phrase. Rather than the two-dimensional representation of the material future of a city deified by the discipline of planning (and associated disciplines), Bissell reveals the comprehensive plan as both the product of and stimulus for complex social processes.
British travel narratives of the early 19th century decried the disorderly nature of Zanzibar's “oriental” urban fabric—just one of several characteristics that defined the then-ruling Omani sultanate as premodern, unenlightened, and in need of European intervention. Upon the declaration of British protectorate status in 1890, colonial administrators considered it imperative to rationalize Zanzibar city and the society that underpinned it by differentiating the built environment according to function and opening up space for ventilation and circulation—in short, by remaking the city according to the principles of the emerging field of town planning.
What ensued was a seemingly endless number of initiatives (1893, 1905, 1909, 1923, 1958, 1968, 1982) that aimed to create a visually and materially legible, economically productive, and socially harmonious city in one fell swoop. By virtue of administrators’ blind faith in the efficacy of planning and their refusal to acknowledge its limitations in the face of scarce financial resources, each planning initiative spawned additions to the existing bureaucratic and legal framework of the colony. It comes as no surprise to our jaded 21st-century sensibilities that more bureaucracy led to greater inefficiency rather than the long-sought total solution.
What is more surprising is how early these problems emerge in the history of planning. Bissell conclusively demonstrates that planning, by its very nature (rather than because of flawed implementation), was doomed to massive failures. Bureaucratic inefficiency reached absurd levels in Zanzibar. An illustrative case was the formation of a Joint Building Authority (JBA) in 1929. Charged with coordinating decisions about the urban environment, the JBA was eventually forced to rescind its decisions after the discovery that the master plan on which it based its work had not been legally approved (p. 288). The problem, according to Bissell, lay with structural inconsistencies in the discipline of planning itself. Equally important, however, were the irreconcilable contradictions of the colonial state, and specifically its desire to simultaneously promote social welfare and cultural “progress” and render the colonies financially independent. What unites these two subjects, the discipline of planning and the colonial state, are the discrepancies that emerge between their abstract conceptualization and embodied reality.
Bissell's book consists of seven chapters, an introduction, and a conclusion. The introduction presents Bissell's key themes—the relationship between abstract urban plans, the processes through which these plans were created, and the lived experience of the city—in a Lefebvrian theoretical framework. In the first chapter, Bissell analyzes European interpretations of Zanzibari social structure and built form. Chapter 2 explores the emergence of the British protectorate, its ad hoc structure and modus operandi. Some strategies that the state used in order to realize its a priori image of a dual (European/African) city are presented in Chapter 3. Environmental determinism and its manifestations in colonial contexts are the subjects of Chapter 4. In Chapter 5, the author revises the concept of “development” to include colonial projects. Chapters 6 and 7 explore how the protracted afterlives of planning initiatives were created. In his conclusion, Bissell discusses the overall success of the colonial state despite gross inefficiency. The book ends by resituating Zanzibar's recent development projects in this lineage of colonial planning.
Each chapter is illustrated with case studies that illuminate the workings of the colonial state and of the discipline of town planning. These include, among others, an analysis of sanitary segregation as a justification for the demolition of “huts” (themselves an artificially contrived category) (p. 191), a study of the administration's attempts to complete a comprehensive sociological survey of the city as a prerequisite for master planning (p. 127), and the frequent redistricting of the city according to geography and use (p. 120). This plethora of detailed description is the book's greatest strength and weakness. Scholars would do well to follow Bissell's lead in attending to the seemingly mundane aspects of colonialism. For example, his fine-grained description of the temporally- and resource-inefficient operations of the protectorate government (p. 84) offers a model for substantiating claims only hinted at by other scholars: “Until 1907, the government was only open five hours a day, and there were twenty-nine public holidays” (p. 100). Throughout the book, Bissell shows how small blunders were emblematic of systemic problems. However, the litany of detailed proposals, decrees, and personalities that emerges as a result will be difficult for most readers to track. Lists of dramatis personae and illustrations, along with a glossary, would have enhanced the accessibility of the text. An extension of this problem is the dearth and low quality of existing illustrations (all black and white) in the book. Maps and plans are frequently indecipherable. This is problematic for a book whose thesis is that urban plans are much more than they seem.
Bissell misses some important opportunities to achieve his goal of using ethnographic methods to reveal disjunctions between the abstract visions and embodied realities of colonial town planning. Readers only catch glimpses of the alternate rationality of Zanzibar city that protectorate officials tried to overturn. For example, what systems were in place before the arrival of the British that made it possible for Zanzibaris to live in a city that was apparently “suffused with poisonous air, noxious emanations, and foul waters” (p. 163)? It is notoriously difficult to ascertain and articulate ways of seeing the world that differ from those framed by Enlightenment rationality, but ethnography may indeed offer some opportunities.
Rather than ethnography, the book relies on careful readings of archival documents. Furthermore, in an attempt to redress a perceived overemphasis on form in the analysis of urban plans, Bissell privileges written over visual texts. Plan drawings are, however, rarely read in isolation even in analyses that privilege form. Every final drawing is preceded by a drawer-full of drafts and written texts that retroactively document the design as a process of negotiation between abstract ideas and the “elaborate legal means and bureaucratic maneuverings” of their intended realization (p. 281). Planners and designers have certainly considered this disjunction between plan and reality since the utopian schemes of the Renaissance. What is different about the colonial case?
This important question remains underexplored in the book: was the inverse relationship between bureaucracy and efficiency present in colonial Zanzibar characteristic of colonial states in particular or typical of all modern nation-states? A more substantial engagement with Michel Foucault's concept of governmentality and the associated body of scholarship on colonial governmentality, or with contrasting theories of the colonial state, might have been productive. Bissell's book nevertheless contributes significantly to our understanding of colonial power and its relationship to the planned and built environment. Selected chapters might be usefully incorporated into graduate and upper-level undergraduate courses. I highly recommend the book to specialists.
