The book aims to understand the influence of policies at different levels – EU, national and workplace – on changing gender relations. Sevil Sümer draws on her experience teaching at the University of Bergen about the Scandinavian Welfare Model and Gender Relations, as a researcher on the EU Fifth Framework project ‘Transitions: Gender, Parenthood and the Changing European Workplace’ and as a new mother with origins and family in Turkey. These strands contribute to the interest of the book as a view from inside and outside the EU and its policies. While it draws on the Transitions research, the book aims primarily to meet the needs of students and teachers for an up-to-date textbook addressing debates about gender in comparative welfare, drawing together discussions of Esping-Andersen with feminist accounts, especially those of Ann Orloff, Diane Sainsbury, Jane Lewis, Pfau-Effinger, Mary Daly and Barbara Haas.
These debates are addressed in a chapter called ‘Comparing Gender Regimes: A Theoretical Framework’. The author gives a clear and systematic account of the positions adopted by Esping-Andersen and shows us the diversity and richness of work in this field. She is a little unlucky in timing, with new works by Esping-Andersen, Gornick and Meyers and Lewis appearing as she wrote. She acknowledges Gøsta Esping-Andersen's work in progress, but is unable to give a full account of The Incomplete Revolution: Adapting to Women's New Roles (Esping-Andersen Reference Esping-Andersen2009) or of Work-Family Balance, Gender and Policy (Lewis Reference Lewis2009), important new works by major European scholars, or Gornick and Meyers’ (Reference Gornick and Meyers2009) North American take on Gender Equality: Transforming Family Divisions of Labor. Here the book is most like the course textbook – of which the author (and others) felt the need – emphasising the diversity of perspectives more positively than developing her own approach.
The ‘Scandinavian Gender Regime: Myth or Reality’ is the subject of a second key chapter. There is little room for the Myth here: Sümer's perspective on the Scandinavian gender regimes of Norway, Sweden and Denmark shows welfare and gender policies supporting gender equality. Detailed national differences are acknowledged, but the broad picture is of state social welfare supporting gender equality in practice and in ideology: a system protecting women and families more successfully than the ‘familist’ regimes of Southern Europe or the individualist ones of the UK and USA. Norway is emphasised here, with its annual first place in the UN Gender Empowerment Measure making front page news, and national pride in being the best place for women to live. Acknowledging the deeply divided labour market, with women in welfare state jobs, the author argues the progress of Scandinavian women in education and politics, and the success of policies supporting families. Changing the division of labour in households has happened more slowly than bringing women into public life, but parental leave policies are enabling men to care, and changing men's perceptions about care.
‘Gender Policies in the European Union’ asks about the nature and extent of gender equality policies in the EU's social agenda. Sümer's historial account argues the deep roots of gender in the EU's social policy, while recognising the limits of policy implementation. Her account of varied voices among feminist responses to the EU emphasises the positive interpretations of the EU's possibilities, while acknowledging the sceptics who argue that gender equality policies in the EU tend to come second (or third) to economic and employment policies.
‘Work–Family Reconciliation in Practice’ offers an account of the ‘Transitions’ study of the implementation of gender policies, again highlighting Norway, compared with Portugal and the UK, representing different gender regimes. The Transitions project asked about national policies, workplaces and parents, to understand the transition to motherhood and fatherhood. The chapter offers qualitative data from these different policy and cultural contexts. Sümer argues that Norwegian parents of young children showed a strong sense of their entitlements, whereas UK parents were ill informed, and Portugese ones were often forced to sacrifice their rights because of work pressures. The case study material offers an unusual component for a textbook, and one that enhances the overall project of understanding changing gender relations in different contexts.
It is a difficult task to draw these strands together. A concluding chapter ‘Towards a European Gender Regime?’ argues that Scandinavian strategies of turning private issues into public ones have offered Europe a good example. Sümer also argues the need to target fathers, to follow Norway's example of parental leave, challenging traditional masculinity, expectations of fathers in paid work and the domestic division of unpaid work, especially childcare.
Each chapter addresses important questions in a thoughtful way. Students and teachers have a need for such a book, and it will make a useful contribution to reading lists. I especially liked its diverse sources, which are a source of strength and interest. They could perhaps be woven into a more coherent whole. It is not clear whether there will be a paperback, though an e-version is advertised. This is not the only book students will need about gender and welfare states, and they may be more willing to do so at paperback price.
