Stuff and Money in the Time of the French Revolution is a must-read for historians of economics interested in money. Rebecca Spang describes the creation and destruction of money during the French Revolution. With her account, money becomes an integral part of the revolution; and its history is the history of the revolution. Money is therefore an active participant in the events, no less than the National Assembly or the guillotine are in the more standard history of the revolution. Here, the political history with which one may be familiar is a faraway background. The center stage is exclusively given to money. In Spang’s account, money is, in a way, more revolutionary than the guillotine, more terrifying than the Terror, creating more instability than civil wars.
The history of money that Spang offers us is not a linear history that goes from a concrete to an abstract means of exchange. Money does not linearly go from commodity to paper. Spang does a marvelous job in also describing the materiality of money, its physical characteristics. Money does not transform itself from physical to abstract. Physical and abstract money coexists, rather than one substituting for the other. The more “monetarized” the economy was, the less need there was for actual physical money. Rich people, and the state itself, lived on credit. Poor people had to have cash.
Money was more abstract when it was in the form of coins than in the form of paper. The function of units of account (or “money of account” or “imaginary money”) was traditionally separated from the function of medium of exchange (the actual coin): for example, while people would quote prices in livres, there was no livre coin but a large variety of coins mostly named after their physical appearance. We have to wait until 1803 to see the legislation that gives birth to the franc as both a new unit of account as well as a new coin. But even as late as 1827, more than two-thirds of the coins issued between 1726 and 1794 were still in circulation. In addition, at the beginning, the assignats were accepted because they were not “paper money”: they were “land in a liquid, circulating form” (pp. 81–82). And yet, with the pressing hyperinflation, the assignats become paper, revolutionizing social relations: only the poor would now be forced to accept them. The rich would rely on metal coins instead. Attempts to make small change would create riots, which even the armed troops were not able to calm down.
For Spang, money is a political actor. “Money is also an institution, or microtechnology, for the production and reproduction of shared norms and social cohesion” (p. 6). When the revolution declares all taxes illegal because the people did not agree to pay them, and at the same time debt is declared sacred so that bankruptcy is not an option, the assignats become an instrument to implement the revolution, and their acceptance becomes a patriotic duty. Spang makes it clear that originally this did not imply legal tender in any way. The assignats were a patriotic symbol exactly because they were voluntarily accepted (or rejected). The individual liberty that the revolution stood for and the forced circulation of assignats could not be compatible.
Money was also an anti-centralization force against which the state had eventually to fight. The thousands of entities that issued money before, during, and even after the revolution are a testimony against the centralizing power of the state. The king may have had monopoly power on minting, but there was no monopoly on mining: the amount of metal brought to the mint was determined by the private sector only. In addition, this monopoly did not imply centralization. France had seventeen independent mints until 1794 (the year of the Terror). Even the social unity that a uniform money should have promoted was originally not a task of the assignats, which bore the differences of their makers, and those differences were perceived as signs of their authenticity. The battle for “material identity was fundamentally a political ideal: the inability to legislate uniformity was an admission that one could not legislate custom and tradition into existence” (p. 133). “National money—like national language—was largely a foreign idea in eighteenth century Europe” (p. 137). But the production of assignats was eventually assigned to the Central Manufactory of Assignats and it gave the state a monopoly on the means of production: yet, “no one could arrive with paper and ask that it be printed into money (yet further proof, one might say, that the assignats were not paper money)” (p. 104). But the large-denomination assignats were soon joined by smaller denomination billets, issued by thousands of bodies across all France.
And yet, money was the only revolution and national symbol that was actually mass produced (not even military uniforms were). The king was captured, after all, because an innkeeper recognized him as the same person on the assignats.
Money, for Spang, is therefore a living institution, which changes shapes and forms and which affects the life of the people with whom it lives. Money is not a “monument” but a living relation between individuals. Money connects women buying bread to tax collectors, mint workers to landlords. Money is a relation among people that forces them to think what other people think. The hyperinflation of 1795–96 was just as powerful, if not even more powerful, a social terrorizing and disruptive force as the Terror itself: “The links holding society together were broken when retailers refused the only money most people had” (p. 230).
The main message that Spang seems to give us is that “paper was not the problem. Politics—the struggle for cultural legitimacy and economic power among individuals defined in regional, social, and ideological terms—politics was the problem” (p. 249). To understand revolutionary money, we need to abandon models that see money as purely an abstract thing or purely a material thing, and adopt instead models of money that take into account its living history and its dialectic interactions between its abstract ideal and its material form. This is a message from which historians of economics could benefit.
