Introduction
Disasters, whether natural or man-made, continue to pose significant challenges to health care systems worldwide. The Asian Disaster Reduction Center defines a disaster as “a serious disruption of the functioning of society, causing widespread human, material, or environmental losses that exceed the ability of affected society to cope using only its resources.” 1 The increasing frequency and severity of disasters globally have highlighted the critical importance of disaster preparedness among health care professionals, particularly nurses who constitute the largest group of health care providers and are often first responders during emergencies. 2
China has reported the highest number of disaster events in Asia, with 577 events documented between 2000 and 2019. 3 The country’s vast geographical diversity creates unique disaster vulnerability profiles across different regions. While first-tier cities like Shanghai and Beijing have established comprehensive disaster preparedness systems with extensive resources, non–first-tier inland cities face significant challenges due to limited funding, infrastructure, and specialized training opportunities.Reference Wang, Sun and Lu 4 This disparity was starkly evident during recent disasters, such as the extreme rainstorm in Henan Province in July 2021, which affected nearly 15 million people and resulted in 398 deaths (Henan Provincial Emergency Management Department, 2022).
The International Council of Nurses (ICN) emphasizes that disaster preparedness and response should be integral components of nurses’ knowledge and skills. 5 However, previous studies have predominantly focused on emergency departments and specialized rescue teams in tertiary hospitals in major urban centers, with limited attention to the unique challenges faced by nurses in smaller cities and county-level hospitals.Reference Li, Turale, Stone and Petrini 6 , Reference Zhang, Yang and Cao 7 This research gap is particularly concerning as these areas often bear disproportionate impacts during disasters due to their geographical locations, resource constraints, and infrastructure limitations.
Our previous quantitative studyReference Wu, Li, Wang and Xu 8 investigated disaster preparedness among nurses in Yongcheng City, Henan Province, using the Disaster Preparedness Evaluation Tool (DPET). The findings revealed moderate levels of disaster preparedness (total average score: 146.76 ± 34.98), with professional titles, disaster relief experience, and disaster training identified as significant influencing factors. While these quantitative results provided valuable insights into the current status and influencing factors of disaster preparedness, they did not capture the lived experiences, psychological impacts, organizational challenges, and contextual nuances that shape nurses’ disaster response capabilities in these settings.
Qualitative research approaches offer unique advantages in exploring complex phenomena within their natural contexts, particularly when seeking to understand human experiences, perceptions, and the meanings individuals attribute to events.Reference Creswell and Poth 9 By employing a phenomenological approach, this study aims to complement our quantitative findings by delving deeper into the lived experiences of nurses involved in disaster response in non–first-tier Chinese cities. This methodological triangulation enhances the comprehensiveness and validity of our understanding of disaster nursing preparedness in resource-limited settings.
The purpose of this qualitative study was to explore the lived experiences, challenges, and perceptions of nurses regarding disaster preparedness in Yongcheng City, Henan Province, with the goal of identifying barriers, facilitators, and potential strategies for enhancing disaster nursing capabilities in non–first-tier Chinese cities. Specifically, this study sought to address the following research questions:
-
1. What are the lived experiences of nurses participating in disaster response activities in non–first-tier Chinese cities?
-
2. What psychological, professional, and organizational factors influence nurses’ disaster preparedness and response capabilities?
-
3. What strategies do nurses employ to overcome challenges in disaster response situations?
-
4. How can disaster nursing education, training, and management be improved to enhance preparedness in resource-limited settings?
By addressing these questions, this study contributes to the growing body of literature on disaster nursing while providing practical insights for health care administrators, educators, and policymakers seeking to enhance disaster preparedness in similar contexts. The findings have implications for developing targeted interventions, training programs, and support systems that address the unique needs and challenges of nurses in non–first-tier Chinese cities.
Methods
Study Design
This study employed a descriptive phenomenological approach to explore the lived experiences of nurses involved in disaster response in non–first-tier Chinese cities. Phenomenology was selected as the methodological framework because it allows for in-depth exploration of individuals’ lived experiences and the meanings they attribute to these experiences.Reference Giorgi 10 This approach was particularly appropriate for understanding the complex, multifaceted nature of disaster response from the perspective of nurses working in resource-limited settings.
