Symbolism and Ritual in a One-Party Regime provides an intimate look at a now vanished world: the presidential campaigns conducted by Mexico's long-ruling hegemonic party, the Partido Revolucionario Institutional (Revolutionary Institutional Party, PRI), in the days of its power. The authors begin with a puzzling question. Given that during PRI hegemony the election of the PRI candidate to the presidency was never in doubt, why did the party and the candidates invest so much energy, money and time in mounting an elaborate presidential campaign? The authors make a compelling argument that the intended audience of these campaigns was not the voters, but the political class itself. Campaigns served to provide information to the future president about the competence and mobilising skills of specific party leaders, gave clues to political elites about the future president's priorities, informed the candidate about the demands of different regions and sectors, and identified the candidate publicly with all of the disparate components of the ‘Revolutionary Family’, converting him into a symbol of unity for the nation.
The book draws on an ethnographic analysis of the 1987–8 presidential campaign of Carlos Salinas de Gortari, a fateful choice in retrospect, given that the 1988 election was a turning point in PRI control, when a breakaway candidate, a former PRI member, Cuauhtémoc Cárdenas, mounted the most successful challenge to PRI dominance to that point and nearly upset Salinas in the process. Yet the authors make a persuasive argument that during the campaign itself neither Salinas nor the PRI, nor even Cárdenas, expected this outcome; thus the Salinas campaign was run largely according to traditional principles. The authors base their conclusions on participant observation of numerous campaign events, hundreds of interviews with PRI operatives and attendees at events, and content analysis of media coverage. The book is well written, though at times awkwardly translated, and gives the reader a ‘you-are-there’ feeling of the sights, sounds and atmosphere of PRI campaigns.
Although some of the research upon which this book is based has been previously published, much of it will be unfamiliar to a US audience, and the book advances in important ways beyond earlier publications. In particular, points about the interpretation of campaign events and rituals are marshalled together with analysis of media coverage in support of an overarching argument. Though obviously of interest to Mexicanists and historians as an account of the PRI's past, the book has the potential to have a broader impact on studies of what scholars have called ‘competitive authoritarianism’ (Steven Levitsky and Lucan Way, Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes after the Cold War, Cambridge University Press, 2010), or ‘electoral authoritarianism’ (Andreas Schedler (ed.), Electoral Authoritarianism: The Dynamics of Unfree Competition, Lynne Rienner, 2006). This regime type has attracted growing attention from researchers because it seems so common in many parts of the world.
Much of the research on competitive authoritarian regimes has focused on how such regimes stay in power and what might bring them down. This book illuminates the functions of electoral campaigns for the authoritarian regime itself. What do authoritarian regimes intend to achieve by holding elections and staging campaigns? The authors of Symbolism and Ritual criticise interpretations suggesting that elections are held to improve regime legitimacy, noting that elections can hardly improve legitimacy if everyone knows they are not fair, and point instead to the internal benefits of electoral campaigns for the ruling coalition. This focus on the functions of campaigns in electoral authoritarianism may prove a fruitful line of research in other cases.
However, the authors themselves make relatively little effort to go beyond the Mexican case to point out potential applications to other authoritarian regimes. Instead, they tack on to the end of the book, after the chapter entitled ‘Conclusions’, two more chapters on the 2000 and 2006 elections, which make rather strained comparisons between pre-1988 PRI campaigns and the later campaigns of the Partido Acción Nacional (National Action Party, PAN) and the Partido de la Revolución Democrática (Party of the Democratic Revolution, PRD). Clientelism is not unique to the PRI or to Mexico; neither are efforts by politicians to cloak themselves in national symbols. Even the tea-leaf-reading aspects of the Salinas campaign, noting who stands close to the candidate, who sits on the dais, and so forth, are secondary aspects of many competitive campaigns. What was unique about PRI campaigns prior to democracy was simply that these aspects constituted their primary purpose. Thus, the persistence of these features of campaigns after 2000 does not by itself reveal, in my view, a ‘continuation of the traditional political culture (holistic and hierarchical)’ (p. 286).
Moreover, it is not entirely clear what ‘culture’ means to the authors. The PRI certainly operated under a system of informal norms and expectations that helped participants interpret the actions of others and send understandable messages themselves. Yet the speed with which, even in the PRI, this ‘traditional political culture’ gave way to a competitive presidential primary and professional media campaigns suggests that these norms did not constitute a set of core values, but rather a more flexible and ultimately disposable repertoire of behaviours. What changed were the structural incentives. As the authors note, ‘in a democratic context, a format that focuses on accommodating internal forces and mediating party conflicts would amount to electoral suicide’ (p. 273). Implicitly, of course, it made perfect sense to concentrate on these goals when the outcome of the election was predetermined.
The University of Arizona Press, which published Symbolism and Ritual in a One-Party Regime, is primarily known for anthropological scholarship, and regular readers of the press will not be disappointed by this work. But those interested in comparative political science (this author's specialty) will also find much to admire and ponder.
