Rola el-Husseini's Pax Syriana is a solid, well-written book that examines elite politics in Lebanon during the 1989–2005 period of Syrian suzerainty. While an excellent primer on Lebanese politics of this period, the book also situates its subject in the context of post–World War II Lebanese political history. It will therefore be especially helpful to those looking for an outline of some of the basic and deep-seated fault lines marking Lebanon’s elite politics over a long durée. Most informed readers will likely find the last chapter's examination of the country's attitudes towards Syria particularly interesting, especially in light of the civil war now raging across the border. (The chapter is based largely on interviews that the author conducted between 2001 and 2006.) Along with a brief foreword from former U.S. Ambassador to Lebanon Ryan Crocker, the book contains an introduction, seven chapters, and a conclusion. It also has a timeline of major events from 1989 to 2005 as well as an appendix, which provides a “Who's Who of Lebanese Politics” in the postwar era that many readers will find helpful. The book is free of jargon and accessible to a general audience. Instructors looking for a work that focuses on post civil war politics in Lebanon or on Lebanese–Syrian relations could certainly assign Pax Syriana to undergraduate and graduate students alike.
The author draws on a wide range of secondary sources in Arabic, English, and French, as well as fifty-six interviews she conducted “with established and emerging members of the political elite” (p. xviii). El-Husseini also held twenty-two “informal discussions with journalists, academics, and other observers of the Lebanese political scene” in Lebanon between 2001 and 2006 (p. xviii). Her interviewees come from across the Lebanese political spectrum. Chapter 7 (and to a lesser extent Chapter 6) draws heavily from this fieldwork.
According to el-Husseini, her focus on elites “provides a very direct line to understanding the shifting features of political power and of national political discourses” (p. xvii). She breaks the elite down into three subgroups: “state elites,” or the group that came into power during the civil war period; “strategic elites,” or those who wield power from outside the electoral system, such as “military commanders, religious leaders, and important journalists” (p. xx); and “emerging elites,” or the younger politicians waiting for their chance to step into important positions.
Given the book's focus on the Lebanese political elite, it should come as no surprise that Pax Syriana paints a rather uncomplimentary picture of some. The sketches of former President Emile Lahoud and politician Michel Murr standout as particularly unflattering. One of the few exceptions in el-Husseini's rather bleak tableau is Samir Qassir, the academic and journalist assassinated in 2005, who comes off as a person of great integrity and courage.
The book argues that the underlying issues that led to the 1975–90 civil war remain unresolved due to two factors, both related to Pax Syriana. The first is “Syria's . . . interference in Lebanon's political affairs” in the postwar period (p. 214). Syrian hegemony guaranteed a kind of “superficial” stability, but this came at the cost of the continuing “stagnation” and “gridlock” of Lebanon's political system. Second, Lebanon's unyielding clientelist confessional system, with its closed patronage networks, became even more deeply entrenched during the Pax Syriana period. Elite cartels consolidated their power through an ever-expanding capacity for corruption that was partly facilitated by Syrian officials.
For those well acquainted with the recent history of Lebanese politics, much in this book will be familiar. However, even the most well-informed reader will find that the book offers much more than a scorecard of the comings and goings of major political figures, a description of the shifting geographies of elite networks, and speculations about the motives behind the maneuvers of the Syrian leadership vis-à-vis Lebanon. Pax Syriana takes up a number of issues that one wishes were more common in works on Lebanese politics, such as the dearth of women among the elite (pp. 164–70) and their almost complete absence from important political positions in general (one of the only exceptions is Setrida Geagea), or the “brain drain” of talented and highly skilled youth who, despairing from the confessional system's stranglehold on politics, seek their fortunes abroad (pp. 119–20).
Perhaps due to limitations of space or possibly for analytical clarity, a few key sections of the book remain suggestive and could benefit from a bit more concrete detail. For example, in Chapter 6 the author outlines a taxonomy of seven ideal types of “emerging elites,” ranging from “civil society activists” to the “Hezbollahi” (pp. 170–85). El-Husseini could have strengthened this section by identifying more than one or two representatives for each category. Along the same lines, the “Clients of Syria” section in the fourth chapter names only a single individual (pp. 106–8), while the appellation “warrior-priests” is applied to only three individuals (pp. 75, 256). The reader would gain greater appreciation of el-Husseini's nomenclature and typologies had she ascribed them more widely to political actors in Lebanon. This is not to question the soundness of the book's many thought-provoking arguments; it is only to suggest that more empirical evidence would bolster the analytical and theoretical weight of the book.
Finally, one wonders whether the title of the book, Pax Syriana: Elite Politics in Postwar Lebanon, is completely faithful to its content. Although focused on the period of Syrian dominance in Lebanon (1991–2005), the book quite rightly takes a long view of Lebanese political culture in order to provide a sense of the logic of the elite-dominated confessional system. Because this same logic seems to prevail from the prewar period into the present, it is not hard to imagine a reader who, although cognizant of Syria's presence in the pages of the book, might wonder where the line between Pax Syriana and the general continuity of Lebanese political culture lies. In other words, how much of a factor was Syrian dominance in Lebanon if the political culture operates the same way now as it did in the 1960s? Perhaps this is the question with which the author intended to leave the reader. In any case, Pax Syriana has much to teach anyone interested in Lebanese politics, society, and history.