Setting
The study was conducted in Yongcheng City, located in the easternmost part of Henan Province, China. Yongcheng has a population of approximately 1.68 million and covers an area of 2020 square kilometers. The city is rich in mineral resources and is characterized by its inland location and county-level administrative status. Four comprehensive hospitals at or above the second level in Yongcheng were included in the study: 2 tertiary hospitals serving as the city’s main medical care and emergency centers, and 2 secondary first-class hospitals affiliated with a group. These hospitals represent the primary health care infrastructure available for disaster response in the region.
Participants
Participants were recruited using purposive sampling to ensure the selection of individuals with direct experience in disaster response activities. The inclusion criteria were: (1) registered nurses with at least 3 years of clinical experience; (2) current employment in 1 of the 4 selected hospitals; (3) participation in at least 1 disaster response activity or major emergency event; and (4) willingness to share their experiences and insights. We aimed for maximum variation in terms of age, gender, professional title, department, and type of disaster experience to capture diverse perspectives.
Potential participants were initially identified through hospital nursing departments and approached by a research team member who explained the purpose and procedures of the study. Those who expressed interest were provided with detailed information about the study and given time to consider their participation. A total of 12 nurses (9 females and 3 males) from various departments, including emergency, intensive care, surgery, and internal medicine, agreed to participate. Sample size was determined by data saturation, which was reached when no new themes or significant insights emerged from additional interviews.
Data Collection
Data were collected through semistructured in-depth interviews conducted between September and December 2023. An interview guide was developed based on the literature review, our previous quantitative findings, and the research questions. The guide included open-ended questions focusing on participants’ experiences during disaster response, challenges encountered, coping strategies employed, perceptions of preparedness, and suggestions for improvement. Example questions included: “Could you describe your experience during the most recent disaster response you participated in?,” “What challenges did you face during the disaster response?,” and “How did the experience affect you professionally and personally?”
Interviews were conducted by 2 researchers trained in qualitative interviewing techniques. Each interview was held in a private room at the participant’s workplace or another location of their choice to ensure comfort and confidentiality. Interviews lasted between 45 and 90 minutes and were audio-recorded with participants’ consent. Field notes were taken during and immediately after each interview to capture nonverbal cues, contextual information, and initial analytical insights. Demographic information was collected at the beginning of each interview.
Data Analysis
All interviews were transcribed verbatim within 24 hours of completion and analyzed using Colaizzi’s seven-step method,Reference Colaizzi, Valle and King 11 which is widely used in phenomenological nursing research. The analysis process included: (1) reading all transcripts multiple times to gain a sense of the whole; (2) extracting significant statements related to the phenomenon under study; (3) formulating meanings from these significant statements; (4) organizing the formulated meanings into clusters of themes; (5) integrating the findings into an exhaustive description of the phenomenon; (6) formulating the fundamental structure of the phenomenon; and (7) validating the findings by returning to participants for verification.
Two researchers independently coded the data and then met to compare and discuss their analyses until consensus was reached. A third researcher was consulted to resolve any disagreements. NVivo 12 software (QSR International, Melbourne, Australia) was used to manage and organize the data. The analysis was conducted in Chinese to preserve the nuances and cultural meanings in the original data, with the final themes and selected quotes translated into English for publication.
Ethical Considerations
The Ethics Committee of Shanghai East Hospital approved the study. All participants provided written informed consent before participation. They were informed about the voluntary nature of participation, their right to withdraw at any time without consequences, and the confidentiality of their information. To protect participants’ privacy, all identifying information was removed from the transcripts, and pseudonyms were used in reporting the findings.
Trustworthiness
Several strategies were employed to ensure the trustworthiness of the study, following Lincoln and Guba’sReference Lincoln and Guba 12 criteria of credibility, transferability, dependability, and confirmability. Credibility was enhanced through prolonged engagement with participants, member checking (sharing preliminary findings with participants for verification), and peer debriefing among the research team. Transferability was addressed by providing thick descriptions of the research context, participants, and findings. Dependability was ensured through maintaining an audit trail of all research decisions and processes. Confirmability was strengthened by researcher reflexivity, acknowledging potential biases and preconceptions, and using direct quotes from participants to support the findings.
Results
Analysis of the interview data revealed five major themes that captured the lived experiences and challenges of nurses involved in disaster response in non–first-tier Chinese cities: (1) Psychological Stress and Emotional Adaptation, (2) Disaster Emergency Response Capacity and Management, (3) Communication and Collaboration, (4) Challenges in Disaster Nursing Capacity Development, and (5) Impact of Disaster Relief Participation. Each theme comprised several subthemes that further elucidated the complex nature of disaster nursing in resource-limited settings. Table 1 presents the demographic characteristics of the participants.
