Iranian cinema produced after the 1979 Iranian Revolution captured the interest and imagination of cinephiles and scholars around the world. Featured heavily on the international film festival circuit, Iranian cinema became synonymous with the art cinema aesthetics of filmmakers such as Abbas Kiarostami and Bahram Beyzai, while the feminist films of Tahmineh Milani and Rakhshan Bani-Etemad were read as astute indictments of the Iranian government. The study of post-revolutionary Iranian cinema has been shaped in part by the international response to these films, which by and large understands them as art produced in spite of or within the limits of state censorship. Blake Atwood's Reform Cinema in Iran enters a scholarly landscape that bears the traces of this response. Despite notable attempts to rethink the language of Iranian cinema – Negar Mottahedeh's Displaced Allegories: Post-Revolutionary Iranian Cinema (Duke, 2008) is a prominent example – the field has been somewhat limited by these readings. Breaking new ground, Atwood asks how we can expand our understanding of contemporary Iranian cinema by moving beyond the totalizing category of “post-revolutionary” (4). This question arises, almost consequentially, in the context of a scholarly landscape for which “1979” has consistently served as a point of rupture that delineates how we understand Iranian cinema. Whereas previous studies of cinema made in the Islamic Republic of Iran emphasize how filmmakers work with and beyond the limitations of censorship, Atwood is more interested in the mutually collaborative relationship between cinema and politics. No period provides a more fitting case study than the years in which former President Mohammad Khatami brought “reform” to national politics and to Iran's state-sponsored cinema.
Atwood's concept of “reform cinema” examines how such a category emerges in a historical moment when discourses of reform were influential on both the political landscape and on Iranian cinema. He argues that there is an intimate relationship between the reform movement and the film industry, and that it has been obscured by both popular and academic discourses that privilege the cultural effects of the Islamic Revolution (14). As Atwood demonstrates, the relationship between cinema and politics during the reform period is complex, operating in often surprising ways. Atwood's argument is aimed in part at rethinking the very definition of political cinema in Iran. Although most of the scholarly discourse links political cinema in Iran to the ideology of the Islamic regime in the immediate years after the Revolution and to the influence of radical film movements such as Latin America's “Third Cinema,” Atwood suggests reform cinema demonstrates that political cinema's collaboration with mainstream political movements is one of its defining qualities. This particular notion of political cinema also calls into question the legacy of the Iranian Revolution's infamously mired position on cinema as a technology of Western imperialism. The argument implies that while the country's discourse of political reform transformed political ideology to a much more conservative form, the same might be said of its political cinema, which in this period did not operate solely as a mode of resistance to the mainstream (11).
In his examination of reform cinema, Atwood draws from political speeches, campaign films, newspaper reports, film reviews, and essays, as well as reading the aesthetics of films. Reading, for example, the use of sound in Rakhshan Bani-Etemad's Under the Skin of the City (2001) allows him to argue for the manner in which reform cinema articulated its position in relation to the discourses with which it was so intimately entwined. The analysis of film aesthetics alongside the discourse of reform in Iran allows Atwood to move past some of the key paradigms through which non-Western cinemas have been read in the context of film studies. It also offers non-specialists a more nuanced understanding of the relationship between cinema and the state in Iran. This methodology positions the monograph well in both film studies and Iranian studies.
Reform Cinema in Iran departs from existing studies of Iranian cinema by bringing together analyses of the celebrated art cinema alongside a chapter on the popular cinema that is less known outside Iran. In a chapter titled, “Who Killed the Tough Guy? Continuity and Rupture in the Filmfārsi Tradition,” Atwood examines how the relationship between the film industry and the reform movement served to transform popular genres such as film farsi, a commercial film movement that began in the mid-twentieth-century and consisted primarily of melodrama and gangster movies. The scope of Reform Cinema also extends to an analysis of the changes brought by digital technology to Iranian film culture, as well as a chapter on reformist aesthetics beyond the period associated with Khatami and political reform. Finally, the book's conclusion takes the reader on a walk through the Cinema Museum in Tehran. Here, Atwood practices a critical geography that culminates with a meditation on censored filmmaker Jafar Panahi and the status of political filmmaking in Iran. The diversity of these chapters is promising for students of Iranian cinema, as the book offers in-depth analyses of contemporary films using a theoretical approach that is novel in the field.
Reform Cinema offers an important new paradigm for thinking through aesthetics, the film industry, and the state in Iran.
