Although recent years have seen a number of general histories on Korea being published in English, new additions are always welcome. A History of Korea: From “Land of the Morning Calm” to States in Conflict by Jinwung Kim is a clearly written, comprehensive, and impressively detailed work and as such has the potential to be a useful contribution. The author is a specialist on Korea-U.S. relations, and in particular the treatment of post-1945 developments in this book gives an in-depth and balanced picture of a very tumultuous and contested period in Korean history. The introduction states that one of the author's aims in writing this book was to present a coherent consensus on contentious periods in Korean history. The treatment of the division of Korea and the outbreak of the Korean War is indeed successful in achieving this, and the treatment of postwar developments is also illuminating by giving equal weight to the treatment of both states. The detailed narration also provides insights lacking in other English-language general histories.
The treatment of other periods in Korean history is also very detailed and in a similar manner often provides information usually not found in general surveys. This is a potential strength of the book, but unfortunately the treatment of other periods suffers from a lack of academic stringency. In the richness of details there are claims that are impossible to substantiate. Claims to know the sentiments of “all Koreans” could be understood in certain contexts in a book of this nature, but this reviewer fails to see how the author can claim to know that Neolithic man on the Korean peninsula called the sun “hanŭnim” (p. 5). The book contains other similar anachronisms: that the Yemaek and Han all “spoke the same language, Korean” (p. 9), and that the three Han people used the “ture” system of communal farming (p. 30). In the view of this reader, explaining that the paksa of Koguryo were “equivalent to today's PhD” (p. 65) does not facilitate a good understanding of the period.
The above-mentioned intention to provide a coherent consensus is in earlier parts impaired by the occasional uncritical inclusion of contested claims with little foundation in historical sources. Uncritically introducing the claim that it was the dongyi that established the Chinese Yin (Shang) dynasty is problematic in itself (p. 9), but to later claim that Yin people migrated to Chosŏn because it “was considered the native state of the dongyi people” (p. 12) and that they felt that “the Zhou, established by Chinese, might not suit them well” is to undermine the reader's trust in the academic stringency of the book. Another example of the inclusion of contested claims is the suggestion that Koreans might have used a hieroglyphic script before the introduction of the Chinese writing system (p. 63).
The unfortunately uncritical inclusion of problematic claims might be a result of the ambition to provide a narration rich in detail, but could also be related to the lack of a coherent approach to historical development that could have provided an overarching principle for how to deal with historical facts. In a general history, the larger framework is as important as the individual facts, and the approach to Korean history in this work feels rather outdated and certainly does not reflect recent academic scholarship. The notion of a Korean nation, for example, is uncritically projected back into prehistoric times, and the unfolding of Korean history is not described in terms of socioeconomic and sociopolitical developments, in the context of larger regional interactions and trends, or in any other comprehensive and dynamic manner, but is rather understood in quite crude terms of dynastic cycles—for example, “compared to other nations, each of Korea's dynasties lasted too long, and fell into chronic corruption, stagnation, inertia, and lethargy” (p. xiii).
Apart from some odd claims to new historical facts being introduced, the author simply states that the aim of the book is to “provide foreign readers with a general survey of Korea's long, rich history from ancient times to present” (p. xiii). This in itself is, of course, not problematic, but it is not made clear in what way this aim dictates the approach to Korean history and its narration, and with “foreign readers” as the target audience unfortunately the book falls into the habit of repeatedly claiming the superiority and outstanding characteristics of Korea. This reviewer is not questioning the cultural achievements of Korea, but such an approach can hardly be considered a new and fresh contribution to the field warranting the authoring of a new general history.
Furthermore, in addressing a foreign audience, the author also apparently feels a need to settle the “history war,” that is, “South Korea's long-standing battle with China and Japan over historical records and territorial disputes” (p. xiv). Reputing untenable Chinese and Japanese claims through objective and balanced scholarship is of course a welcome endeavor, but the manner in which the narration in this book is interrupted with rather long sections of anachronistic references and speculations as to the ulterior motives of Korea's neighbors does not facilitate a better understanding of the issues at stake.
Given the solid, balanced, and informative treatment of post-1945 developments (although unfortunately the objectivity in dealing with the postliberation period is somewhat lost when the book finally reaches the last presidencies in South Korea), I would like to be able to recommend this book both to an academic audience and to the larger readership interested in Korea, but overall the somewhat outdated approach to the long-term developments of Korean history and the lack of academic stringency in the treatment of earlier periods in Korean history impair the potential this book has to be an important contribution to the field.