Demographic characteristics of participants (N = 12)

Theme 1: Psychological Stress and Emotional Adaptation
This theme encompassed the psychological experiences of nurses during disaster response and the strategies they employed to manage stress and emotions. Four subthemes emerged: psychological pressure, sense of responsibility and mission, self-regulation strategies, and social support systems.
Subtheme 1.1: Psychological Pressure
Participants consistently described experiencing significant psychological pressure during disaster response activities. This pressure stemmed from various sources, including the urgency and severity of the situation, uncertainty about their capabilities, concern for patients’ outcomes, and worry about their own safety. One participant recounted:
“When I first arrived at the scene after the flash flood, I was overwhelmed by the chaos and suffering. There were so many injured people, and we had limited supplies. I felt my heart racing and my hands trembling. I questioned whether I was adequately prepared for this situation.” (P3, Emergency Department Nurse)
Another nurse described the emotional toll of working with multiple casualties:
“Seeing so many injured people, especially children, was mentally exhausting. I kept thinking about whether I was making the right decisions under such pressure. At night, I couldn’t sleep because the images kept replaying in my mind.” (P7, ICU Nurse)
Subtheme 1.2: Sense of Responsibility and Mission
Despite the psychological challenges, participants expressed a strong sense of professional responsibility and mission that motivated them to persevere. This commitment to their professional duty served as a psychological anchor during difficult situations:
“As nurses, we have a responsibility to help those in need, especially during disasters. This sense of duty gave me strength when I felt overwhelmed. I kept reminding myself that people were counting on us.” (P2, Surgical Department Nurse)
Another participant emphasized the importance of professional identity during crisis situations:
“In that moment, I wasn’t just an individual; I represented the entire healthcare system. This responsibility pushed me to stay focused and provide the best care possible despite my fears and exhaustion.” (P10, Emergency Department Nurse)
Subtheme 1.3: Self-Regulation Strategies
Participants described various self-regulation strategies they developed to manage stress and maintain psychological well-being during and after disaster response. These included mindfulness techniques, positive self-talk, compartmentalization, and physical exercise:
“I learned to take brief moments to breathe deeply and center myself, especially before making critical decisions. This helped me maintain clarity amidst the chaos.” (P5, Internal Medicine Nurse)
“After my shift, I would go for a run or do some physical exercise. It helped me process the stress and emotions I had suppressed during work. Without these outlets, I don’t think I could have continued functioning effectively.” (P8, ICU Nurse)
Subtheme 1.4: Social Support Systems
Participants highlighted the crucial role of social support from colleagues, family members, and institutional structures in helping them cope with the psychological impacts of disaster response:
“The camaraderie among our team was essential. We checked on each other regularly, shared our feelings, and sometimes just sat together in silence. This solidarity made the burden more bearable.” (P1, Emergency Department Nurse)
“My family didn’t always understand what I was going through, but their presence and support when I returned home gave me strength to continue. Just knowing they were there for me made a difference.” (P11, Surgical Department Nurse)
However, several participants noted the absence of formal psychological support systems within their institutions:
“There was no official psychological support or debriefing after the disaster response. We were expected to process everything on our own and return to normal duties immediately. I think this is a significant gap in our system.” (P4, Internal Medicine Nurse)
Theme 2: Disaster Emergency Response Capacity and Management
This theme captured participants’ perceptions and experiences regarding their technical and managerial capabilities during disaster response. Three subthemes emerged: weak emergency rescue skills, imbalanced disaster knowledge structure, and incomplete disaster response processes.
