The essays in this book constitute a useful survey of current thinking about panentheism, especially in so far as panentheism is judged to be fruitful for the dialogue between scientists and theologians.
The book is organised into four sections, each of which has a distinctive purpose. The first section takes a historical and analytical look at panentheism: historical because these essays attempt to situate panentheism as the alternative that has emerged from what the authors regard as the dead-end choice between pantheism and classical theism; analytical because the essays invest considerable effort in the task of defining panentheism.
For, as several essays in this section (and others) note, panentheism means different things to different people. For some, it has the minimal sense of affirming God's presence in or with the world while prudently avoiding pantheism. Others have a more ambitious definition, whereby they wish to emphasise God's capacity to be influenced by events in the world. As a result, a large portion of this book is devoted to achieving conceptual clarity about panentheism and its theological implications. Indeed, not a few passages are dedicated to discussing the importance and difficulties inherent in trying to achieve conceptual clarity on this subject. It cannot be said that the book comes to a consensus on the issue; however, it is understandably too much to ask of a single book to accomplish this definitional task. The merit of this first section lies in its clear delineation of the range of definitions of panentheism and its indication of the theological issues at stake in each definition.
The second section features essays expounding upon God's relation to the world in the light of modern science. These essays are driven by the conviction that, despite the lack of a universally agreed upon definition of panentheism, traditional theism, as commonly understood, is inadequate for anyone whose worldview is shaped by modern science. Traditional theism, it is felt, errs in portraying divine action as an interruption of the nexus of finite causation. Panentheism is offered as an improvement on traditional theism because it minimises or (for the more daring) eliminates the need to posit such interruptive divine action. On the superiority of panentheism (however loosely defined) in this regard there is unanimity in this book.
The essays of the third section portray Orthodox contributions to the discussion and give the book an ambivalent flavour. On the one hand, these authors embrace one of the uniting theses of the book, the importance of affirming God's presence and activity in the world and of doing so in a conceptually rigorous way. To this end they make use of standard Orthodox ideas such as creatures’ participation in the divine logos and God's ‘energies’ as the principle by which God is active in the world. On the other hand, these authors represent the conservative edge of panentheism, for their unease with the implications that some have drawn is evident. In particular, they steadfastly refuse to concede the possibility that God's being is affected by events in the world, a conviction that comes easily to many of the other contributors. Indeed those portraying Orthodox theology in this collection seem quite content with traditional theism's emphasis on God's transcendence and are distinctly unwilling to compromise that emphasis one bit, except to the extent that their tradition provides means for affirming God's immanence as well.
The final section is entitled ‘Western Christianity’, but the four essays here do not attempt to be representative. Indeed, their authors are quite eclectic – a Thomist, a process-theist, an author who leans towards process theology (although not without reservations) and an author urging a wisdom-Christology. Consequently, this section had little thematic unity, apart from the authors’ agreement on the evils of deism and the inadequacy – variously assessed – of traditional theism.
The book begins and ends with chapters whose purpose is to summarise the remaining essays and to note points of agreement and disagreement among them.
As someone who follows the dialogue between scientists and theologians, I found the essays in this book to be helpful in clarifying and distinguishing the various notions of panentheism. Several (especially in the second section) provide helpful suggestions for thinking about divine action. The essays representing Orthodox theology ably set forth the convictions of that tradition and thus provide a distinctively theological perspective that is sometimes absent in the dialogue between scientists and theologians. The remaining essays likewise offered stimulating analyses of the issues.
But outside the relatively small universe of people who follow this dialogue, who is likely to profit from this book? First of all, it must be admitted that a considerable amount of background knowledge is required if readers are to follow the arguments of these essays. The reader must be able to catch subtle differences between various shades of panentheism, as well as understand notions such as emergence and top-down causality. As a result, this book could be used in an undergraduate setting only if the instructor were first able to provide students with the requisite background knowledge. It appears that this book is aimed primarily at active participants in the science-theology dialogue and secondarily at readers who have some theological or philosophical training.
This observation about the book's ostensible audience should by no means be taken as a criticism. This collection serves the admirable purpose of announcing the status of current discussion about a topic of great theological importance. The fact that its primary audience is a bit narrow and that it fails to achieve a consensus on the details of panentheism is no criticism but instead an observation of the fact that theology faces issues today that are unprecedented. Never before has theology had to accommodate its view of divine activity to a scientific account of causality that, in its extent and detail, renders usual views of divine activity either unnecessary or inconceivable. The essays in this book represent the attempts by thinkers daring enough to affirm the meaningfulness of our talk of divine action while taking into full account the claims of modern science. In short, these essays portray the state of theological thinking today on the frontier of knowledge and thought. The messiness of the task is an index of the work to be done. This book marks an important step forward in the difficult but necessary business of clarification and the equally difficult and necessary business of speculation that are a part of that work.
