The book's subtitle, Per’un Archeologia dell’Architettura, reflects Demma's methodology: archaeological remains are combined with epigraphic and literary testimony to enable an understanding of Puteoli's principal surviving concezioni spaziali as both architectural and functional entities, considering their form, decoration, and evolution over time.
In the first part of the book D. surveys several important buildings of the town in chapters by monument or monumental group. The chronological range of this study is from the late first to the third centuries a.d.; the earlier periods in Puteoli's existence are the subject of ongoing excavations. At the level of individual monuments this approach works well. The book confines itself to a study of individual monuments rather than a synoptic study of the architecture of Puteoli, still less of the development of Puteoli itself, so D.'s structure means that the individual trees are somewhat more conspicuous than the wood.
The best-preserved of the buildings studied by D. is the well-known Flavian amphitheatre; there are also chapters on the partially-submerged Macellum (the so-called Temple of Serapis), the sacred buildings (of which only one is now visible, the rest being studied through architectonic fragments and archival material), and the surviving fragments of the forum buildings. Each chapter is further subdivided to give a bibliography and epigraphic and literary sources where possible, and an overview of the site's excavation history, together with a discussion of the materials, construction, and decoration of the building(s) in question. D.'s approach is therefore complementary to pre-existing studies of individual buildings, acknowledging and in some cases extending or correcting them; the difficult circumstances of the Macellum, for example, mean that D.'s overview of its construction techniques is the first. Anyone interested in these buildings will find D.'s survey a useful resource.
Interesting historical conclusions can be drawn from some of this material, such as the involvement both of central imperial authorities (in the provision of materials, for example) at the same time as local workshops and patrons, including (especially in ch. 3) the participation of the wealthy freedmen in which Puteoli abounded.
The second part of the book, chs 5–7, consists in a study of the town's vast store of architectural fragments, uncovered in excavations since the Bourbon era and still accumulating. As the excavation of Puteoli progresses, the publication of a catalogue of architectonic fragments is to be welcomed. The typological study of architectonic fragments in recent years has produced specialized studies of small categories of ornament; D., however, seeks to survey a wide range of fragments in this study and, by giving what he calls a descriptive typological (morphological) and a stylistic (phenomenological) analysis, to avoid the perceived polarization between chronological and semantic methodologies in architectonic typologies. To this end he takes account of context where it is known (which is by no means always) and considers the entire ornamental repertoire of pieces to try to date them, avoiding an overly narrow focus on sub-classes of ornament studied in isolation from each other. Ch. 5 presents the typological analysis, and ch. 6 this broader contextualized approach, which considers the matter of marbles and workshops. Ch. 7 is the partially-illustrated catalogue of nearly 500 items, to which the text of the previous chapters refers and which in itself represents a significant amount of archival work. A brief conclusion follows.
D. sets out to write an archaeological/architectural work including a catalogue, rather than an historical study (he refers readers in search of one to the appropriate works by Zevi et al.). One consequence is that the reader must turn to the short conclusion to see how D. fits his subject matter into the wider story of the history, development, and function of Puteoli. For many, this will be the best place to start: here D. offers some interesting glimpses of the connection between imperial interventions and local social change and the town's architecture and civic spaces, beginning under Nero and continuing with restorations and additions in later reigns. Given D.'s insistence on the importance of cultural and historical context to the study of the monuments, a fuller treatment of this aspect or an introductory chapter locating the monuments and fragments within the wider history of the town, or of comparable towns in Roman Italy, would have added much to the book for a general reader. It would also have been good to see a plan of the Roman town, however incomplete, with the monuments discussed here placed in their contexts (there is one fold-out archaeological map, with the remains marked onto the modern street plan of the town of Pozzuoli).
As it is, the specialist interested specifically in Puteoli or in the methodology of architectonic analysis will find much of interest here; the student of the broader history of Roman urbanism will have to hunt thoroughly among D.'s chapters, but will find interesting material to justify the search.
The book is illustrated with photographs and reproductions of old excavation documents; these are all in black and white only, many without scale markers, and some rather grainy. For the astonishingly high price of €300, however, one is entitled to expect a more lavish presentation; this paperback volume of 362 pages is not particularly robust or elegant — the review copy is already showing damage at one corner — and unfortunately represents very questionable value for money.