Subtheme 2.1: Weak Emergency Rescue Skills
Many participants expressed concerns about their practical emergency rescue skills, particularly for disasters that were uncommon in their region or required specialized techniques:
“We receive basic emergency training, but it’s often generic and doesn’t address the specific challenges we face during disasters like flash floods or mine accidents that are common in our region.” (P6, Emergency Department Nurse)
“During the chemical spill incident, I realized I lacked specific skills for managing chemical burns and respiratory complications. Our training hadn’t prepared us for this type of disaster.” (P9, ICU Nurse)
Participants also noted discrepancies between training scenarios and real-world disaster situations:
“The gap between simulation exercises and actual disasters is enormous. In real situations, resources are more limited, conditions are unpredictable, and the emotional pressure is much higher. Our training doesn’t adequately prepare us for these realities.” (P12, Surgical Department Nurse)
Subtheme 2.2: Imbalanced Disaster Knowledge Structure
Participants described an imbalance in their disaster knowledge, with a stronger understanding of certain disaster types (particularly infectious disease outbreaks) but limited knowledge of others:
“After COVID-19, we received extensive training on infectious disease management, but our knowledge of other disasters like natural catastrophes or industrial accidents remains limited.” (P3, Emergency Department Nurse)
“I feel confident managing pandemic situations now, but I’m much less prepared for earthquakes or floods. Our knowledge structure isn’t comprehensive enough.” (P7, ICU Nurse)
Subtheme 2.3: Incomplete Disaster Response Processes
Participants identified gaps in disaster response protocols and processes, particularly regarding role clarity, command structures, and postdisaster management:
“During the emergency, there was confusion about who was responsible for what. The command structure wasn’t clear, and this led to some duplication of efforts and other gaps in care.” (P2, Surgical Department Nurse)
“We focus primarily on the immediate response phase, but there’s little guidance on post-disaster recovery and long-term follow-up care. This creates discontinuity in patient care.” (P10, Emergency Department Nurse)
Several participants emphasized the need for more comprehensive disaster response frameworks:
“We need clearer protocols that cover the entire disaster cycle—from preparation to long-term recovery. Currently, our processes are fragmented and reactive rather than systematic.” (P5, Internal Medicine Nurse)
Theme 3: Communication and Collaboration
This theme encompassed participants’ experiences with communication and teamwork during disaster response. Two subthemes emerged: communication abilities and team organization and cooperation capabilities.
Subtheme 3.1: Communication Abilities
Participants described various communication challenges during disaster response, including information transmission under pressure, communication with patients and families, and interdepartmental coordination:
“In crisis situations, clear communication becomes even more critical yet more difficult. Sometimes important information was lost or distorted as it passed through multiple people under pressure.” (P1, Emergency Department Nurse)
“Communicating with distressed patients and families requires special skills that many of us haven’t been formally trained in. It’s challenging to provide clear information while also offering emotional support.” (P8, ICU Nurse)
Several participants noted that communication difficulties were exacerbated by technological limitations:
“When the cellular network was overloaded during the flood, we had to rely on runners to transmit messages between different areas. We weren’t prepared with alternative communication methods.” (P11, Surgical Department Nurse)
Subtheme 3.2: Team Organization and Cooperation Capabilities
Participants emphasized the importance of effective teamwork during disaster response while highlighting challenges in team coordination:
“Working with teams from different departments or hospitals was challenging because we had different protocols and terminology. This sometimes led to confusion and delays.” (P4, Internal Medicine Nurse)
“The most effective teams were those that had trained together before the disaster. When you’re working with unfamiliar colleagues during a crisis, it adds another layer of complexity.” (P6, Emergency Department Nurse)
Participants also described how leadership qualities influenced team functioning:
“Strong leadership made all the difference. When we had a clear leader who could make decisions quickly and coordinate our efforts, we worked much more effectively despite the chaos.” (P9, ICU Nurse)
Theme 4: Challenges in Disaster Nursing Capacity Development
This theme captured the institutional and systemic barriers to developing disaster nursing capabilities in non–first-tier cities. Four subthemes emerged: lack of quality training opportunities, insufficient human resources, high work intensity, and inadequate hospital attention.
