Historians familiar with the literature of the 1906 San Francisco catastrophe will give a mental sigh of relief when reading the introduction to this useful book. Unlike authors of other valuable but journalistic accounts of the disaster, Andrea Rees Davies clearly and systematically sets forth in her introduction the historical methodology and argumentation used to construct this monograph derived from her Stanford University doctoral dissertation. After revealing the inspiration that her former career as a San Francisco firefighter brings to her studies of urban disaster, Davies outlines her sources and the questions she asks of them. She challenges certain received notions, such as the egalitarianism of disaster relief, arguing in contrast that “relief efforts put new emphasis on preexisting social differences, an outcome that would have long-term consequences for San Franciscans” (3). Davies sets her story in the most convincing San Francisco disaster historiography, the “seismic denial narrative,” arguing that the focus on the damage rendered by fire and minimization of the preceding earthquake “rendered San Francisco no more vulnerable than any other city and touted its rebuilding as a sound investment” (4).
Davies also throws into relief “the uneven transition from nineteenth-century approaches to charity to twentieth-century social work methodologies,” highlighting in particular the contribution of women (7). Surprisingly, Davies omits from her discussion of moral reform the intensive public health campaigns that contributed to post-disaster construction policies.Footnote 1 Her sharpest focus is on disaster survivors themselves, and although Davies inserts their stories in the larger political and economic context, her work remains essentially a social history presenting the argument that “interactions among relief policy makers, providers, and recipients reveal the underlying social dynamics in San Francisco and expose some key themes of the national debates about aid and welfare for suffering Americans in general” (5). In addition to post-1906 San Francisco historiography, this monograph contributes to the larger scholarship of Progressive Era moral reform and social order, gender relations, urban development, and urban disasters, presenting an in-depth history of post disaster relief and recovery anchored in an analysis of San Francisco's social stratification and urban growth.
Davies organizes her analysis geographically by neighborhoods that themselves reflect ethnic residential separation, or as in the case of San Francisco's Asian population, segregation. After reviewing the initial impact of the disaster, she outlines the city's political context into which a massive relief and reconstruction effort fit. Davies marks important distinctions between official and non-official, scientific and non-scientific aid, all the while making clear the enormous power ultimately accrued by the centralized, highly bureaucratic, and well-funded San Francisco Relief and Red Cross Funds, commonly referred to as the Relief Fund. This organization was administered by James Phelan, a figure who, in his career as San Francisco realtor and banker, progressive urban reformer, three-term mayor, and U.S. senator, neatly combined leading roles in business, politics, and reform. Although Davies points out a few cases of Phelan's abuse of funds and hints at a larger pattern, she does not expand further—a logical choice given her focus and limited space.
Davies pays particular attention to the role of women in the recovery period, demonstrating her nice sense of phrasing when writing that the removal of “physical boundaries between public and private property … literally pushed domestic life into public space,” especially in the long enduring relief camps housing refugees (85). Women were prominent in their roles as professional social workers, Roman Catholic nuns, middle-class volunteers aiding in establishing camp life, or as refugees struggling to earn their livings while caring for children and families. Davies argues that while “jobs seemed endless for able-bodied men” in construction and reconstruction work (119), the disaster deprived women of most of the domestic service or other paying jobs open to them. She also clearly differentiates between the experiences of the city's large Chinese community and other ethnic groups. Davies concludes with a useful discussion of San Francisco's changing urban geography, as rebuilding created “rapid decentralization and residential expansion” (122), although a deeper analysis of city neighborhoods would have been preferable to the too-rapid overview provided of outlying north and east-bay cities and counties. The maps provided to illustrate population movement are difficult to read, in contrast to the excellent supply of well-chosen and sharply reproduced photographs placed attractively throughout the book.
Davies emphasizes relief organizations’ “gender ideology” (87), as well as a housing system that “ranked refugees by class status framed as moral status” (103), to conclude that the “city that emerged after the disaster glorified industrial progress” was “framed within traditional and idealized notions of race, gender, and family” (142). Yet while gender is conceptualized in terms of “ideology,” Davies presents local challenges to San Francisco's class-based political and economic ideologies as “socialist beliefs and self-righteous anger” (79). She relegates the efforts of United Refugees, an incorporated organization of displaced San Franciscans claiming the right to influence relief policies, primarily to making “a direct run for the relief fund” (79). The essence of the Populist-oriented United Refugees program, calling for the use of relief funds to create producer, consumer, and residential co-operatives, is reduced to a “perplexing legal document [that] represented capitalist means to socialist ends” (81). This perspective is surprising, given her clear analysis of the class orientation of the Relief Fund's business leadership. Other minor problems with this book consist of a few lapses in causal logic and an occasional lack of editing. The book suffers most of all from a lack of space, with only 220 pages in which to develop argument, analysis, and demonstration and to present citations, appendices, maps, photographs, notes, and bibliography, in contrast to the most recent journalistic account of the San Francisco disaster that has the luxury of 418 pages.Footnote 2
Nonetheless, in this short space Davies does an excellent job of teasing out the complexities of the post-disaster city while maintaining her focus on San Franciscans themselves in all their diversity. In her epilogue she presents the voices of city residents as they remember choosing in just a few seconds what household artifact they could save from destruction. Davies skillfully uses these disaster remnants to return the focus to the important spatial dynamic in her analysis, the “symbiotic relationship between geography and identity” (145), that constitutes perhaps this book's most important contribution and points the way for future research.
