With her study of three generations of women in the California chapters of the Communist Party (USA), Beth Slutsky adds to the growing body of literature that examines the intersection between “old” left-wing radicalism and activism for women's rights. In recent years, work by Dayo F. Gore and Erik S. McDuffie has prompted a reevaluation of the ways that the Communist Party offered opportunities for African American women's radicalism, outside and parallel to the mainstream liberal civil rights movement. For Slutsky, the Communist Party was an often contradictory space for women to develop radical strategies and ideas in a world where both women and left-wing politics were marginalized. Drawing on an impressive range of primary source material from archives across California, she details the lives of three women who shaped the face of Communist activism from the first red scares of the early twentieth century through to the uneasy alliance between Communism, civil rights and the New Left. The activities of Charlotte Anita Whitney, Dorothy Ray Healey and Kendra Claire Harris Alexander represent major shifts in ways that American society viewed Communist radicalism, but more importantly Slutsky offers us in-depth biographical portraits of three women who were fighting for their own place in a society that sought, for various reasons, to exclude them. In this, Slutsky carefully creates a world where the public face of activism intertwines inevitably with the private lives of the activists.
The book is organized around these three biographical chapters, each progressing in chronological order. We first meet Anita Whitney, a socially elite leftist, whose prolonged legal battles, imprisonment and subsequent campaign for release forced the issue of free speech to the forefront of the party's platform in the heady days of the first red scare, and also provided opportunities for alliance with other radical and reformist organizations. By mid-century, after the party had aligned itself with the mainstream through the Popular Front era, postwar Stalinism caused many to reassess their allegiance to the CPUSA. Dorothy Ray Healey emerged as a leader of a new generation of activists devoted to labour organization and radical activism within an increasingly hostile domestic political situation. The third protagonist, and only woman of colour of the three, is Kendra Alexander, who simultaneously aligned herself with the party, the civil rights movement, and the black power movement, and would eventually head Angela Davis's defence team in 1972 when Davis faced charges of kidnapping, conspiracy and murder.
Across these biographical chapters, three common strands emerge: radicalism through the performance of imprisonment, the importance of the Communist Party in a larger network of radical organizations, and the ways that all three women deal with contradictory expectations around gender within the Party. For example, Whitney had developed a highly nuanced left-wing political persona by the late 1920s through her work with settlement houses, suffrage organizations, the Industrial Workers of the World and the Socialist Party. Yet the broad coalition of support she received in challenging her conviction (for violating the state Criminal Syndicalism Act) used her gender to claim that she was politically naive and so should not be imprisoned. Healey, a dyed-in-the-wool campaigner for labour rights, put her young son's welfare above her radical politics when his illness brought her out of her underground hiding. Hers, Slutsky tells us, was not an egalitarian marriage: there were certainly tensions between her radical activism and her traditional expectations of marriage. For Alexander, Communism offered a solution to the kinds of racial and gender inequality that had come to the fore with both the civil rights movement and the marginalization of women within that struggle. While the biographical approach gives us a detailed and incredibly rich understanding of each woman and her political environment, Slutsky could go further in teasing out the trends that their activism reveals. She nods every so often to points of continuity, but these are mostly timeline overlaps. Slutsky seeks to paint a picture of these women simultaneously as representative of something larger than themselves, but also as exceptional: without a more substantive discussion of their commonalities and differences, this dichotomy does not always work.
In many ways, Slutsky's generational approach echoes the concept of “waves” in the development of feminism. But it also challenges this idea that activism comes in waves: the timeline Slutsky offers us clearly demonstrates sustained radicalism from the 1910s until the 1980s, with overlapping campaigns and interconnected threads challenging the idea that there were peaks and troughs through the century. Importantly, the book challenges the traditional interpretations that the CPUSA was an outlier group in the landscape of the left, and that it essentially collapsed in the wake of McCarthyite investigations. Slutsky's immaculately researched book leaves us in no doubt that there was a vibrant continuum of left-wing radicalism in the Golden State.
