A long standing expert on the world of the Sumerians, and already the author of a leading monograph on the subject, Harriet Crawford, Emeritus Fellow of the Institute of Archaeology of University College London and Senior Fellow at the Cambridge University McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, returns to the theme as the editor of this quite exceptional volume, a work which is at the same time a source book, a statement of the state of research and an exposition of new ideas and approaches. It is a volume which anyone interested in the field - student, layman or academic - will not only want to read but to have on the library shelf. The book is organised into thirty two principal chapters, each written by an expert in their field. Crawford herself, in addition to setting the tone with an excellent introduction, also contributes the chapter on trade. The list of contributors alone is breath-taking: Tony Wilkinson on landscapes, Guillermo Algaze on the prehistory, Augusta McMahon on the third millennium, Graham Cunnigham on language, Nicole Brisch on history, Jason Ur on settlement patterns, Elizabeth Stone on urban structure, Joan Goodnick Westenholz on religion, Benjamin Foster on mythology, Jon Taylor on administration, Magnus Widdell on land management, Holly Pittman on sigillography, Lisa Cooper on connections with Syria, Lamberg-Karlovsky on connections with Iran - the list goes on. It is a magnificent rôle call of the leading lights in the field, it is an extraordinary authorship, and it sets this book apart. It also means that the work has a scope and reliability which is by no means the rule in general studies and which give it a unique authenticity.
The work starts with an examination of the geological background and the geomorphological factors which provide the stage - the ever shifting stage - for the rise and triumph of Sumer. A critical aspect of this is mastery of hydrological resources, a term taken to encompass all water resources - marshes and rivers as well as irrigation channels - and for all of which the sources are constituted out of a rich and not always easily compatible mix of archaeological ground data, satellite imagery and information from the texts. The hydrographic profiles of the two rivers are considered and this, together with a consideration of the focus of the practical texts from (especially) Ur III times leads to the conclusion that short, local canals had significant advantages over longer off-take canals; important political and social implications follow from this. The agricultural organisation is reviewed, examining such factors as allocation of fields, the rates of grain sown and the yields they delivered. It is of course the surplus generated by this agricultural regime which formed the basis of society. The massive building programmes, with their implications for social hierarchy and the organisation of labour, manifest from at least the Late Uruk period, set the course for Sumerian civilisation. And while excavations have focused perhaps a little too much on these monumental remains, their recovery is nevertheless one of the triumphs of archaeology. The deficit is in any case to some extent made up for by the intensive survey to which much of the land of Sumer has been subjected. At least some of the workforce was captive labour; the extent to which this was a bi-product or even a primary aim of the Uruk expansion can at this stage only be guessed at. Also beyond our grasp is what language the texts of this period were being composed in. This said, there is no doubt that by the Early Dynastic period texts were indeed being written in Sumerian; and while the placing of Sumerian in terms of the modern classification of language families is still not settled, the language itself is increasingly understood and decipherable. The evolution and workings of the script are covered, including a look at the numerical and mathematical systems, seals and sealings practices. Other contributions deal with specific aspects - such as social hierarchies, legal systems and organisation of crafts - which can be approached through the texts. Much attention is also given to matters concerning religion, in relation to both architecture and specific matters such as mythology, iconography, sacred marriage and temple administration. Last but not least, extensive coverage is given to the evidence for trade and for military and political contacts and interactions with northern Iraq, Syria (including Ebla and Mari), Turkey, Egypt, Iran, India and the Gulf. A strength of the work is the balanced integration of the textual and archaeological data, and its thoroughness and utility is much enhanced by the fact that each chapter has a dedicated bibliography. This is, in short, a most superb contribution to the field. Crawford and her team have provided a truly valuable service in compiling a unique introduction to the world of ancient Sumer which will clearly be the standard work for a considerable time to come.
