Joseph Roach's latest book, It, takes readers on a vertiginous quest for the ineffable stuff of stardom—for “it”—a term that he characterizes as “a pronoun aspiring to the condition of a noun” (1). Surprisingly, “It is a very large subject” (3). Roach gleans his inspiration for this capacious topic from a somewhat obscure “Hollywood tastemaker” named Elinor Glyn (1864–1943). It was she who began to theorize the term and was responsible for giving actress Clara Bow the moniker: the “it” girl. One of this book's many achievements is its revival of Glyn for theatre history. In addition, Roach's study helps us to understand key terms in the field such as “charisma,” “beauty,” “charm,” “magic” and “aura.” From Quintilian to the funeral effigy of the fifteenth-century Katherine of Valois to quixotic modern avatars such as Madonna and Michael Jackson, Roach guides us through a dizzying and dazzling array of artifacts: role-icons such as pirates and the piratophiles that study them, Maggie Thatcher's Hogarthian hair, paintings of Buckingham by Augustus Egg, portraits of Sarah Siddons, Shakespearean tragedies, photographs of Princess Diana, the effigies of kings, Barbie dolls, Pepys's diary, periwigs, waxworks, and The Beggar's Opera to name only a few. Although marketed as “Performing Arts/Cultural Studies,” It is, in fact, composed of etymology, theatre history, economic theory, visual studies, anthropology, psychology, and cultural criticism. It draws upon Roach's vast archive of ideas about acting, flesh, bone, and the insistent persistence of theatre as both tenor and vehicle of life. The book does not merely bear Roach's trademark style: it exemplifies it.
It has six chapters, each of which is titled with a noun. They are, in order of appearance: Accessories, Clothes, Hair, Skin, Flesh, and Bone. These words suggest an archeological model, an ‘order of things,’ that moves us from surface to depth; however, the actual material discussed in each of the peripatetic chapters belies such strict linearity. They give us, over and over again, convoluted, complicated critical genealogies that stress that continuity and difference are coconspirators.
In the brilliant introductory chapter, Roach calls the theatre “the most consequential synthetic experience” (28). Fundamentally, Roach is consumed with our desire to “experience experience (by vicariously living through someone else's embodiment of it)” (29). Finding ‘essences’ in hat, shades and attitude, Roach explains the doubled bodies inhabited by kings and actors—the natural bodies that die and the bodies that live by unnatural means—“preserved on celluloid, on digitized files, or in the memory of the theatergoing public as an afterimage” (36). Again, this ripe (pun intended) theory teaches us to rethink dead metaphors, invigorating them with new meaning and new life.
In Chapter 1, “Accessories,” Roach has much to say about the excess superfluity of the accessory which is read in relation to the trope of synecdoche. This ingenious chapter continues Roach's (and indeed our own) obsessions with and investments in the vestiges of life that remain in seemingly insignificant remainders, such as accessories, that Roach (re)imagines as vestments. Specifically, he focuses on the first celebrity, Charles II, who was idolized by the Victorians years after his reign. Later in the book, Roach suggests that “Public intimacy may seem to be a purely modern and secular idea, but it is in fact rooted in traditional religious doctrine and, more deeply and lastingly, in popular religious feeling… . As an instance of temporal ‘percolation’ rather than ‘flow,’ reenchantment has doctrinally orthodox beginnings but no end in sight” (16). This suggests that Roach's take on the ‘long eighteenth century’ (1688–1832) is long indeed: in fact, he claims, not at all cheekily, “it isn't over yet” (44). Here, Roach extends his previous work on the echoes in the bone that define performance as well as on the afterlife of images. Finally, he believes that “the It-Effect” is something that “recycles its idols widely and markets them relentlessly” (201).
Roach, among our perspicacious scholars, here illuminates that thing—or more precisely, those things—that have attracted and continue to attract us. For example, he returns throughout the book to the conundrum of the lifelike funeral effigy—“more colorful than a death mask, yet more faithful than a portrait” (47). The sweep of Roach's study compels us—seemingly without effort—to major insights about human behavior. The book delivers more than mere bon mots: it brings us pleasure and profundity and performance. It is itself a sexy, star-studded study.
