The maroon community based at “the Fort” in Prospect Bluff on the Florida panhandle was the largest in North American history. The embodiment of the anti-slavery rhetoric and ideology of British Royal Marine Edward “Fighting” Nicolls, and recruited by the British during the War of 1812, the community of former slaves allied with the Seminoles and Red Sticks that occupied the fort after the British withdrawal forms the subject of Nathaniel Millett's The Maroons of Prospect Bluff and Their Quest for Freedom in the Atlantic World. Examining issues of race, citizenship, and freedom against a backdrop of Anglo-American hostility, Millett, an Atlantic and race historian, aims to nuance slave studies through a regional analysis of the community prior to juxtaposing this experience within a multidimensional Atlantic and African diasporic framework. The crux of Millett's thesis, which resonates throughout, is that Nicolls's anti-slavery doctrine entwined with the former slaves' understanding of freedom, thereby establishing the “guiding principles and identity” of the Prospect Bluff community (127).
The book comprises eleven chapters, which can effectively be divided into two sections. The first section, chapters 1 to 5, establishes the influence and ideological profile of Nicolls before the second section analyses the Prospect Bluff community in comparison with maroon communities throughout the Americas. Chapter 1 explores the origins of Nicolls's anti-slavery doctrine and his ability to radicalize before developing this theme in chapter 2, which discusses the recruitment drive of Nicolls and Captain George Woodbine, who were charged with raising an army of slave and Indian soldiers in the historically restless and troublesome Southeast. The formation of the Corps of Colonial Marines was of concern to whites and Creeks throughout the United States, who feared a rebellion emanating from Spanish Florida. Chapter 3 dissects the escalating hostilities in the Southeast region, an “Atlantic borderland” on the cusp of the Anglo-American and Spanish Atlantic empires, by examining the British occupation of Pensacola as part of the wider British military strategy of capturing the strategic stronghold of New Orleans from the United States (34–35). While Millett explores the official British military strategy, chapters 4 and 5 emphasize the willingness of Nicolls to support his Indian and black allies even if this meant straying from his military instructions. These chapters portray Nicolls as an anti-slavery maverick with rebel tendencies. The second section shifts the focus from Nicolls to a more in-depth examination of the community itself, which Millett describes as “the only large maroon community on the entire continent” (146). Initially probing the ecological identity of the community, Millett begins to flesh out the study in the subsequent chapters, exploring the demographic and cultural profile, the daily life, and the political and military identity of the community. Millett claims that according to a modern understanding, the political and legal rights that were manifest in a black polity being formed at Prospect Bluff are testament to Nicolls's success in spreading his anti-slavery doctrine through his granting of British subject status to the former slaves on his departure. Nicolls's departure and the subsequent destruction of the community at the hands of American and Creek forces form the penultimate chapter before Millett concludes his work in the first Seminole War. Though the destruction of the community eradicated a considerable obstacle in the larger effort to annex Spanish Florida and expand the slave system, the legacy of Nicolls transcended the confines of “the Fort” and thus undermined its destruction. The Prospect Bluff experience would live on in the minds of Nicolls's black and Indian allies for many years to come in their understanding of freedom and in their experience of shared purpose and togetherness.
To summarize, this book is a welcome addition to the expanding paradigm of studies of the Atlantic world, establishing the historical importance of the Prospect Bluff community in relation to the wider issues of race and citizenship in the early republic. Millett brings the community to the historical fore through Nicolls's ideology, thereby ensuring that his study is far more than a comparative analysis of maroon communities. At the same time, the depth of analysis of the community itself will be of particular interest to environmental scholars. Given that the book centres on Nicolls, Millett could have offered more in-depth analysis of the formation of his character by expanding the discussion of formal education and religion as influencing factors in his radical anti-slavery ideology. Was Nicolls's doctrine uniformly interpreted by all members of the community? What influence did the official British military positions, which often contradicted Nicolls's actions, have on his influence to radicalize? How faithfully was his doctrine transmitted from those who had met him to those fugitive slaves who joined the community once he had departed? These are, however, minor suggestions to an excellent book of multidisciplinary appeal. Millett, supported by an impressive bibliography, has composed a thought-provoking work that will be useful to nonexperts and scholars alike.
