The persistence of the now centuries-old belief that “race,” referring to biological differences that delineate human populations from one another, is real and transmitted in the “blood,” has shaped conversations about belonging in American Indian communities. Many non-Indians assume that anyone who claims Indian “blood” belongs to a tribe, but for Native people, these determinations are informed by many factors, including the legal constructs related to citizenship, economic concerns stemming from the management of communal resources, and social norms within and outside of Native communities. In the Gilded Age and Progressive Era South, Native peoples had to continually revisit their answer to the question “who belongs?” to reflect community expectations, protect resources, and ensure that outsiders perceived them to be Americans Indian—not colored—people. In her comparative analysis of five Southeastern tribes, Mikaëla M. Adams explains how.
Adams builds off the work of Osage anthropologist Jean Dennison, who coined the term “logic of recognition,” referring to the pressure tribes have felt to portray what whites perceived as a distinct racial and cultural identity to maintain their political sovereignty. In other words, determinations of belonging are at the same time expressions of human relationships among insiders and a performance for outsiders. This process was never simple, and it varied widely, particularly in the South as tribes negotiated this within the black/white binary of Jim Crow. Adams explains how this played out through chapter-length case studies of the Pamunkey Indian Tribe of Virginia, the Catawba Indian Nation of South Carolina, the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians, the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians of North Carolina, and the Seminole Tribe of Florida and Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida. She asserts that the determination of tribal citizenship remains a fundamental expression of tribal sovereignty; that definitions of tribal citizenship evolved in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries in response to post-Civil War federal Indian policy and the rise of Jim Crow; and that tribes made strategic decisions intended to maintain their autonomy, particularly over land and resources, while retaining some traditional means of determining relatedness.
Adams begins with an outstanding introduction clarifying that although white Americans have conflated race and belonging, tribal citizenship is a legal matter. Her introduction would be particularly useful even as a stand-alone reading in courses about race and identity construction. In Chapter One, Adams explains how the Pamunkeys, who have maintained possession of a separate reservation since the colonial period and who were recognized by the federal government in 2016, created a multitiered system of defining citizenship and its accordant rights based on descent from a core group of ancestors, current social connections, and a residency requirement. The Catawbas, the focus of Chapter Two, have cultivated a close relationship with their white neighbors in South Carolina since the colonial period; as a result, they internalized some of their attitudes about race, particularly concerning the inferiority of African Americans. Following the Treaty of Nation Ford in 1840, South Carolina created appropriation lists to facilitate the distribution of payments. Catawbas influenced the content of the lists, and the lists shaped Catawba conceptions of belonging, especially regarding intermarriage to African Americans and residency in the state. These lists served as the basis for a roll in 1943 that formalized decades of calculated exclusion.
Adams's next two case studies explore Native groups who remained behind in their ancestral homelands when most of their nations were removed. She turns to the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians in Chapter Three. Denied land rights under the Treaty of Dancing Rabbit Creek in 1830 and through allotment at the turn of the twentieth century, the Choctaws carved out an identity for themselves as separate from the Choctaws in Indian Territory and black Mississippians by portraying themselves as fullbloods committed to their language and traditional way of life. Shunning Choctaws with African ancestry, they attained de facto federal recognition in 1918. In western North Carolina, the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians aggressively sought to keep their rolls small and exclude those with less than 1/16th Cherokee ancestry. They are the subject of Chapter Four. Access to reservation land and per capita payments proved attractive to “white Indians” who claimed descent but lacked ties to Cherokee communities. Cherokees with African ancestry also found themselves excluded by the Eastern band.
In her last chapter, Adams examines the cases of the Seminole Tribe of Florida and the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida. A shared history of dissent sparked their resistance to removal and formal political organization. Ultimately, non-Indian development and settlement prompted some Seminoles to accept reservations and organize to protect their resources. Well into the twentieth century, Seminole and Miccosukee people shunned those who intermarried out of a rejection of intermixture and mistrust of outsiders.
Adams draws evidence from a range of ethnographic, tribal, state, and federal sources. Each one of these chapters could be its own book, and yet her concise, detailed treatment of the five case studies is comprehensive and nuanced. She emphasizes common concerns in all the case studies: a fear of being perceived as black and losing tribal status; the loss of control over tribal politics and resources to intermarried whites; the distribution of resources to those who moved away and no longer shared cultural and social ties with the community.
This book will be a welcome addition to classes on the histories of Native peoples, the South, and race. A strength is Adams's pivot between policy and personal stories. She infuses the book with just enough genealogy to provide a human face to decisions that often had less to do with relationships than with protecting resources; asserting sovereignty; or, in the case of the federal government, just finishing the job.
Nearly two centuries after the federal government forcibly removed large numbers of Native people from the Southeast, many Indigenous nations in the region are thriving. They have retained or gained access to tribally owned land, maintained aspects of their traditional culture while adapting to modern life, and continue to function as self-governing communities. This book is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand Native Southerners today.
