It is symptomatic of Die Adam Smith Industrie called forth by the bicentennial publication of Smith's complete works in 1976 that only four (on a latitudinarian count seven) of the 28 chapters in this handbook deal with Smith's economics. That disproportion poses an intellectual puzzle, since while no one seriously disputes that Smith was one of the truly original thinkers of his age, it is arguable that without the Wealth of Nations he would rank as a secondary member of the Scottish Enlightenment whose claim to fame rests on his elaboration of certain notions suggested by Hume concerning the cognitive role of imagination to explain the formation of manners and moral values, first-rate work no doubt, but hardly the stuff of genius. Yet it is this secondary production to which Smith owes his present status among students of eighteenth-century thought, who for the most part seem uninterested in his economics. This is a book for specialists, but not in economic history or the history of economic thought.
As is well known, Smith ordered all his correspondence and manuscripts with the exception of the youthful History of Astronomy to be burned after his death, so that his thoughts on matters not explicitly treated in his published work have to be reconstructed from various editions of The Theory of Moral Sentiments, the Wealth of Nations, his lectures on Jurisprudents and Belles Lettres reconstructed from aural memory of students (who were forbidden to take notes in class), and the few letters that survived the funerary incineration. This is a little like reconstructing Pre-Socratic thought from scraps preserved in the writings of classical philosophers. Triangulating these references with each other and with the writings of Smith's contemporaries is an exacting task that, on the evidence of this handbook does not seem to have borne much fruit, possibly because Smith was a master at covering his tracks, or perhaps because there are no tracks to cover. There may be fish in that sea, but the larger species have long been taken, while the mesh of textual analysis is too large to net the smaller ones.
As a handbook intended to display recent work on Adam Smith's thought, the chapters are grouped into sections on Adam Smith and his contemporaries, his thoughts on language, art and culture, moral philosophy, history and politics, economics, social relations, and his legacy. With the exception of the essays on economics, the contributions overlap considerably, and many are wordy, imprecise, and gummy. It is discouraging, though perhaps revealing, that some of the gummiest are by university professors of English. The collection would have benefitted from editorial pruning. As it is, the philosophic and literary material is indigestible. The essays on Smith's economics are mixed and provide no novel insights. By far the best essay in the collection is Hugh Rockoff's exposition of Smith's theory of money and banking. As to the exposition of the concepts of labour and capital and value and price, one is better off consulting the original, where the economic argument and definitions are set out clearly and unambiguously. On economics, Smith left no doubt about what he meant.
The same cannot be said of The Theory of Moral Sentiments, which goes far to explain the rash of commentary provoked by it. This is a difficult book because the epistemological status of Smith's “impartial spectator” is not as obvious to us as it was to Smith's contemporaries, who seem to have accepted the theoretical gambit, although no one followed it up. There is thus room for exposition and analysis in the context of the Enlightenment assault on scholastic philosophy. Unfortunately, the essays in this collection do not address this problem; there are no demonstrations running from premises to conclusions, merely assertions claiming to “rescue” Smith's thought from erroneous interpretations that provide no clear basis for judging the nature and extent of the errors. This is putting the cart before the horse. The handbook is, therefore, best viewed as a self-referential conversation in which economists and economic historians have no part and no obvious interest. It is nevertheless incumbent on the participants to explain what the conversation is about and why it matters. Eighteenth-century philosophy is not so recondite as to be inaccessible to educated persons. If Adam Smith has something original and important to say beyond his economics, it would be nice to be told precisely what it is. Despite the attention given to Smith's moral philosophy, his true and undying gift was in economics; unlike the Wealth of Nations, the Theory of Moral Sentiments, which was widely read and respected in his own day, was a dead end that had no progeny. The only reason for continuing to work on it is that Smith dearly loved his first-born to the end, and David Hume thought it was good. Why?
