In June 1887, a reporter for the Era commented on the crowd assembled to see a young American actress in her professional debut. “Pluck,” the author commented, “especially in the gentler sex, is ever the most popular of virtues, a popularity which will of itself suffice to account for the numerous and brilliant crowd which was assembled to do honour to Mrs. Brown-Potter at the Gaiety…” (26). In this brief comment, the journalist isolates and exemplifies the struggle that would make Cora Urquhart Potter such a fascinating figure: she was a determined and ambitious woman whose quest for artistic and personal fulfillment fascinated theatregoers and clashed against the polite constraints imposed upon the “gentler sex.” In Cora Urquhart Potter: The Victorian Actress as Provocateur, Craig Clinton recounts the two-decade career of the titular socialite-turned-actress and argues that her steadfast determination to pursue both her own artistic path and personal independence represented a conscious challenge to Victorian mores that both reflected and advanced the ascendance of the New Woman.
On one level, Cora Urquhart Potter operates as a detailed professional biography that reclaims a largely forgotten icon of U.S. theatre history. Although Potter enjoyed significant fame—or notoriety—during her own time, there has been relatively little attention paid to her in modern scholarship, and this is the first biography to examine the actress and her work. Rather than limiting his work to a straightforward biography, however, Clinton argues that Potter's transgressive drive for self-realization, her public advocacy for female independence, and her rejection of polite, middle-class notions of female respectability worked in concert with her fame and visibility to make her a noteworthy agent and example of New Womanhood in the late Victorian era, and an early vanguard of the emergent feminist movement. In this regard, Clinton presents his work as a cultural history that is best viewed alongside other works that examine the role of actresses in late Victorian culture. Clinton draws on both Tracy Davis's Actresses as Working Women and Susan A. Glenn's Female Spectacle to articulate his methodology, and these works can be aptly taken as his scholarly antecedents. This project has a smaller scope—Clinton looks at the career of a single actress as a case study rather than undertaking a broader cultural history of female performers—but his focused examination of a single career provides both a fresh entrée into the discussion as well as an enjoyable examination of a fascinating and controversial public figure. Potter's determined rejection of married life and the polite mores of New York's high society in her pursuit of artistic and personal independence, furthermore, makes her a particularly apt subject for a study of the tension between the New Womanhood and the Victorian world in which it emerged. Focusing on just this dichotomy, Cora Urquhart Potter is a welcome contribution to the study of women's experiences in this dynamic period.
The most engaging moments in this biography are those in which Clinton describes Potter as a rebellious individualist at odds with a culture that confined affluent women to respectable invisibility. To achieve this line of inquiry, Clinton focuses heavily on the critical reception of Potter's performances, interweaving descriptions of her professional achievements with anecdotes reflecting her personal insistence on self-sufficiency and autonomy. Chapter 2, which describes the familial conflicts and critical reception surrounding Potter's 1887 professional debut, stands out in this regard, and establishes the conflicted relationship with polite society that would dog Potter throughout her lengthy career.
In most chapters, Clinton organizes his argument around a particular theatrical season or tour. In doing so, he is able to describe in significant detail a significant number of the plays in which Potter performed and the critical reception they engendered. Although at times the repetition of this structure can begin to seem formulaic, it nonetheless allows Clinton to draw enlightening connections among Potter's theatrical choices, her personal quest for autonomy, and the artistic and social concerns that shaped the often vitriolic responses to her work. In Chapter 4, for example, Clinton contextualizes the critical response to Potter's performance in a new adaptation of Antony and Cleopatra with a description of the period's conventionally sanitized adaptation practices. He thereby makes a compelling argument that it was Potter and her male costar's refusal to conform to idealized gender norms and the unapologetic sexuality of their performances, rather than the quality of their work, that engendered the largely negative response. Similarly, in Chapter 6, Clinton discusses the reception of Potter's performance in Thérèse Raquin, and suggests that the negative critical responses to this piece can be attributed both to her adoption of avant-garde acting techniques that critics were slow to accept, and to her interpretation's “eye-for-an-eye” approach to marital infidelity that promoted a female sexual equality shocking to her straitlaced contemporaries. Through this series of analytical vignettes embedded in a chronological narrative of Potter's life and career, Clinton organically advances his argument that Potter's visibility and her unwavering quest for independence—financially, personally, and artistically—made her iconic of New Womanhood and the emerging feminist movement.
