In this richly illustrated volume, Hérica Valladares unfurls a compelling argument that the widespread appearance in the first century c.e. of frescoes depicting amatory scenes — couples in the preliminary stages of intimacy and relevant mythological scenes — reflects a widespread interest in art as a metonymic code designed for the knowing reader of Roman bucolic and elegiac poetry. Referring to Roland Barthes’ conception of tendresse (A Lover's Discourse — Fragments, 1978), Valladares formulates a notion of tenderness in Roman art, whereby images served as representational, amatory codes that gave ‘form to the ineffable through a series of metaphoric displacements’ that were ‘historically and culturally determined’ (4). For the author, the cultural and historical determinants at work were the popular poems of, primarily, Vergil, Propertius and Ovid, and the Augustan milieu wherein marital relationships came under scrutiny and legislation, yes, but also gained primacy of place. As marriage became the sanctioned locus of erotic desire, the author suggests, the domus became a space where home-owners might design a domesticated, artistic vocabulary engaged with knowing reception of Roman love-poetry.
In her introduction, V. presents the major prevailing interpretations of amatory scenes in Roman wall-painting, e.g.: that they are attempts at rendering everyday life (Brendel, 1970); that they are artistic reflections of attitudes about sex, gender and status (Clarke, 1998); and that they evoke the sensuality of Hellenistic epigrams (Rizzo, 1929 and 1936). She offers that ‘this intense new interest in amatory subjects on the part of a Roman audience is also linked with events taking place closer to home’ than Alexandrian literature (8), and she demonstrates the significance of the domestic space as a scaena for romance in the poetry of Catullus and Propertius. Despite the early demise of literary love-poetry, she suggests that wall-paintings would become the place where ‘a pictorial code for depicting romantic tenderness began to take shape’ (28). In the three chapters that follow, the author artfully unpacks a number of images found in elite Roman houses and in expensively adorned Pompeiian homes, and explains how they correspond to this notion of tenderness.
V. begins in the first chapter by comparing images in a house at Rome and two at Pompeii: the ancient Villa della Farnesina, entombed on the banks of the Tiber, the house of Caecilius Iucundus and the house of Lucretius Fronto. The paintings depict loving couples in rooms that are far from private, appearing in association with a tablinum, a triclinium or a porticoed garden — clearly designed to be viewed and appreciated by guests. As the author sees it, these works demonstrate ‘the crystallization of a Roman amatory code [and] a close association between luxury, privacy, and tenderness’ (57) and an engagement with elegiac poetry in which ‘romance and marriage were no longer mutually exclusive’ (65). In the second chapter, V. examines the widespread appearance of Polyphemus and Galatea in many houses, starting with the House of Livia on the Palatine Hill. Interpreting these paintings in concert with bucolic and elegiac poetry of the period, she shows that the images of a handsome, love-struck Polyphemus on the wall of Livia's tablinum, for example, reflect a synthesis of these poetic forms, ‘a more tender vision of the pastoral world as a quintessential amatory landscape’ (91). Polyphemus and other problematic figures (Argus, Perseus, Hercules) are depicted on walls at Rome and Pompeii in ways that do not match any one poetic treatment, but that make sense in the cosmopolitan milieu of poetic reception, as V. indicates. A third chapter explains the frequent appearance of another ‘monstrous’ figure, Medea, contemplating the murder of her children, as she was probably represented in the painting by Timomachus, often discussed in literature of the period. Marshalling considerable evidence from the anthologies of Greek epigram, Pliny the Elder and Ovid, most notably his Heroides, V. makes the case that the fascination with Medea reflects interest in ‘the artist's skill in representing that which was unrepresentable: his subjects’ emotions … their tender interiors’ (142). Thus, the author concludes, women like Medea, Phaedra and Helen, who all famously appear together in the House of Jason at Pompeii, are not so much women who transgress, but women whom love drove to great extremes. Medea in so many domestic frescoes becomes, therefore, a ‘love heroine … emblematic of the larger process of the creation and diffusion of a Roman poetic and pictorial amatory discourse in the early imperial period’ (185). V. closes her book with a brief epilogue that provides other indications, in painting and in funerary relief sculpture, that conjugal tenderness became a trope that Romans took for granted.
The book includes many black-and-white images and ten coloured photographic plates that amply illustrate the concepts V. explains, and there are plans for each house or villa that is discussed at length. Her prose is lucid, relatively jargon-free and conceptually clear, and the author deftly manages literary and artistic interpretations throughout her analyses. One may quibble here and there with the interpretations that V. offers — wishing perhaps to apply more emphasis to misogyny, Roman notions of female transgression or objectification of the female body in these images. Even so, V. has succeeded in painting a lively picture of elite Romans and wealthy Pompeiians appreciating the resonance between painted images, lived experience and literary subjects as they gazed upon and discussed images on the walls of the homes they visited and inhabited.