Subtheme 4.1: Lack of Quality Training Opportunities
Participants consistently highlighted limited access to specialized disaster nursing training, particularly compared to their counterparts in first-tier cities:
“We rarely have opportunities for advanced disaster nursing training. Most specialized courses are held in major cities, and only a few selected nurses from our hospital can attend due to cost and staffing constraints.” (P3, Emergency Department Nurse)
“The training we do receive is often theoretical rather than practical. We need more hands-on simulation exercises that reflect our local disaster risks and resource constraints.” (P12, Surgical Department Nurse)
Subtheme 4.2: Insufficient Human Resources
Participants described how staffing shortages affected disaster preparedness and response capabilities:
“We’re already understaffed for routine operations. During disasters, we’re stretched even thinner, which affects both the quality of emergency care and regular patient services.” (P7, ICU Nurse)
“Unlike big city hospitals, we don’t have specialized disaster response teams. The same nurses handling daily care must also respond to emergencies, often without adequate rest periods.” (P2, Surgical Department Nurse)
Subtheme 4.3: High Work Intensity
Participants reported experiencing extreme workloads during disaster response, often without adequate rest or rotation systems:
“During the COVID-19 surge, I worked 12-hour shifts for 14 consecutive days. This level of exhaustion affects decision-making and increases the risk of errors.” (P5, Internal Medicine Nurse)
“The physical demands of disaster response are enormous—standing for hours, lifting patients, working in uncomfortable protective equipment. We need better systems to manage fatigue and prevent burnout.” (P10, Emergency Department Nurse)
Subtheme 4.4: Inadequate Hospital Attention
Participants perceived that disaster preparedness was not always prioritized by hospital administration, particularly during noncrisis periods:
“Disaster preparedness often feels like an afterthought. It becomes a priority only after an incident occurs, then fades from attention until the next crisis.” (P1, Emergency Department Nurse)
“Budget allocations for disaster preparedness are minimal compared to other hospital priorities. This affects everything from training opportunities to equipment availability.” (P8, ICU Nurse)
Theme 5: Impact of Disaster Relief Participation
This theme captured how participation in disaster response affected nurses professionally and personally. Two subthemes emerged: professional impact and personal life impact.
Subtheme 5.1: Professional Impact
Participants described how disaster response experiences influenced their professional development, skills, and career perspectives:
“Participating in disaster response accelerated my professional growth. I developed skills and confidence that would have taken years to acquire in routine practice.” (P6, Emergency Department Nurse)
“The experience changed how I approach everyday nursing. I’m more resourceful, adaptable, and better at prioritizing care even in non-emergency situations.” (P9, ICU Nurse)
Some participants noted that their disaster experiences influenced their career choices:
“After being involved in the emergency response team, I decided to pursue additional training in disaster nursing. It gave me a new professional purpose.” (P4, Internal Medicine Nurse)
Subtheme 5.2: Personal Life Impact
Participants reflected on how disaster response experiences affected their personal lives, relationships, and worldviews:
“The experience changed my perspective on life. I became more appreciative of small joys and less concerned with trivial problems.” (P11, Surgical Department Nurse)
“My family noticed changes in me after the disaster response. Some were positive—I was more resilient and compassionate. But I also brought home stress and sometimes had difficulty disconnecting from work.” (P3, Emergency Department Nurse)
Several participants described experiencing symptoms of posttraumatic stress:
“For months after the major accident, I had nightmares and would become anxious when hearing sirens. We need better recognition and support for these psychological after-effects.” (P7, ICU Nurse)
A summary of the extracted themes, subthemes, and representative participant quotes is presented in Table 2, offering a comprehensive overview of the qualitative findings. The relationships among the subthemes and their development process are illustrated in Figure 1. Figure 2 presents a thematic map that visually synthesizes the lived experiences and key challenges faced by nurses during disaster response.
Themes, subthemes, and representative quotes from participants

The development process of subthemes.

Thematic map of nurses’ lived experiences in disaster response in non–first-tier Chinese cities.

Discussion
This qualitative study explored the lived experiences and challenges of nurses involved in disaster response in non–first-tier Chinese cities, providing valuable insights that complement our previous quantitative findings.Reference Wu, Li, Wang and Xu 8 The emergence of 5 major themes—Psychological Stress and Emotional Adaptation, Disaster Emergency Response Capacity and Management, Communication and Collaboration, Challenges in Disaster Nursing Capacity Development, and Impact of Disaster Relief Participation—highlights the complex, multifaceted nature of disaster nursing in resource-limited settings. In this section, we discuss these findings in relation to existing literature and their implications for practice, education, and policy.
