Most Jewish Israelis were raised on stories of the early Zionist settlers who suffered from malaria during their first years in Palestine and the young pioneers who subsequently drained the swamps from which the disease emanated. Indeed, the draining of swamps in prestate Palestine has been a pillar of Zionist folklore and Israeli national heritage for more than seventy years.
But how did malaria impact the local Arab and the Jewish settler populations, and how widespread was it? To what extent was swamp drainage the work of Zionist institutions, and what role was played by Palestinian Arabs and Mandate government officials? What was the source of the scientific and technological knowledge required to drain swampland and control the disease? In addition, how did these efforts factor into nationalist ideologies and the political debate over the future of Palestine at the time? Such questions have gone relatively unexplored in the historical scholarship on Israel/Palestine, that is, until the recent publication of Sandra Sufian's Healing the Land and the Nation: Malaria and the Zionist Project in Palestine, 1920–1947.
Based on an impressive collection of secondary sources and primary documents from archives in Israel, England, and the United States, Healing the Land offers a thorough and balanced history of Zionist swamp draining and antimalaria efforts in Mandate Palestine. Sufian maintains that these efforts were not simply practical measures taken to prevent illness among Jewish settlers and to free up additional land for Jewish settlement in the process, but they also assumed Zionist ideological significance as a necessary precondition for transforming Diaspora Jewry into a culturally, physically, and economically healthy people living in their biblical homeland (thus the book's title, Healing the Land and the Nation). In this way, Sufian shows how science and medicine served as powerful forces in the transformation of Palestine's physical landscape and Zionism's campaign to appropriate both land and the land from the country's local Palestinian population.
Healing the Land is organized thematically, with each of its seven chapters addressing a different aspect of Zionist antimalaria and swamp-draining efforts. Sufian skillfully weaves these components together to produce a complex and sophisticated narrative that emphasizes historical detail as well as political, discursive, and metaphorical significance. Chapter 1 explores the Zionist aim of transforming Diaspora Jewry into a healthy nation and the role of Zionist antimalaria efforts in facilitating the Jewish people's bond to the land. Chapter 2 offers a brief epidemiology of the disease, a summary of its presence in Mandate Palestine, and an overview of Mandate and Zionist policies regarding malaria control. In the next two chapters, Sufian focuses on Zionist officials' practical, semantic, and discursive use of swamp-draining measures to facilitate continued Jewish immigration and settlement and describes the nuts and bolts of the practical drainage work carried out. The following two chapters show how scientific and medical understandings of the land, and the distinctive “medical cartography” that emerged from the swamp-draining efforts, transformed Palestine by eradicating the very landscapes they represented. In the final two chapters, Sufian explores the Zionist “culture of health” that went hand in hand with the Yishuv's antimalaria efforts and then highlights the ethnically contested nature of swamplands in prestate Palestine.
Healing the Land is an academic exploration of a hitherto underresearched topic of historical and geographical significance and therefore makes an important contribution to the scholarship. The book's importance, however, is by no means limited to its coverage of an unexplored subject area and use of new material. Its value also derives (and perhaps most importantly) from its critical and thorough treatment of its subject matter, which offers new insight into a host of related topics. One compelling example stems from Sufian's constant reminder of the colonial context in which Zionist and British antimalaria measures in Palestine were carried out. Sufian shows not only that these efforts were based on techniques and scientific knowledge developed and applied in other colonial territories, but also that they produced knowledge for other colonial malariologists and international health organizations engaged in malaria-control efforts around the world. In this way, Palestine emerges not only as a recipient of colonial scientific knowledge but also as an exporter, based to a large degree on the extensive work of Zionist malariologists and public health officials.
Another related topic on which Healing the Land sheds new light is malaria's changing influence on Palestine's pre-1948 Jewish-settlement geography. During the first few decades of colonization, Sufian recounts, this influence was positive, because the large, thinly populated tracts of land in the plains and valleys, which absentee landlords purchased from the Ottoman government and subsequently sold to Jewish land purchasers, typically included swampland and a high prevalence of malaria. This changed later, we learn, when in 1927 Zionist health professionals and the Jewish National Fund agreed that the establishment of new settlements would be conditional upon the beginning of local malaria-control measures.
Healing the Land is a pleasure to read (except perhaps in the case of a few particularly dense sections presenting detailed empirical findings), both because it is beautifully written and because it establishes its relevance to modern-day Israel from the outset by beginning and ending its historical narrative with an account of Israel's partial reflooding of the Huleh Valley swampland in the 1990s (four decades after it was drained). This reversal, Sufian explains, reflects the major change that has taken place since the 1950s in how Israeli and Zionist officials understand their natural environment in general and the role of swampland in particular, as well as the common denominator of science, research, and landscape engineering that lay at the heart of both the draining and the reflooding projects.
All in all, and despite its focus on a seemingly technical subject that is typically thought of as the territory of geographers and scientists alone, Healing the Land will be of great interest to students and scholars of medical history, colonial history, and historical geography with regard to Israel/Palestine and in general. It reminds us that in addition to the forces that more typically factor into historical narratives of modern geographical change, science and medicine must be recognized and explored as a force through which people shape their histories and reshape the physical and imagined geographies in which they live.
