Borrowing a term and a concept from William Least Heat-Moon's epic examination of and rumination on the empty-seeming Chase County, Kansas – PrairyErth (a deep map) – Susan Naramore Maher seeks to establish that the “deep map” is an emerging genre that is increasingly central to the contemporary nonfiction writing of the Great Plains of the United States and Canada, both as a mode of literary practice and (ideally) as a means of engendering a kind of cultural and environmental rejuvenation in this flat and lightly populated part of North America. The reader soon discovers, though, that it's difficult to pin down exactly what a “deep map” is; indeed, Maher admits herself that “the deep map resists any master paradigm” (23). The closest she comes to an abstract definition may be when she says that “the deep map presents the multiple histories of place, the cross-sectional stories of natural and human history as traced through eons and generations” (10), or perhaps when she asserts that what deep maps share “is a desire to delve below the surface and the present, to challenge mythic renderings of place, and to destabilize established or dominant viewpoints” (23). If these are some of the deep map's distinguishing features, in practice writers can execute them in a wide variety of ways, as the authors whose work she examines demonstrate. Maher works not from definition to analysis, but from analysis to definition: in a somewhat circular way, her implicit assertion seems to be that deep maps, basically, are what deep-mapping writers produce. You know them when you see them.
This approach ends up working to her advantage, as it emerges from Maher's discussion that deep mapping is primarily a sensibility more than a technique or method, a way of seeing more than a strategy or a school; as Maher herself puts it at one point, “Deep mapping is an aesthetic and an ethos” (23). To be sure, Maher does attempt to group her deep mappers into thematic chapters to further signal her sense of deep mapping's central points of concern: in “Deep Mapping History” she discusses Wallace Stegner and Least Heat-Moon; in “Deep Mapping the Biome,” the scientist–essayists Don Gayton, John Janovy Jr., and Wes Jackson; in “Deep Mapping Dimensions” (of time and space), Loren Eiseley and John McPhee; and in “Deep Mapping Lived Space,” the memoirists Julene Bair, Sharon Butala, and Linda Hasselstrom. Given the breadth and heterogeneity of deep mapping, however, any of these writers could probably have been put into a different chapter or into a set of alternative chapters entirely, and in this polymorphous context it does seem odd that Maher grouped her only three women authors in the chapter having to do with ideas of home and domesticity, a conventional cultural assignment to be sure. After all, in Maher's discussion, deep mapping has to do with many things at once: with stretches of history ranging from individual lifetimes to geologic eons; with the intersection of personal, regional, and national stories; with the complexity of natural life on the Plains and its interpenetration with human occupation; with indigenous populations being pushed aside by white settlement; with boom and bust, gain and loss; with science and spirituality; with anything and everything that a writer discovers within the time and space of a particular patch of the Plains pursued as deeply as that writer can take it. There may be many deep mappers on the Great Plains, but, as with cartography in general, no two mappers are going to represent that landscape in the same way. As Maher notes, “History and maps are never finished, never completed, always approximate” (56).
While Maher does not concern herself greatly with definition and strict categorization, then, to do so would violate the spirit of the very writing that she examines. While perhaps not intentionally, Maher is herself writing a deep map of the deep map “genre.” She approaches the books and authors that she studies as her own personal scholarly Great Plains and, like any one of those authors, focusses on unique particularities as well as broader connections; she writes associatively instead of linearly, comes to no final answers, and presents us in the end not with the understanding of Great Plains literary nonfiction, but with what is emphatically Maher's understanding of that nonfiction – and that's a good thing. If deep mapping is a sensibility more than anything else, Maher does an excellent job of taking that sensibility off the pages of others and using it to shape her own.