Psychological Dimensions of Disaster Response
Our findings revealed that nurses in non–first-tier cities experience significant psychological pressure during disaster response, consistent with previous studies documenting psychological distress among health care workers in emergency situations.Reference Brooks, Dunn, Amlôt, Rubin and Greenberg 13 , Reference Labrague and De Los Santos 14 However, our study extends this understanding by highlighting how the resource constraints and limited specialized support in smaller cities may exacerbate these psychological challenges. The absence of formal psychological support systems reported by our participants is particularly concerning and aligns with findings from other resource-limited settings globally.Reference Hugelius, Adolfsson, Örtenwall and Gifford 15
The strong sense of professional responsibility and mission expressed by participants served as a psychological protective factor, enabling them to persevere despite challenges. This finding resonates with the concept of “moral resilience” described by Rushton et al.,Reference Rushton, Caldwell and Kurtz 16 which refers to the capacity to sustain integrity in response to moral complexity, confusion, distress, or setbacks. However, while this professional commitment is admirable, it should not substitute for systematic psychological support structures. As noted by Veenema et al.,Reference Veenema, Griffin and Gable 17 health care organizations have an ethical responsibility to provide comprehensive psychological support to disaster responders.
The self-regulation strategies developed by nurses in our study represent important adaptive mechanisms that warrant further investigation and potential incorporation into disaster nursing training programs. Similar coping strategies have been documented in studies of health care workers responding to major disasters,Reference Sun, Wei and Shi 18 , Reference Mao, Yang and Li 19 suggesting that these approaches may be universally valuable despite contextual differences.
Technical and Managerial Capabilities
The concerns expressed by participants regarding their emergency rescue skills, particularly for region-specific disasters, highlight a critical gap in disaster nursing education. This finding aligns with our quantitative results, which showed moderate scores in disaster skills (3.15 ± 0.39) and knowledge (3.48 ± 0.30). The imbalance in disaster knowledge structure, with stronger preparation for infectious disease outbreaks but limited knowledge of other disaster types, reflects global trends following the COVID-19 pandemic.Reference Labrague and De Los Santos 14 However, this imbalance may be particularly problematic in regions like Henan Province, which faces diverse disaster risks including floods, mine accidents, and extreme weather events.
The gap between simulation exercises and real-world disaster situations identified by participants underscores the need for more realistic, context-specific training approaches. This finding is consistent with research by Xia et al.Reference Xia, Li, Chen, Jin and Zhang 20 and Yan et al.,Reference Yan, Turale, Stone and Petrini 21 who emphasized the importance of high-fidelity simulation and scenario-based learning in disaster nursing education. For non–first-tier cities with limited resources, developing cost-effective yet realistic training methods represents a significant challenge that requires innovative solutions.
The incomplete disaster response processes described by participants, particularly regarding role clarity and command structures, echo findings from other studies of disaster response in resource-limited settings.Reference Baack and Alfred 22 , Reference Tzeng, Feng and Cheng 23 Clear protocols covering the entire disaster cycle—from preparation to long-term recovery—are essential for effective disaster management but are often lacking in smaller health care facilities. This gap may be addressed through the development of standardized yet adaptable disaster response frameworks tailored to the specific contexts and resources of non–first-tier cities.
Communication and Teamwork Dynamics
Communication challenges during disaster response, including information transmission under pressure and coordination across departments, emerged as significant concerns in our study. These findings align with previous research identifying communication as a critical factor in disaster response effectiveness.Reference Veenema, Losinski and Hilmi 24 , Reference Sonneborn, Miller, Head and Cross 25 The technological limitations experienced during disasters, such as overloaded cellular networks, highlight the need for redundant communication systems and protocols—a challenge that may be particularly acute in resource-constrained settings.
The importance of preestablished team relationships and clear leadership, emphasized by our participants, is consistent with the concept of “team familiarity” described byReference Salas, Reyes and McDaniel 26 as a key determinant of team performance during crises. For non–first-tier hospitals with limited opportunities for specialized team training, developing strategies to enhance team cohesion and leadership within existing constraints is essential. This might include regular interdepartmental exercises, joint training sessions, and leadership development programs focused on crisis management.
Systemic Challenges in Disaster Nursing Development
The institutional and systemic barriers identified in our study—lack of quality training opportunities, insufficient human resources, high work intensity, and inadequate hospital attention—represent significant obstacles to enhancing disaster nursing capabilities in non–first-tier cities. These findings extend our quantitative results by providing deeper insights into the contextual factors that influence disaster preparedness scores.
