This is a fascinating exploration of the sensory experiences within the houses of Pompeii and Herculaneum. The book functions as an extended case study weaving together approaches found in shorter articles in recent edited collections on the senses in antiquity, such as E. Betts (ed.), Senses of the Empire (2017) and M. Bradley (ed.), Smell and the Ancient Senses (2015). Such articles tend to be subdivided by type of sense and type of context. Instead, Hannah Platts creates a rich multisensory (domestic) world, observing and emphasising obvious and yet overlooked aspects of ancient life.
Chs 1 and 2 set the scene. The book ‘explores the diverse corporeal responses (including smell, touch, sound, taste and sight) to be had within the Roman house’ (3). P.'s review of scholarship on the Roman house reveals that the focus has been almost exclusively on issues of visual access (especially various flavours of access analysis). Thus, her holistic approach is a welcome change. P. considers the extent to which sensory experiences ‘affect perception of a home and how far and for what reasons were multisensory experiences open to manipulation by house owners?’ (4). She contends that Roman house owners were aware of the importance of crafting a multisensory experience to influence their own and their visitors’ impressions and comfort.
Ch. 3 uses Seneca's amusing complaint about the sounds and smells from the nearby bathhouse to begin an exploration of the relationship between streetscapes and house interiors. P. explains the science of how smells dissipate in air and how sound travels; this ensures a useful technical baseline for her reading audience. P. conjures birds tweeting, dogs barking, the voices of passers-by, the sonance of weather and the din from the amphitheatre, complete with a discussion of decibel levels and sensitivity to topography and seasonality (e.g. the effects of temperature on the spread of smell and sound).
Chs 4 and 5 consider the experiences of someone in the atrium/tablinum and the cubiculum, respectively, with reference to a survey by P. of doors and other room-dividers which separate the street from the house and one interior room from another. Attention is devoted to how much the owner of a house was able to control the sensory experiences of his visitors. P. is interested, again, in moving beyond visual analysis to include sounds and smells. While the discussion overall is suggestive, there is not enough acknowledgement that different types of room separators have varying efficacy as sensory barriers — curtains, screens, or partitions obstruct a view, but allow the passage of smells and sounds, while a full door on hinges successfully blocks all three.
Chs 6 and 7 examine the experiences associated with food: in the triclinium, and within and between the kitchen/latrine and the rest of the house. Colourful literary references to food and hosting (Nasidienus, Trimalchio, Zoilus) as well as the rarely referenced Colloquia of the Hermeneumata Pseudodositheana set the scene. P.'s archaeological data reflects her survey of the arrangement of rooms and location of room dividers from a sample of houses. This allows a number of observations, including the fact that larger houses placed the kitchen and dining areas at a greater distance, suggesting the desirability of concealing kitchen activities from guests. P.'s attention to the multisensory experiences of slaves, not just host and guests, rounds out these two rich chapters.
It is at this end of the book that P. explores the possibilities of sensory habituation, that is, an ancient person may become used to the smells or sounds around them (some of which may have been unpleasant). Thus even noxious odours could have been relatively benign or indeed almost indiscernible. The issue of habituation might have been better addressed at the outset of the book and thus included or dismissed, as needed, within each chapter's focus. I also wondered how the inclusion of ethnographic information may have further enriched or nuanced the analysis (e.g. when Romans had dead bodies decomposing in the atrium, how might that compare with the experiences of modern/recent societies who keep the recently dead close by?).
A final consideration is that of scope: the textual references are quite disparate in chronology and geography (including both Plautus and Apuleius), whereas the material evidence comes almost entirely from first-century Pompeii and Herculaneum. Nods to Rome or other sites are few. Although the limits of this dataset are mentioned in the first chapter, the challenges of generalising from this time and place to all Romans warrants further discussion. There are perhaps two different audiences for this book: first, the classicist looking to learn about multisensory studies; second, the Roman archaeologist looking to explore the house in a new way. The former might appreciate the detailed background on debates about the Roman house (i.e. public vs private). The latter would probably have preferred additional multisensory interpretations. So much has been written on the urban and domestic world of Pompeii that one wishes P. assumed a greater degree of prior knowledge on the part of the reader and expended less time on previous studies. But it may well be impossible to please both audiences. These criticisms do not detract, however, from the innovations of specific chapters, nor from the project as a whole. Using this book as a model, it would be interesting to see someone take a similar approach to other Greco-Roman contexts in a book-length study, for example a multisensory approach to temples or sanctuaries.
