Considering Kurdistan's ever-changing and increasingly significant role in a volatile and realigning part of the Middle East, all new contributions to the literature are welcome. Kurdish Identity brings together Kurdish specialists from academic, diplomatic, human-rights, and political worlds to provide historical and contemporary analyses, global and regional perspectives, and some original research, all largely, and thankfully, devoid of lofty theory and pretentious prose.
For readers hungry for the latest research on Kurdish national identity and the most up-to-date analyses of their political status in the tumultuous post Iraq-invasion region, this 2007 volume may fail to satisfy. Kurdish Identity was born of an April 2000 conference and as such displays the unevenness that often results from these publishing endeavors. In addition, the book is largely unable to address the numerous questions concerning Kurdish identity that have mushroomed since the end of the Iraqi Baʿth regime, which has forever altered the position of the Kurds vis-à-vis their Arab, Turkish, and Persian neighbors.
The Iraq references in the book naturally suffer the most, loaded with analyses of the impact of United Nations sanctions and discussions of “reconciliation” (which is not a reference to Shiʿa–Sunni Arab relations) and of Iraq as a failed state. However, several selections stand as historical documentation of the mindset of Kurdish politicians and American diplomats in the preinvasion period. A few humorous-in-retrospect moments appear, such as the statement by Francis J. Ricciardone, former State Department special coordinator on Iraq: “We recognize that change in Iraq will come from within” (p. 248).
This twenty-five-chapter edited volume offers more valuable contributions. In some chapters an effort was made to update; others heavy on historical analysis or original research are not impacted by the passage of time.
The book is divided into five easy-to-maneuver parts with the three core sections focused on identity issues and the rise of nationalism in Iraq, Iran, and Turkey. This organization speaks volumes about Kurdish identity and reinforces both the general notion among scholars that the Kurdish nation is no monolith and the editors' summarizing contention that “the Kurdish identity in the Middle East remains a function of the Kurdish situation in the various states in which they live” (p. 262).
An examination of the position of Kurds in Syria is absent, as is often the case given the dearth of research opportunities in that country. Iranian Kurds are usually less represented in the field as well, so the inclusion of four chapters on nationalism, human rights, and economic change in Iran is welcomed.
Farideh Koohi-Kamali offers a well-researched and thought-provoking analysis of the history, character, and dimensions of Iranian Kurdish nationalism. She links that development to the peculiarities of midcentury Iranian land-reform policies that inadvertently fostered social cohesiveness among the Kurds and deterred class antagonism, which in turn promoted nationalist awareness. In addition, the Kurdish sense of inequality compared to Persian Iran further encouraged group solidarity and fueled nationalist sentiment. The Kurdish intelligentsia was therefore poised to transfer those sentiments into a mass movement when central authority collapsed in 1979: “What nationalist intelligentsia had to achieve by much hard groundwork in other historical eras and other countries was achieved for the Kurdish nationalists by the sheer force of rapid economic and social changes resulting from the land reform program of the 1960s” (p. 227). Although the new Islamist government quickly reestablished control, the one year of political freedom was enough, according to Koohi-Kamali, for leaders to build a mass party on the solid foundation of nationalist identity that had formed earlier.
To the west in Turkey, state policies of a different nature determined the path to Kurdish nationalism, as detailed by M. Hakan Yavuz in “Five Stages of the Construction of Kurdish Nationalism in Turkey.” He posits that Turkish Kurdish cultural identity was politicized by Kemalist modernization policies and concludes that Turkey needs a new social contract based on secularism, the rule of law, and recognition of the country's multiculturalism. For Yavuz, the continuing “Kurdish problem” allows for external pressure on the Turkish state and hinders internal democratic reform and therefore must be addressed.
Michael M. Gunter similarly argues, although from a different point of view, that settlement of the Kurdish question is the key to Turkey's future. He provides a cogent and detailed analysis of the political impact of the 1999 capture and imprisonment of Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) leader Abdullah Öcalan, which, he writes, “led to a process of continuing implicit bargaining between the Turkish government and the PKK that holds out the hope of a win–win result for all the parties involved” (p. 53). Although realistically outlining the many obstacles, including the self-interest of the powerful Turkish military, Gunter asserts that a resolution not only could lead to the end of a bloody insurgency but also could move the country toward more democratic policies. This in turn would move Turkey toward acceptance in the European Union, which would expand the Kurdish question to the purview of it.
There are other worthwhile reads in the book, including Earnest Tucker's intriguing discussion of “Ottoman Lessons for a Federal Iraq” and Carole A. O'Leary's “Communalism and the Future of Iraq,” both of which offer insights into the civil strife that has gripped Iraq in the past few years. In all, this title is useful for those teaching undergraduates about the region and belongs on the shelf of anyone interested in sorting through the various strains and impacts of Kurdish identities.