Limited access to specialized disaster nursing training, particularly compared to counterparts in first-tier cities, creates an inequity in disaster preparedness that may exacerbate existing health care disparities between urban and rural areas in China.Reference Qin, Liu and Xie 27 This disparity is concerning, given that smaller cities and rural areas often face higher disaster risks due to geographical factors and infrastructure limitations.Reference Wang, Sun and Lu 4
Staffing shortages and extreme workloads during disaster response not only affect the quality of care but also contribute to burnout and psychological distress among nurses. This finding aligns with research by Luo et al.Reference Luo 28 and Zhang et al.,Reference Zhang, Zhang and Gong 29 who documented high rates of burnout among health care workers in resource-limited settings during crises. Developing sustainable workforce models that account for surge capacity needs while preventing burnout represents a critical challenge for health care administrators in non–first-tier cities.
The perception that disaster preparedness is not prioritized by hospital administration, particularly during noncrisis periods, reflects a common challenge in disaster management globally—the difficulty of maintaining readiness for low-probability, high-impact events.Reference Veenema, Lavin, Griffin, Gable, Couig and Dobalian 30 However, this challenge may be magnified in resource-constrained settings where competing priorities for limited funding are particularly acute.
Professional and Personal Impacts
The transformative impact of disaster response experiences on nurses’ professional development and personal lives represents a significant finding with implications for both individual career trajectories and organizational talent development. The accelerated skill development and increased adaptability reported by participants align with the concept of “post-traumatic growth” documented in studies of health care workers following disaster response.Reference Manning-Jones, dT and Stephens 31
However, the psychological after-effects described by some participants, including symptoms of posttraumatic stress, highlight the potential costs of disaster response participation without adequate support systems. This finding underscores the importance of comprehensive follow-up care for disaster responders, including psychological assessment and support services.Reference Brooks, Amlôt, Rubin and Greenberg 32
Implications for Practice
Based on our findings, several practical implications emerge for enhancing disaster nursing capabilities in non–first-tier Chinese cities:
-
(1) Psychological Support Systems: Health care organizations should establish formal psychological support mechanisms for nurses involved in disaster response, including predeployment preparation, on-site psychological first aid, and postdeployment debriefing and counseling services. These systems should be adapted to the specific resources and constraints of non–first-tier hospitals.
-
(2) Contextually Relevant Training: Disaster nursing education should be tailored to the specific disaster risks and resource constraints of non–first-tier cities. This includes developing training modules focused on locally relevant disaster types (e.g., floods, mine accidents) and realistic scenarios that account for resource limitations.
-
(3) Communication and Team Training: Regular interdepartmental exercises focusing on communication and coordination during crises should be implemented. These exercises should include scenarios with communication technology failures to prepare teams for technological limitations during actual disasters.
-
(4) Comprehensive Disaster Response Frameworks: Clear protocols covering the entire disaster cycle should be developed, with particular attention to role clarity, command structures, and postdisaster recovery processes. These frameworks should be adaptable to the specific contexts of non–first-tier hospitals.
-
(5) Resource Optimization Strategies: Given the resource constraints in non–first-tier cities, innovative approaches to optimize existing resources should be explored. This might include regional collaboration networks, resource-sharing agreements, and tiered response systems that maximize efficiency.
Table 3 outlines targeted recommendations across key domains for enhancing disaster nursing preparedness in non–first-tier cities, along with specific implementation strategies.
Recommendations for improving disaster nursing preparedness in non–first-tier cities

Strengths and Limitations
This study has several strengths, including its focus on an understudied population (nurses in non–first-tier Chinese cities), the use of a rigorous phenomenological approach, and the complementary nature of the findings to our previous quantitative research. The inclusion of participants from various departments and with diverse disaster experiences enhances the transferability of the findings.
However, several limitations should be acknowledged. First, the study was conducted in a single city in Henan Province, which may limit the transferability of findings to other regions with different disaster risks and health care systems. Second, the retrospective nature of participants’ accounts may be subject to recall bias, particularly for disaster experiences that occurred in the more distant past. Third, despite efforts to ensure trustworthiness, the translation of quotes from Chinese to English may not fully capture the nuances and cultural meanings in the original data.
Future Research Directions
Based on our findings, several directions for future research emerge:
-
(1) Comparative studies examining disaster nursing experiences across different tiers of Chinese cities to identify unique challenges and effective strategies at each level.
-
(2) Intervention studies testing the effectiveness of contextually tailored disaster nursing training programs in non–first-tier cities.
-
(3) Longitudinal studies exploring the long-term professional and psychological impacts of disaster response participation on nurses in resource-limited settings.
