As its title emphasizes, this book is constructed in terms of the fashionable metaphor of ‘mapping’, its three parts offering the ‘Lay of the Landscape’, ‘Cartographies’ and ‘Mapping PAR in the United States’. The avowed aim of the collection is ‘to bring the United States into dialogue with work in practice as research in performance and the arts in general’ (p. xvi). Indeed, two-thirds of the contributions to the fourteen-section opening part are from the UK, Australia, Canada, Finland, South Africa and China, affording US readers an opportunity to engage in dialogue with more established and recently emergent PaR cultures. The remaining contributions to Part I reciprocally chart what is happening now in the USA. Part III then takes up the mapping of US arts practices in fourteen short case studies, whilst Part II offers ‘Terms for Finding/Charting the Way(s)’. The rationale for the nine keyword entries in the latter section is that they appear frequently in the collection (p. xxii), but they would equally appear in many a book on contemporary performance.
The mapping metaphor is particularly useful in acknowledging the situated position from which this book speaks. The Introduction points out that ‘how we know what we know is partly dependent on where we know’ (p. xx). Such a ‘standpoint’ epistemology resonates with much PaR activity involving ‘scholarly acts’ (p. xix) overtly concerned with subject–object interrelations. A subtle distinction between EU/UK PaR and US PAR (p. xviii) annexes social practices to experimental performance, and, indeed, half of the contributions to Part III focus on practice-based pedagogies whilst the other half are concerned with community performance. Though this perspective is illuminating about the current understanding of practice as research from a US standpoint, I am not wholly convinced by the argument that this is a dimension subtly different from what has been established in the UK and elsewhere. Applied arts and ethnographies are certainly not excluded from the UK conception of PaR; their inclusion is contingent, as with all PaR, upon a research inquiry which is fundamentally grounded in arts practices.
Shannon Jackson addresses the question ‘When is Art Research?’ to open Part III, but recounts a seminar series which talks around the question, marking challenges and opportunities rather than addressing it directly in the current institutional context. Lynette Hunter, however, acknowledges the need for PAR to establish itself in the face of an at times hostile academy. In a second contribution to Part III, she affirms PAR as art which ‘searches and constitutes things through the process of articulating the research’ (p. 230), and this approach certainly resonates with a key finding from the UK debate: the challenge is to bring out the research imperative (in the practice itself and/or in related documentation). Though many of the accounts in this volume offer fascinating insights into what practitioners are doing in their teaching and in communities, only a few clearly formulate this research dimension.
This is by no means to dismiss the contribution this publication makes in ‘generating research projects on PaR and its development in different contexts’ (p. xv). Though PaR is now established in many parts of the world, its place in academic research culture is not entirely secure. Haseman's account of missed opportunities in Australia (pp. 51–61) is a salutary reminder that we need to be clear when arts practice constitutes a knowledge-producing inquiry, and to work together to advance the cause. Though I would not wish to efface difference, a common approach might be politic at this moment. The collection offers a variety of specific contributions, and it is helpful to have a US perspective. I welcome the thirty or so voices joining in the conversation on practice as research.
