The past few decades have been a time of renewed interest in both qualitative and quantitative study of the Roman economy, and yet ancient economic historians have had surprisingly little to say about capital. Although the Oxford Classical Dictionary now includes entries on ‘credit’, ‘inflation’, ‘prices’ and ‘monopolies’, for example, one cannot find an entry on ‘capital’ — a major factor of pre-industrial production alongside land and labour. This volume, edited by Paul Erdkamp, Koenraad Verboven and Arjan Zuiderhoek, provides a much-needed intervention — giving readers not only a vibrant and well-informed methodological discussion, but also a series of case-studies which illuminate the rich complexity as well as the contextual constraints on capital in the Roman world.
The editors outline an ambitious study of ‘all material resources such as tools, workshops and factories, warehouses, and so on, that are needed or used to realize production’ (5). This broad definition of capital does not explicitly mention ‘human capital’ (especially slaves), but hints elsewhere in the introduction and the fact that skilled labour and slavery are discussed in several contributions belie an expansive view of the capital structure in the Roman world. Norman Underwood's chapter, for example, considers the transfer of human capital into the church from the fourth century a.d. onwards. Relying heavily on legal texts and literary sources, Underwood argues that church leaders brought many of the empire's professionals — educators, physicians, architects, etc. — into permanent positions in the church. In so doing, the church gained access to a vast pool of skills and talents, resulting in a fundamental shift in the control of skilled human capital by the mid sixth century a.d.
A major theme in the collection is innovation — with several chapters discussing technology and techniques as key aspects of capital. The volume's only chapter on the Archaic period, for example, portrays Rome and the cities in its vicinity as part of a society of growing social and economic stratification bolstered by innovations in agricultural processes (such as intensive farming) and urbanisation. Using a combination of evidence from burials, pottery and the retrospective observations in later Roman literary sources, Christiano Viglietti argues that the cities of archaic Latium were not only receptive to new techniques and practices — whether these were imported from outside the region or represent local adaptations — but that Rome and its neighbours embraced the demographic and cultural consequences of increasing economic surpluses. But not all innovations brought significant economic advantages, as Tamara Lewit's synthetic survey of press technology illustrates. In one of the volume's most innovative contributions, Lewit traces the diversification, if not quirkiness, of press technologies, undermining the idea that the seemingly more efficient screw technology quickly replaced existing press technologies. Screws did make for more reliable and safe presses, but Lewit, through detailed explanations and diagrams of the press process, shows that these devices probably did not generate much more output than traditional presses. According to Andrew Wilson, however, some technologies did spread rapidly through the Roman world. Wilson, who has studied water-powered devices for much of his career, believes that the High Roman Empire, and not Late Antiquity as other scholars suspect, represents the peak in the use of such devices. In support of his case, Wilson points to the roughly 230 confirmed sites where archaeologists have discovered at least one (but some cases several) large centrally driven millstones. People in various parts of the Roman world used water power in a range of applications, from milling grain to crushing ore. Wilson claims that the wealth required for investment in water mills was ‘within reach of many landowners’ — a notable outlier in a volume in which most contributors see capital as securely controlled by local or imperial elites. Hopefully, Wilson will expand upon and perhaps attempt to quantify this point in a future study.
Contributions draw on a mixture of qualitative and quantitative approaches. A fine example is the chapter by Wim Broekaert and Zuiderhoek — an expansive survey of the control of capital across agriculture, maritime trade and urban production. Although the authors study each area very differently — in part due to the different types of source material available — they tend to come to similar conclusions in each case: elites predominantly controlled capital goods. In considering the costs of shipping and ship-building, for example, the authors use existing quantitative estimates of shipping costs, ship sizes, crew sizes and operating costs to show that the financial barriers to entry into maritime shipping markets were high compared to later periods. There were still ways for non-elites to involve themselves in shipping — by pooling resources, for example, or even building small ships by drawing upon basic carpentry skills — but the high costs associated with owning and operating large ships ensured elite dominance of the capital structure. For agriculture and urban workshops, the story appears to be much the same. The accounts of agronomists — especially Cato and Columella — hint at elite ownership and control of vast amounts of land. Elites also provided and subsequently benefitted from the technologies and tools used to improve the land's productivity. Even owning or operating urban workshops, the authors argue, required access to wealthy patrons, inheritance or large lines of credit — limiting the scope for a financially independent class of small business owners.
Credit, both in kind and cash, is another major area of focus. Verboven's chapter on capital markets echoes and augments aspects of his first book, The Economy of Friends. Economic Aspects of Amicitia and Patronage in the Late Republic (2002), now twenty years old. He shows that Roman capital markets were limited by the volume of metal currency, and also the highly personal nature of the lending market. Loans were provided primarily through social networks. Verboven also provides a valuable intervention on fractional reserve banking, noting that it was practised by deposit bankers in the Hellenistic World. We can reasonably assume that argentarii and nummularii loaned out a portion of the money they took in as deposits, keeping the rest in reserve. Verboven argues convincingly that while the Roman banking system was not ‘modern’, it was nevertheless sophisticated. Verboven's discussion of the need to disentangle concepts of modernity and sophistication is both refreshing and illuminating. In Roman Egypt, however, fractional reserve banking was uncommon, according to Merav Haklai. Her detailed study of papyrological deposit contracts, especially the terminology and formulae used, suggests that Roman Egypt was not only highly monetised, but thoroughly permeated by access to credit in both currency and kind.
The editors have managed to put together a cohesive collection of contributions which balance detailed case-studies with well-founded general insights on the Roman economy. As capital in the Roman world becomes a subject of interest in the future — not only among Roman historians, but to scholars of other pre-industrial societies — this volume will be of enduring relevance and importance.