-
(4) Implementation research examining the feasibility and effectiveness of regional collaboration networks for disaster preparedness and response in non–first-tier cities.
-
(5) Mixed-methods studies investigating the relationship between psychological factors and disaster nursing performance in various contexts.
Conclusion
This qualitative study provides critical insights into the lived experiences and challenges of nurses involved in disaster response in non–first-tier Chinese cities, complementing our previous quantitative findings and contributing to a more comprehensive understanding of disaster nursing preparedness in resource-limited settings. The 5 major themes identified—Psychological Stress and Emotional Adaptation, Disaster Emergency Response Capacity and Management, Communication and Collaboration, Challenges in Disaster Nursing Capacity Development, and Impact of Disaster Relief Participation—highlight the complex interplay of individual, organizational, and systemic factors that influence disaster nursing capabilities in these contexts.
Our findings reveal that nurses in non–first-tier cities demonstrate remarkable resilience and commitment despite facing significant challenges, including psychological pressure, limited specialized training opportunities, resource constraints, and high workloads during disaster response. The self-regulation strategies and professional values that enable nurses to persevere under these challenging conditions represent important strengths that can be leveraged in disaster preparedness efforts. However, the absence of formal psychological support systems, gaps in disaster-specific skills and knowledge, communication challenges, and institutional barriers to disaster nursing development underscore the need for targeted interventions at multiple levels.
Based on these findings, we propose a multifaceted approach to enhancing disaster nursing capabilities in non–first-tier Chinese cities:
First, health care organizations should establish comprehensive psychological support mechanisms for nurses involved in disaster response, including predeployment preparation, on-site support, and postdeployment follow-up care. These systems should be adapted to the specific resources and constraints of non–first-tier hospitals and integrated into routine disaster preparedness planning.
Second, disaster nursing education and training programs should be contextually tailored to address the specific disaster risks, resource limitations, and learning needs of nurses in non–first-tier cities. This includes developing modules focused on locally relevant disaster types, realistic simulation exercises that account for resource constraints, and practical communication and teamwork training.
Third, health care administrators and policymakers should prioritize the development of clear, comprehensive disaster response frameworks that cover the entire disaster cycle and provide explicit guidance on roles, responsibilities, and coordination mechanisms. These frameworks should be adaptable to the specific contexts of non–first-tier hospitals while maintaining alignment with national and regional disaster management systems.
Fourth, innovative approaches to resource optimization and regional collaboration should be explored to address the resource constraints faced by non–first-tier cities. This might include establishing regional disaster nursing networks, resource-sharing agreements, and tiered response systems that maximize the efficiency of available resources.
Finally, greater attention should be paid to the long-term professional and personal impacts of disaster response participation on nurses, including both the potential for accelerated skill development and professional growth and the risk of psychological distress and burnout. Support systems that recognize and address these impacts are essential for sustaining a resilient disaster nursing workforce.
Figure 3 proposes a conceptual model for building disaster nursing capacity in non–first-tier Chinese cities, grounded in our study findings. By addressing these recommendations, health care organizations, educators, and policymakers can enhance disaster nursing capabilities in non–first-tier Chinese cities, ultimately improving disaster preparedness and response in these vulnerable yet vital health care settings. The insights gained from this study may also inform disaster nursing development in similar resource-limited contexts globally, contributing to more equitable and effective disaster health care systems worldwide.
Proposed model for disaster nursing capacity building in non–first-tier Chinese cities.

Data availability statement
The authors confirm that the data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article (and/or its supplementary materials).
Author contribution
XL: conceptualization and methodology. LS: data curation, writing—original draft preparation. LX: supervision, writing—reviewing, and editing. MW: visualization and investigation. LD: data curation and investigation.
Funding statement
This work was supported by the Key Disciplines Group Construction Project of Shanghai Pudong New Area Health Commission (PWZxq2022-10), the Key Discipline Construction Project of Shanghai East Hospital (2024-DFZD-003S), Xuguan Medical Research Special Fund Open Project (Grant No. 2024-XG-M07), the Three-Year Action Plan for Discipline Construction of School of Nursing at Tongji University (Grant No. JS2210320). Important Weak Subject Construction Project of Shanghai Pudong New Area Health Commission (Grant No. PWZbr2022-04), Outstanding Leaders Training Program of Pudong Health Bureau of Shanghai (Grant No. PWRl2022-01).
Competing interests
None.
