The escalation of urban violence and crime in Brazil over the past 30 years is very much connected to drug trafficking, the illegal arms trade and, more recently, the territorial control imposed by criminal groups in certain neighbourhoods. There is no doubt that in this scenario, men are both the main victims and the perpetrators: the highest homicide rates are concentrated among young, poor black men living in the favelas or morros of the Brazilian urban centres. As a result, although it is wildly recognised that women play a fundamental role when it comes to communitarian life, they emerge as secondary actors when the phenomena of urban criminality is considered and analysed.
Challenging this perspective, Robert Gay chooses to approach the drug trafficking business and how its growing development is shaping the lives of the favela inhabitants of Brazil from a less usual point of view. In his book, the reader is carried trough a series of interviews conducted between 1999 and 2002 that recount the life of Lucia, a female inhabitant of a favela in Rio de Janeiro – the second-largest Brazilian city, where an important part of the organised crime groups is concentrated, and a city that holds some of the highest homicide rates in the country. The interviews bring out a narrative that could be described as a personal saga, wherein Lucia, while looking back on her life and memories, reflects on her trajectory: her intermittent and at the same time multiple connections with the drug trafficking business, the difficulties at many levels faced by her family and friends, and her intent to change life. The result is a sensitive, dense and extended picture of Brazilian society.
As we get to know Lucia, it is impossible not to remember Sidney Mintz's classic study of rural workers in Puerto Rico. His access to Puerto Rican society was gained exclusively through the life story of one of these workers: Don Taso. Mintz assumed that telling Taso's story would be equivalent, at some level, to telling the stories of people like Taso. Like Mintz, at the same time that Gay offers an in-depth portrait of an individual trajectory, he refers to the story of Lucia in order to suggest some hypotheses about Brazilian society, showing how urban violence has been configured over the past decade and describing how its incorporation in daily life has been changing patterns of sociability, with severe consequences. As a result, we learn about police corruption, the failure of the education system, the wars between controlled shanty towns, and the brutal prison system, among other themes. The interesting aspect resides in the fact that Lucia is not only a ‘drug dealer's woman’, she is also a mother, a daughter of a communitarian religious leader, a person who is trying to find a job or a profession with some dignity, and a young woman who wants to enjoy life by going out and buying new clothes and jewellery. In this sense, her multiple social roles and aspirations are able to connect all these subjects that allow a diverse understanding of the presence of crime in this area. Her relationship with drug trafficking, however, seems to be a common denominator to all that and, moreover, a trap from which she cannot escape. Although the book concentrates on the subjects of crime and urban violence, its content goes beyond these thematic arenas and into such areas as class relations, racial issues and even the weakness of the Brazilian social welfare state.
The structure of the book allows for each interview to be followed by a short analytical review of the related topic. The conciseness of these reviews, which include subjects such as ‘family’, ‘education’, ‘economy’ and ‘religion’ – each one a possible book in itself – is compensated for by their diversity. These sections are useful for framing Lucia's concerns and might also serve as a reference in terms of both content and bibliographic sources. The portrait that is built up by Gay also points to other possibilities regarding the involvement of women with crime. Data from the Brazilian National Penitentiary Department shows that while the national incarceration rate among men increased 4 per cent between 2007 and 2008, the increase among women was 12 per cent. Just as elsewhere in Latin America, most of these woman were convicted for drug trafficking. In many cases they were arrested for transporting drugs or other forbidden merchandise to their imprisoned partners. In other words, their involvement with crime is immediately related to their personal involvement with criminals.
Regarding research methodology, the book also brings a relevant contribution. The fact that Gay has known Lucia and her family for a long time gives him permission and knowledge to address delicate subjects. On the other hand, he has a connection with Lucia and her family that is no longer exclusively related to his researcher position and the impact of this can be perceived from the way the book's argument is built. Throughout the consecutive interviews, the author inevitably circumscribes the subject that he wants to address by the questions that he poses. Lucia reacts, choosing what she wants to answer and to where she wants to drive the conversation. These dynamics express the relationship between interviewer and interviewed but also between friends, and make the book an inspiring source for a reflection on ethnography and its possibilities and limits.
Lucia can almost be read as a novel, in which the reader anxiously wants to know the outcome of Lucia's trajectory and shares the author's declared hope that she manages to change her life. As a result, it is inevitable that the reader ends by partaking in the melancholy expressed by Gay as the book reaches its conclusion.
