Since the publication of Michael Fried's “Art and Objecthood” in 1967, the philosophical status of modernist theatre has been the object of scholarly and critical attention. Though Fried's puritanical position has been largely discredited, the issue—that theatre as an art form and theatricality as a broader cultural tendency are both deeply problematic in terms of modernist ideology—has retained its critical heat, if one takes as evidence Jonas Barish's monumental The Antitheatrical Prejudice in 1981 and, over the next two decades, the rise of French poststructuralist theory, with its many references to Antonin Artaud and Samuel Beckett, and the ubiquity of Guy Debord's notion of the “society of spectacle.” Alan Ackerman and Martin Puchner, editors of Against Theatre: Creative Destructions on the Modernist Stage (the inaugural publication of Palgrave Macmillan's “Performance Interventions” series), further this discussion with a collection of essays that investigate antitheatricality in a range of modernist works.
Readers may recall the 2001 issue of Modern Drama edited by Ackerman and Puchner. Five of these essays were published there, including the introduction. That issue showed a surprising range of subject. Kirk Williams explored naturalism's contradictory attitudes toward metaphor and, by extension, theatrical representation itself; Herbert Lindenberger traced antitheatrical themes in several twentieth-century operas; Rebecca Walkowitz contrasted two versions of Joseph Conrad's The Secret Agent, the masterful novel and the awful stage adaptation; and Elinor Fuchs compared metatheatrical techniques in plays by Genet, Müller, Handke, and Parks. This strength is amplified in the anthology, which includes eight previously unpublished essays. Organized in three parts—“Frames,” “Materials,” and “Values”—the essays examine diverse issues, genres, and moments. Arnold Aronson's recent work on scenography is sampled, as is Elin Diamond's fascinating, potentially paradigm-shifting work on Zora Neale Hurston. Charlie Keil traces antitheatrical tendencies in modernist film, Patrick McGuinness in the work of Mallarmé and Maeterlinck, and Marjorie Perloff in several pieces by John Cage. More directly theoretical approaches are found in Part III, “Values,” which includes Walkowitz's piece on Conrad, David Savran's description of Gilbert Seldes's efforts to legitimize “serious drama” in the 1920s, Herbert Blau's ruminations on the philosophical and practical paradoxes of “seeming,” and Julie Stone Peters's fascinating essay on censorship.
The diversity of subject matter and approach puts “theatre,” a notoriously slippery term, under all kinds of pressures, but this is the intention. For the contributors, “theatre is understood sometimes as a medium, sometimes as trope or idea, but always as a crucial configuration of relationships between ‘actors’ and ‘audiences’ that cannot be taken for granted and is subject to question from a variety of perspectives, including aesthetic, political, legal, and technical ones” (1). Counterbalancing this, the contributors generally emphasize concrete dimensions of theatre. The collection as a whole demonstrates not only that the theatrical arts are fundamental to aesthetic modernity, but also that theatre historical research is fundamental to any assessment of theatre's modernity. The premise here is that
[W]e can no longer isolate different attacks on the theatre and hold them up as examples of an ingrained prejudice. Instead, we must ask which particular understandings of the theatre stand behind the various forms of anti-theatricalism, what draws them to the theatre that they would bother to attack it so vehemently, what values motivate these attacks, and from what position or discipline are they launched. (12)
I find this position to be both theoretically and historiographically on the mark.
The anthology gestures toward a rethinking of theatrical modernism itself. Ackerman and Puchner define modernism as “an insistence on authenticity that can ultimately only uncover its own artifice,” as a “heightened aesthetic self-reflexivity or attention within art to its artness, its media and, especially in theatre, to the constituting role of the audience,” and “an emphasis on pluralism or multiplicity that is both internal and external to art” (4). There is a methodological implication to this definition; most of the essays emphasize an “oscillation between the concrete detail of realism and a poetics of abstraction” (5), not only in the works they examine, but also in their approach to those works. This desire to generate broader conclusions occasionally leads to overreach, as in McGuinness's article on symbolism, which reduces one of the more complex movements in modern theatre to a few works by Mallarmé and Maeterlinck, and Williams's piece on naturalism, which reaches its conclusions based on only two German plays. But generally, I find the balance between the specific and the general to be salutary.
Less salutary is the anthology's uncommented and fairly breathtaking Eurocentrism. Modernist studies has been revolutionized by regional studies, postcolonial theory, and other approaches that proffer the notion of “differential modernities.” One finds here discussion neither of non-Western manifestations of modernist antitheatricality nor of the kinds of transnational dialogues that shaped the European critique. In terms of the former, one thinks of antiapartheid theatre in South Africa, driven to antitheatricality both by a lack of resources and a recognition that racism is fundamentally about appearance. Discussion of censorship and modernist art could only benefit by reference to artists working under authoritarian regimes in Latin America or Southeast Asia. Discussion of Buddhism or Taoism would seem germane—if not fundamental—to any essay on Cage. And what of the influence of Hindu and Celtic cosmology—Buddhism, too—on the symbolist movement? But one can't have everything, and teachers and students can gain much from mapping the insights and methods of these essays against modernist theatre in Kuala Lumpur, Sidney, Toronto, Buenos Aires, and other sites where the politics of seeing and being seen are both hot topics and weighty historical legacies.
But, I've got to admit, every time I found my anti-Eurocentric hackles rising (feminist and queer ones, too), I read another essay and found myself engaged, educated, and entertained. The finely sifted understanding of theatricality and its many nuanced opponents that emerges in this collection is a welcome, timely, and smart contribution to the debate. It reminds me how much I have to learn about modernist theatre, particularly its European tendencies.
